Pages

Thursday, June 21, 2012

Islam ‘Supremacism’: A By-Product of the Flawed Doctrine of Political Islam, Islamic Ideology, NewAgeIslam.com

Islamic Ideology
Islam ‘Supremacism’: A By-Product of the Flawed Doctrine of Political Islam
By Maulana Waris Mazhari

What exactly does this verse mean when it talks about establishing the supremacy of Islam over other religions? Numerous ulema, including leading Quranic commentators, have interpreted this verse in different ways. The vast majority of the ulema regard the Arabic word izhar that is used in the sense of ‘prevail’ in this verse (which is translated as ghalba in Urdu) to mean the establishment of the intellectual superiority of Islam over other religions because, being in accordance with reason and providing sufficient arguments for its claims, Islam is indeed superior to them. In his al-Jami‘ al-Ahkam al-Quran, the noted classical Islamic scholar Imam Abu Abdullaj Qurtubi comments on the word izhar used in this verse as follows:

‘To prevail means to establish [Islam’s] superiority through proofs and evidence.’

In contrast, some scholars have taken the above-quoted Quranic verse as indicating the establishment of the superiority of, or domination by, Islam on the political plane at the global level, but they argue that this will happen only at the hands of Jesus when he returns to the world again, just before the Day of Judgment. This was the opinion of Abu Hurairah, a noted companion of the Prophet and narrator of numerous Hadith reports, and is mentioned in most of the important Quranic commentaries.

http://newageislam.com/islam-supremacism--a-by-product-of-the-flawed-doctrine-of-political-islam/islamic-ideology/d/2769


0 comments: