Pages

Monday, April 25, 2022

Muslims Need To Introspect Why So Many Muslims Are Leaving Islam And Proudly Declaring Themselves Apostate

By Sumit Paul, New Age Islam 25 April 2022 Is it not a puzzling thing for a non-Muslim to know that 6.7 million Pakistanis are addicted to drugs (heroin, marijuana, amphetamine etc.) but not to alcohol? Because alcohol is forbidden, but not drugs in the Islamic scriptures. Though all man-made faiths are scripture-driven, Islam is particularly stubborn and completely unyielding on this count. What's written in the Quran and Hadees, must be followed in Toto is a typical mentality that almost all Muslims possess. A couple of years ago in London, I was having dinner with an Oxford-educated ex-Muslim, whose highly educated parents migrated from Sargodha, (Punjab province in Pakistan) and settled in England. I asked him the reason why he left Islam and turned a Murtad (Arabic for an apostate). He told me that when his parents insisted that his (that ex-Muslim's) child must undergo Khatna (circumcision), he resisted and thought that it was the last straw on the camel's back. He had an English wife who willy-nilly converted to Islam. The couple realized that this religious insistence would go on so long as they were in the fold of Islam because before the insistence on circumcision, both were forced to have only halal meat as Jhatka meat was strictly forbidden at home and outside as well. They resented this religious totalitarianism and decided to relinquish not just Islam but all organized faiths, created and concocted by our troglodyte ancestors. They're now atheists and vowed never to tie themselves to the apron-strings of any damn faith and god, Bhagwan or Khuda. That's inconsequential. Point is: What does Allah have to do on Roz e-Hashr (The Day of Judgement) with your circumcision, halal meat and beard if you killed or hurt your fellow humans on earth and did all sorts of knavery while alive? Aren't you cheapening your Creator by relegating Him to the level of humans who tend to judge others on the basis of exceedingly petty issues of everyday interest? That apart, if you strictly look at Islamic practices, many rituals in Islam percolated from the first and preceding Semitic faith, Judaism, though strangely, Islam and Judaism have been at loggerheads with each other right from the inception of Islam a little over 1400 years ago. Circumcision, halal (Kosher in Judaism) and abhorring pork are common practices that both the Semitic faiths share. Now you'll be surprised to know that barring the Orthodox Jews, a few Jews are not subjecting their male-offspring to circumcision. Nor are they insisting on having only Kosher meat. Though they may be few in numbers, at least the beginning has taken place, because breaking the ceiling is of paramount importance. But where's that beginning in Islam? Every Muslim child, however 'educated', 'enlightened' or 'evolved' his parents may be, has to undergo circumcision as an ancient Abrahamic practice and every Muslim will have to eat halal meat. Muslims (and followers of other faiths as well) don't understand that all ritualistic practices have their roots in geographical and circumstantial requirements of the times and climes their religion originated in bronze age. Islam and also Judaism originated from places where there was a dire scarcity of water. Smegma (a white substance) is deposited under the prepuce (foreskin), if a man cannot bathe for long and clean that part (genitals). When drinking water was barely available, bathing was a luxury in the desert. So, to nip this persistent problem of the deposition of smelly smegma in the bud, foreskin used to be removed in a crude manner, resulting in frequent deaths. Na Rahe Baans(pun intended), Na Baje Baansuri! But now when water is available everywhere and one can bathe every day even in Saudi Arabia, the place of the origin of Islam, what's the need to remove the prepuce? But humans would rather be ruined than change their hoary-old religious practices, however silly they may appear in modern times and evolving circumstances. The same can be said about Kosher and Halal. The pre-Semitic Pagans believed that blood of humans and animals carried all the impurities and curses of dead enemies. So, animals were koshered to drain out all the blood. Now, modern medical science has confirmed that meat, whether halal or Jhatka, gets hygienically edible when cooked at high temperature and washed properly. Dearth of water was again the reason for halal as washing the flesh of the butchered animal needed abundance of water. Moreover, halal doesn't have an edge over Jhatka meat in taste and cleanliness. Ergo, there's no need to put a poor animal through excruciatingly painful Dhai-Chhuri(two and a half times slitting the throat), ironically reciting Kalma, La Ilaha Illallah Mohammad Rasoolullah. Muslims across the globe need to introspect to purge their faith of antediluvian practices, customs and rituals. Lastly, though Islam prohibits alcohol, its scriptures tempt the followers with it in the heaven. Didn't an Urdu poet say, ' Jannat Ki Tahoor Bhi Aakhir Sharaab Hai/MujhKo Na Le Chalo Wahan Meri Neeyat Kharaab Hai' (After all, Tahoor, an imaginary wine available only in Jannat, is also alcohol. So, please don't take me there to test my piety). Not only that, according to the ridiculous subcontinental preachers of Islam, mostly based in Pakistan, Allah will himself serve wine to the inmates of Firdaus! If this is not blasphemy, what else is? Will any sane Muslim tell me? URL: https://newageislam.com/the-war-within-islam/muslims-introspect-apostate/d/126857 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism

Islam, Divine Action And Omniscience, Human Freedom, & Theodicy

By T.O. Shanavas, New Age Islam 25 April 2022 IN THE LIFE of devout Muslims, not a day passes without the Arabic phrase Inshah Allah (God Willing) being uttered at the end of any conversation about future events. Without a realistic understanding of the meaning of this phrase, or the purpose, structure, and workings of the universe, we cannot begin to comprehend the process of creation, God’s omniscience in harmony with human freewill, theodicy, or divine response to human supplication. Nor too can we offer a rational, internally consistent refutation of atheists’ exclusion of God in the evolution of life and the universe. Materialists among scientists posit that biological evolution is an “inherently mindless, purposeless process.”1 They presume that impersonal laws rule the universe and that atoms are at work in the workings of life. Biologist Richard Dawkins, a hardcore atheist, has upheld that contingency and natural selection, taking place over a long period of time, account for evolution. By this, Dawkins assumes that the blind forces of physics, chemistry, and natural selection are sufficient to explain the origin and expansion of life.2&3 He has sought to explicate the unfolding of life as the result of genes’ selfish desire to increase their opportunities for survival and reproduction. Similar opinions prevail among some scientists who advocate that there is no reason to include God in the evolution of life. One extremist fulminated that “materialism is absolute [and] we cannot allow a Divine Foot in the door.”4 The passionate exclusion by some scientists of God from the conversation on the origin of the universe stems from an unshakable, unwavering faith in the law of causality which most people acknowledge and which states that a given cause always produces the same effect. Gravity always pulls an apple down to the earth; snow melts in spring; drought brings the destruction of crops. Chemical reactions in any organism, amoeba or human, are explainable by the same laws of physics and chemistry that govern the universe. Based on the law of causality scientists uphold that the future is predetermined and can be predicted through accurate knowledge of past causes. The laws of nature, they argue, are invariant, and scientific observation reveals the past as the product of those laws. Any natural event that departs from the anticipated effect of a uniform cause is classified as an “accident.” However, scientists’ predictions based on their observation of matter and the invariant laws of nature are limited by their own earlier conclusions and experiences. To gather data, scientists peer into nature—from atoms to stars, amoebas to humankind, fungi to maple trees—and phenomena within our universe. Science has collected and categorized data into disciplines such as paleontology, comparative anatomy, biogeography, embryology, molecular genetics, and so on. The materialists’ claim that the unfolding of life is a “purposeless, mindless process” is based upon inferences from catalogued past experiences. John F. Haught, professor of theology at Georgetown University, labelled the materialistic rationalism based on past experiences with the phrase “the metaphysics of the past.”5 Contrary to a purposeless universe of science, Jews, Christian, Muslims, and other theists believe in there being a cosmic purpose. The Prophet Muhammad (s) explained the purpose of creation as follows: “Allah said: I was a hidden treasure. I wanted to be known, so I created the world.”6 The purpose of creation, according to the Qur’an, is: “And We did not create the heaven and the earth and that is between them aimlessly. That is the assumption of those who disbelieve, so woe unto those who disbelieve from the Fire” (38:27) and “I created the jinn and humankind only that they might worship Me” (51:56). The universe is only a testing station where humans are appraised for their devotion to their creator through their conduct on earth as per the rules of divine revelations. Testing is not possible without the examinee encountering challenges across a wide spectrum from goodness to evil. Thus, the Qur’an rhetorically questions: “Or did you suppose you should enter Paradise without God know who of you have struggled and who are patient?” (3:142); “Do people think they will not be tested because they say,‘We have faith?’ And certainly, We tried those before them, so Allah will certainly know those who are true and He will certainly know the liars” (29:2-3); “and know that your wealth and your children are a trial, and that with God is a mighty wage” (8:28); and “And We shall test you with something of fear and hunger and loss of wealth, lives and crops. Yet give good ridings to the patients” (2:155-157). Evidently, according to the Prophet (s) and the Qur’an, the purpose of human creation is to serve God, and the material world serves as the hardware to rate humans’ devotion to their creator prior to their final adjudication on the Day of Judgement. The God of Jews, Christians, and Muslims is omniscient and omnipotent and gifted free will to humans. The sacred book of Islam indirectly upholds the conscientious application of human free will: “Say, ‘Truth comes from your Lord. Let people have faith or disbelieve as they chose.’ For the unjust We have prepared a fire which will engulf them with its (flames)…” (Quran 18:29). The concurrency of divine omniscience and human free will has troubled theologians and philosophers. At least an elementary grasp of the structure, organization, and workings of the universe is essential to unravel the mystery of the consonance of God’s omniscience with human free will and to understand how God invisibly responds to human supplications without the laws of physics and chemistry. According to the Qur’an, the universe and its micro and macro components—the animate and inanimate, in human vocabulary—are alive and have an independent existence; they are organisms with faculties of self, subjectivity, and consciousness. The following verse reveal the existence of these faculties in inanimate creations such as the wind, fire, earth, galaxies, etc.: “And the thunder extols His praise, and the angels are in of awe of Him …” (Qur’an 13:13). A verse relating to Solomon reads: “So We subjected the wind to him [Solomon]; it ran softly at his command to wherever he pleased” (Qur’an 38:36). The presence of self and subjectivity in the heavens, the earth, and mountain is reflected in the following revelation: “Verily, We did offer the trust [of reason and volition] to the heavens, and the earth, and the mountains: but they refused to bear it because they were afraid of it. Yet man took it up—for, verily, he has always been prone to be most wicked, most foolish” (Qur’an 33:72). The component part of a whole has its own independent existence and its own characteristic faculties of self, subjectivity, and consciousness. This is reflected in the verse on the Day of Judgment: “their ears and their eyes and their skins will testify against them as to what they used to do. And they say unto their skins: Why ye testify against us? They say: God hath given us speech, who giveth speech to all things, and who created you at the first, onto whom ye are returned” (Qur’an 41:20-21). The verse pertaining to the beginning of creation (The Big Bang) enlightens that the elementary particles are alive with its own psyche and individuality: “Then He directed Himself to the heaven and it is a vapour, so He said to it and to the earth: Come both, willingly or unwillingly. They both said: We come willingly” (41:11). According to the last verse quoted, vapour (a plenum of elementary particles after the Big Bang) has also self and subjectivity. The self, subjectivity, and potential of the lower order of creation may be minimal or hard to detect for humans: “The seven heavens and the earth and all that is therein praise Him, and there is not a thing but hymneth His praise; but ye understand not their praise. Lo! He is ever Clement, Forgiving” (17:44). As God created higher orders of being, He carefully gifted each of them with a higher level of subjectivity and potential so that they can understand more complex messages from God and react to complex matters in the outside world. Moreover, the entire universe as one piece and its parts, for example ears and skin, have assigned duties and responsibilities. As Qur’an 41:12 states: “He assigned to each heaven its duty and command …” Thus, our incredible live universe and its individual parts act and react, give and take, reward and retribute, etc. just as a living organism. The events emerging from the activities of the live universe and its parts are caused by natural laws and are natural events for science. The universe is like a human body: it is host of hundreds of billions of bacteria, yet we assume it to be a single organism. The universe is not only a living organism but also works as a supercomputer with programs installed at its birth. Thus, the universe and its individual parts with self, subjectivity, and consciousness know what they can and cannot do and what God wants them to do. Every situation, circumstance, or ambiance that a human faces in life emerges from the self-driven independent or collective actions, reactions, and interactions of the components of the entire universe based on its gifted potential. The universe is an all-in-one perfect machine, a computerized organism that is automatized to perform its duties and functions without constant monitoring and intervention by its designer. God is perfect, and His process of creation and its products are impeccable, so that whatever He created has the potentiality to do whatever He intended it to execute. A perfect machine functions by itself without its inventor’s intervention; only then is a product optimally perfect. The Qur’an vouches for this: “Who has created the seven heavens one above another, you can see no fault in the creations of the Most Beneficent. Then look again: ‘Can you see any rifts?’” (67:3) and “[such is] the artistry of Allah, who disposes of all things in perfect order: for he is well acquainted with all that ye do” (27:88). God created an automatized universe with mind-blogging precision so that it would carry out all its duties and operate without constant divine supervision to function as a testing station. God programmed the universe to self-generate its future between the Big Bang (the beginning of universe) and the Big Crunch (the end of the universe). Within the divinely installed program, the circumstances, situations, environments, and ambiance emerge from the independent actions, interactions, and reactions of individual components or many components together. God, being the programmer, knows about the potential of every component—every circumstance, situation, environment, and ambiance that would emerge from all activities. The automatized universe is programmed with the potential to run zillions of event trains and zillions of crossing junctions from zillions of chosen actions of micro and macro components of the universe. God created a network of interconnected roads, highways, and byways of the future between the Big Bang and the Big Crunch. God knows what everything created can do and cannot do in any given circumstance or situation. God does not intrude into the operations of the universe and its components. For humans, God has given guidance though prophets for the preferred choice of action in every situation and the actions that to be avoided. Humans are appraised based on their chosen response to situations emerging from the activities and interactions of the entire world of creation. There is wisdom behind the creation of this automatized live universe with self and subjectivity. God with His indefinite generosity divested to the universe and its components the task of producing future situations and circumstances for humans to manage or resolve. God becomes the best judge of all judges—“Is not Allah the most just of judges?” (Qur’an 95:8)—by divine self-divestiture so that no human can implicate God for their sin. The Qur’an states plainly that “Indeed, Allah does not wrong people in the least, but it is people who wrong themselves” (10:44). The conceptualization of the universe as a flawless, autonomous, computerized, and perfect organism with the faculty of self, subjectivity, and consciousness lays the framework for the consonance of divine omniscience and human free will. The interplay of the activities of the universe and its components creates both good and evil situations. What God created was the potentiality for the emergence of good and evil from the activities of the entire world of creation. The perfect automatized live universe vindicates the divine goodness and providence in view of the existence of evil (theodicy) because the emergence of evil results from the interplay of the components of the universe. Christian theologian and biochemist Arthur Peacocke described the universe as an unfinished movie wherein actors (God’s creatures, including humans) in their individual hierarchical ranks freely choose their roles in the emerging scenarios from the interplay of other components of the universe. Chance and unpredictability are inevitable and are, in fact, built into such a scenario. The Sufi poet Jalaluddin Rumi described this universe as a battlefield where atom struggles with atom such as faith against infidelity. In this struggle, some benefit and others suffer. Unlike “the metaphysics of the past” (the past creating the future) of science, God “creates everything” (Qur’an). In the framework of the universe at its onset, God introduced in the potential to materialize a thing or an event through the acts of humans and other components of the universe. So, without the potential nothing could be actualized. Thus, God is the creator of everything. In the Islamic context, time is a conveyor belt. The experienced past is irretrievable, while the present is only a fleeting moment that we cannot hold on to. On the other hand, we experience the continuous coming of the future. The future in the material world does not exist until it is created by the actions, interactions, and reactions of an entire world of creation. The Islamic creed regarding the coming of future events is grounded in the phrase Insha Allah and the verse “And never say about anything, ‘Behold, I shall do this tomorrow,’ without [adding] ‘if God so wills’” (Qur’an 18:23). Muslims say Insha Allah after every statement pertaining to the future, even for simple tasks such as meeting a friend at 4 p.m. tomorrow. The future is not simply born without cause. Future, for humans, is unpredictable and emerges from the activity of an entire world of creation or one of its creations. The emerging future circumstances, situations, conditions, scenes, events, dilemmas, predicaments, crises, etc. are where humans are challenged and probed for their submission to God. The divine messages demand that humans act morally, ethically, justly, and compassionately in every situation that they face with every arriving moment of the future. Thus, God judges humans based upon their logical, ethical, just, exemplary, compassionate, and truthful management of emerging situations/events, or otherwise. To label the above exposition of verse 18:23, we shall borrow John F. Haught’s phrase the “metaphysics of the future”5 and modify it to read the “Islamic metaphysics of the future.” An unfortunate and horrendous event in Muslim history would explain the concept of the coming future through choices. Events following the Prophethood of Muhammad (s) presented a choice for Hind bint Utba, one of the foremost enemies of the Prophet (s), to join the distinguished companions of the Prophet (s) such as Humza, Ummer, etc. She decided to actualize the bad choice of cannibalizing Hamzah. She will be judged based on her action. For those who do not comprehend the concept of the metaphysics of the future and the automatized universe, a good illustration is that of a computer game. When the programmer sets up the parameters of a game, he/she gives the players multiple options for each moment of play. The players are responsible for the outcome of each move that they make, no matter whether the choice is right or wrong. The programmer knows what the result of each choice can be, and what must be done to complete the game. Moreover, a good programmer will include events that are outside the direct control of the players. Thus, God is the ultimate source of all that occurs, since God created and programmed the universe. This does not preclude us from having real and meaningful choices in our lives. God, being the creator and the programmer of the universe, knows anything and everything within it and what will happen for every action as well as its reaction, and this is truly what is meant by Qdar of Allah (the concept of divine destiny in Islam). For some, libertarianism is incompatible with the sovereignty of God. Of course, God can dictate every action and decision of everything in creation if He chooses so. God can also make the opposite choice of abstaining from enforcing His absolute power, leaving the ultimate decision to humans and other creatures. In mandatory daily prayers, Muslims recite the opening chapter of the Quran, al-Fatihah. “Guide us (O Lord) to the path that is straight, the path of those You have blessed, not of those who have earned Your anger, nor of those who have gone astray.” These verses imply to many Muslim and non-Muslim minds that God does lead some of us astray. Based upon the Islamic metaphysics of the future, educed from the verse 18:23 (Qur’an), God is the source of all potential possibilities and choices in the coming future. When humans and other creatures transcribe the selected option into visible material realty, it becomes the worldly monument of divine creation. God does not intrude into the human process of selection from the available options of the coming future. Therefore, based upon the Islamic metaphysics of the future, the phrases “God misled” and “God guided” refer to the good and bad choices in the coming future emerging from the activities of components of the universe. According to the Qur’an, God will answer our prayers: “‘Call upon Me and I will answer you...’” (40:60). How does God respond to prayer without violating the laws of nature? Based on the following verse, God demands that humans explore and discover His process of original creation and later creation in response to human supplications: “Say [Muhammad to your people]: ‘Travel through the earth and see how Allah did originate creation; so will Allah produce a later creation: for Allah has power over all things” (Quran: 29:20). If it is humanly inconceivable to discover and explain God’s process of creation, all-knowing God would not have decreed to research and learn “how Allah did originate creation … will produce a later creation.” Moreover, the verse voices that all tools are necessary to learn the process of creation available on the earth (“travel through the earth and see how …”). Although Almighty God’s means to act is infinite, based on the above verse, whatever method God applies to respond to supplications is discoverable by humans. Modern theologians and scholars of science and religion have been contemplating how to understand God’s action in the world. The mystery of the divine process of creation is buried in the structure, organization, and operation of universe, and specifically in the quantum mechanical process. Classical physics and chemistry, the collection of theories that existed before the advent of quantum theory, describe the nature at an ordinary (macroscopic) scale. But classical physics and chemistry alone are not sufficient for describing the nature at small (atomic and subatomic) scale. Thus, Max Plank initially explained the photoelectric effect (old quantum theory), and later Neil Bohr, Erwin Schrodinger, Werner Heisenberg, and Max Born advanced into fully developed quantum theory or quantum mechanics. The fundamental feature of the theory is that humans cannot predict with certainty what will happen at the atomic and subatomic level, but they only can give probabilities or averages. According to quantum theory, the behaviour of matter at atomic and subatomic level is unpredictable. No one can say, for example, that a particle was in a specific position in the past or that it will occupy a specific place at some time in the future. Physicist Paul Davis explained it that “A particle such as an electron does not appear to follow a meaningful, well-defined trajectory at all. One moment it is found here, the next there. Not only electron but also all known subatomic particles—even whole atom-- cannot be pinned down to a specific motion.”7 The more accurately we measure the momentum of a particle, the less we can calculate its position. The more we know about the particle’s position, the less we can say about its momentum. Our partial information about the position of a particle only yields the probability that it is within a certain distance of a particular point. The most famous part of the uncertainty principle states that no matter how a quantum particle is prepared or an experiment upon it arranged, it is impossible to precisely predict its position and at the same time its momentum. For example, it is not possible to predict when a radioactive atom will decay. In a uranium (238U) sample, the sudden decay of a specific atom into thorium (234Th) through the emission of alpha particles can only be computed as a probable occurrence. We are unable to explain why a particular uranium sample has decayed while another identical uranium atom next to it has not. We may calculate a certain chance that the decay will take place within the next ten seconds. The probability exists that the remaining atoms may decay over a period of ten thousand years. But no one can give a definite answer regarding the sequence and time of decay.8 If no one can ascertain what is occurring with atoms and subatomic particles—the basic building blocks of the universe and all DNA-based life—how can it be possible to precisely predict the future of human beings or anything else in the universe? This scientific paradox of unpredictability in quantum theory bothered even Einstein, who said: “God does not play dice.” Niels Bohr responded by saying: “Einstein, stop telling God what to do?”9 There is a reason for God to create matter that is not precisely predictable at the atomic and subatomic level. God did not want to place all of His creation in the same spiritual reality. Therefore, He created matter to be the building block of the universe and governed its macro level operation through an immutable system of physical and chemical laws within which it functions in unpredictable ways. With the installation of stubborn chemical and physical laws to function in a uniform and repetitive fashion at the level of larger components of the universe, God made the larger components of the universe comprehensible to the minds of humans, the best of His creations, so that they could build the things that are needed for daily life. God did not intend the same laws of classical physics and chemistry to work as a programmed machine all the way down to the atomic and subatomic levels. By doing so, God answers human supplications with macro level visible responses by generating small fluctuations (jump of a quantum of energy) in the quantum mechanical process.10 In this way, God’s response to His faithful will be invisible to atheists, while the faithful are thankful for their divine gift. Quantum theory gave birth to a new chemistry that explained how atoms are bonded together to form molecules. When two atoms that are initially separated are brought together in a chemical reaction, the electrons in their outermost shell (electrons the farthest from the nucleus) share one orbit. Such sharing in a chemical reaction is called a covalent bond (Figure 1). In covalent bonding, atoms share electrons to form all molecules, including ordinary substances such as water, methane, and so forth. In some cases, covalent bonding can lead to the formation of huge, extended macromolecules such as polymers. One example of such a polymer is deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA), the basic building block of life. Figure 1. FORMATION OF A COVALENT BOND The formation and maintenance of the structure of compounds such as DNA is ultimately the result of a quantum mechanical process in which the behaviour of atoms remains predictable only as a statistical average. Each thought and movement of all life forms remains inseparably connected to electricity and chemistry, and ultimately to unpredictable quantum events as well. If the behaviour of matter and formation of compounds is absolutely unpredictable, can the future of any creature be precisely predictable? The reply of quantum physics is a resounding “no,” because every DNA-based creature is only a mosaic made of atoms in chemical form. The best calculations that modern science can offer are only the averaged probabilities of thousands of quantum events. Chemists have discovered that all components of the physical universe, including genes, are made of atoms arranged in different fashions. Genes are made of DNA. DNA is a collection of nucleotides. Phosphate, sugar, and four amino acids (thymine, cytosine, adenine, guanine) are chemically connected with covalent chemical bonds to form nucleotides. A genetic mutation can produce a major effect on the outward physical features of an organism. Alternatively, a mutation may lead to disease such cancer, and reverse mutation can cure the disease. Mutations depend on changes in individual molecules due to the breaking of specific atomic covalent bonds that involve quantum mechanical processes. The physicist-theologian Robert J. Russell pointed out that “this is ultimately a quantum process at the atomic level initiated by the breaking of a single hydrogen bond.”11 In other words, God built life around the chemistry that provides “the amplifying mechanism for quantum events.”12 The physicist William Pollard remarked that if chemistry is the physical appearance of an organism (phenotype), the quantum fluctuation is the driving cause (genotype). When God prompts a small quantum fluctuation (jump of a quantum of energy) in the atomic or subatomic world to make or break a gene’s covalent chemical bond or bonds, materialists may see a mutation, the accidental birth of a species, or an unexplained cure for an incurable disease. For atheists, it is only a random or accidental event with no known cause. For the faithful, however, the unexplained resolution of his/her suffering from the divine act in the quantum mechanical process is God’s acknowledgement of his/her prayer. This construction of understandable chemistry coupled with unpredictable quantum physics is the ingenious, intelligent design of the all-knowing and all-powerful God. In such a design of the universe, God has the freedom to create any being or substance, living or nonliving, without disturbing any laws of classical physics and chemistry through quantum events in the atomic world. In this material universe, therefore, God does play dice between the Big Bang and the Big Crunch at atomic and subatomic level by sending messenger moments of the future containing His proposals to His creatures. The indeterminism at atomic level (quantum mechanical process) is the intrinsic characteristic of our material universe. Everything or anything that we experience through our five senses is the amplification of the imperceptible quantum mechanical process. Therefore, God, by acting at the indeterminate quantum mechanical process, can transparently respond to prayers without violating any classical laws of physics and chemistry. Another characteristic of the world that we live in is the amazing harmony of our free will with the omniscience of the Almighty. Human experiences are linked to time and space. In order to integrate God’s omniscience with human experiences of the past, the present, and the future, God created time with an elastic property. God enlightened us on this relative characteristic of time centuries before Albert Einstein did (“but lo! A day is like one thousand years of what you reckon” Qur’an 22:47; “On a Day when He will call you, and you will answer by praising Him, thinking all the while that you tarried (on earth) but a little while” (Qur’an 17:52)). Thus, time can shrink to a freezing halt, as in the case of God, or expand for the rest of creation, depending on its space, speed of motion, gravity, etc. Hence, human experience of yesterday, today, and tomorrow is a concurrent event for God, who is outside time and space. Therefore, in this automatized universe, there is freedom, free will, and randomness for the human species without infringement on God’s omniscience. The universe from the Big Bang to the Big Crunch is maze. At both ends, all matter and forces (gravity, electromagnetism, strong and weak forces) are crushed into a mathematical point known as singularity. The maze is fabricated out of alleys, roads, highways, and byways that lead to different futures for the universe until it meets the Big Crunch (the Last Day, or end of the universe; see Figure 1). God already mapped out (created) multiple futures for the components of the universe. But it is still up to humans and other components of the universe—day by day or moment by moment—to decide for themselves which alley or road to step into. God the merciful does not interfere or force humans into making the choice. God voluntarily limits His absolute omnipotence, as stated in the Qur’an: “And had your Lord willed, whoever in the earth would have believed altogether. Will you then coerce the people to become believers?” (10:99). God knows that human free will would be non-existent without voluntary limitation of His omniscience. Therefore, al-Rahman (the most beneficent) and al-Rahim (the most merciful) set a voluntary limitation of His omniscience as reflected in the verse. The self-imposed limitation being voluntary, it does not imply any inherent limitation in God’s ultimate power and omniscience. At the same time, humans are free to choose their future, but a human future is limited by a predetermined maze and the situations and circumstances emerging from the activity of the entire world of creation. In other words, God knows all available futures, and God, being the most merciful and most benevolent, has voluntarily opted not to know which future path His creatures would choose to step into until after His creatures choice is actualized. 1. Barbour, Ian G. Religion and Science. New York: HarperCollins, 1997. p. 81. 2. Dawkins, Richard. The Blind Watchmaker. New York: W.W. Norton, 1986. 3. Dawkins, Richard. River out of Eden. New York: Basic Books, 1995. 4. From Richard Lewontin’s review of Carl Sagan’s book, The Demon & Haunted World: Science as a Cradle in the Dark, in the New York Review of Books, January 9, 1997. 5 Haught, John F. God After Darwin. Boulder: Westview Press, 1999, pp. 83-88. 6. Nasr, Seyyed H. Islamic Spirituality Foundation. New York: The Crossroad Publishing Company, 1991. 7. Davis, Paul. God and the New Physics, pp 101-102. 8. Russell, Robert J. “Special Providence and Genetic Mutation: A New Defense of Theistic Evolution,” Evolutionary and Molecular Biology, p. 202. 9. https://tildesites.bowdoin.edu/~naculich/3140scans/dice.pdf 10. Alston, P. William. Divine Action, Human Freedom, And The Laws of Nature. Quantum Cosmology And The Laws of Nature, Scientific Perspectives on Human Action. Robert John Russell, Nancy Murphy, and C.J. Ishan. Editors. 1999. 11. Russell, Robert J. “Theistic Evolution: Does God really Act in Nature?” Center for Theology and the Natural Science Bulletin, 15.1, 1995. 12. Miller, Kenneth. Finding Darwin’s God. New York: HarperCollins Publishers Inc., 1999 p. 206. URL: https://newageislam.com/islamic-ideology/divine-action-omniscience-human-freedom-theodicy/d/126859 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism

Understanding Maulana Azad’s Idea of Theological Pluralism in Indian Islam and his Concept of ‘Unity of Religion’ (Wahdat-e-Deen)!

By Ghulam Rasool Dehlvi, New Age Islam Main Points: 1. Azad formed the bedrock of Islamic pluralism in context of a multicultural, multilingual, and multi-religious India. 2. Not many know Maulana Abul Kalam Azad as a ‘pluralist theologian’ and as an inclusivist exegete of the Qur’an. 3. Azad’s epistemology of Usu’l al-Deen (genealogies of the religion) and his engagement with the Qur’anic hermeneutics have been disregarded by most of the traditionalist Ulema. 4. Azad’s idea of theological pluralism focuses on Wahdat-e-Deen (Unity of the Religion) without rejecting the essential messages and universal values of the non-Semitic, Semitic and Christo-Judaic faith traditions. 5. In colonial India which was rocked by communal violence and in that background Azad’s concept of Wahdat-e-Deen was greatly helpful. 6. The two most important results of Azad’s pluralist theological underpinnings were (1) his vehement opposition to the two-nation theory, and (2) his avid advocacy for national integration and unity among Muslims and non-Muslims in post-partition India Maulana Azad ------- From his early writings in Nairang-i-e- Ālam (Deception of the World) and thereafter in his own paper Lisān-us-Ṣidq (The Speech of Truth), and his publications of al-Hilāl and al-Balaagh, to his autobiography titled as Ghubār-iKhāṭir (The Accumulated Dust of the Conscience), and his exegesis of the Qur’an—Tarjuman-ul-Qur'an, Maulana Abul Kalam Azad formed the bedrock of theological pluralism in Indian Islamic tradition in the early 20th century in context of a multicultural, multilingual, and multi-religious India. Not many know Maulana Abul Kalam Azad as a ‘pluralist theologian’ and as an inclusivist commentator or exegete of the Qur’an. He is popularly known to us merely as a Muslim freedom fighter and the first education minister of India. But a few Islamic scholars like Asghar Ali Engineer sought to explore Azad’s theological work. When Engineer closely studied Azad’s marvellous commentary on the Qur’an titled as Tarjuman-ul-Qur’an (interpreter of the Qur’an), he called him a ‘socio-theologian’ because of Maulana’s deep insights into socio-cultural complexities of the country. However, Azad’s strong epistemology of Usu’l al-Deen (genealogies of the religion) and his deep engagement with the Qur’anic hermeneutics have been largely ignored. Most of the traditionalist Ulema, inadvertently or knowingly, overlooked his insightful commentary on the Qur’an. They barely touched upon Azad’s creative theological and hermeneutical underpinnings. Before we proceed to the main discussion, let’s keep in view that Azad was a fervent nationalist and an ardent follower of Islam at the same time. He took great pride in both of his assets; his firm faith in Islam as the ultimate religion and his unshakable loyalty to India as his Motherland. In his 1940 Presidential Address to the plenary session of the Indian National Congress, he made it patently clear: “I am a Muslim and profoundly conscious of the fact that I have inherited Islam’s glorious traditions of the last 13 hundred years. I am not prepared to lose even a small part of that legacy…I am equally proud of the fact that I am an Indian, an essential part of the invisible unity of Indian nationhood, a vital factor in its total make-up without which its noble edifice will remain incomplete. I can never give up this sincere claim. It was India’s historic destiny that its soil should become the destination of many different caravans of races, cultures and religions. Even before the dawn of history’s morning, they started their trek into India and since then, the process has continued.” Now the reason why I look up to Maulana Azad as a ‘pluralist theologian’ is his great emphasis on the concept of Wahdat-e-Deen (unity of religion). This has been given paramount importance in his theological epistemology and Qur’anic hermeneutics. All religions, according to Azad, are spiritual paths to eternal salvation, and are pervaded by the same spirit of truth, while the differences and apparent dichotomies in their theological realms do not influence the essentials of religion. The outward way (shari'a or minhaj) differ, depending on the historical and territorial circumstances. Therefore, Azad’s idea of pluralism focuses on Wahdat-e-Deen without rejecting the essential messages and universal values of world religions—including the Semitic religions and Christo-Judaic traditions as well as the non-Semitic religions such as Hinduism, Buddhism and Jainism. Although this is debatable whether Azad’s proposition of Wahdat-e-Deen can be conflated with Wahdat-e-Adyan (unity of all religions) or not, his intent behind this scholarly adventure was crystal clear. He sought to reduce communal conflicts between the adherents of two diametrically different religions in India—Islam and Hinduism. Thus, Azad emerged as the major proponent of pluralism among the Indian Ulema, who were vehemently opposed to the idea of theological pluralism in Islam. However, Azad’s pluralist tendencies and inclusivist thought and practice are lesser known to the public. It should have been well preserved at least in the intellectual memory. Born to a Qadri-Naqshbandi Sufi scholar, Maulana Khairuddin Dehlvi, Abul Kalam Azad was imbued with a mystically inclined Islamic tradition at a very early age. Therefore, he began to think and contemplate over the essential truths of all religions. His mystical pluralistic inclinations stemmed from a broader notion of Wahdat-e-Deen (Unity of the Faith) well-embedded in the Islamic tradition. In fact, his deep faith in the religious pluralism and oneness of mankind was based on the popular Sufi doctrine of Wahdatul Wujud(Unity of the Existence). This is further reinforced by Azad’s idea of God, as "cherisher" and "nourisher" of all worlds (Rabb Al-'Alameen) as enunciated in the first chapter of the Qur’an, Surah Al-Fatiha. This concept of divinity transcends all fragmentations and divides among God’s best creation—mankind—in terms of race, colour, and creed and ethnicity, according to the findings and writings of Azad. Asghar Ali Engineer gives us a very convincing and candid explanation of the background in which Maulana Azad forms the concept of Wahdat-e-Din. He notes: “Not that this was unknown before [Azad] as Shah Waliyullah too refers to the concept of unity of religion in his Hujjat-u-Allah al-Balighah. Many Sufi saints like Hazrat Nizamuddin Awliya and Mazhar Jan-i-Janan also refer to truth of other religions like Hinduism, particularly in Indian context. However, Maulana’s work on this is much more significant for number of reasons. His arguments are based not only on the verses of the Qur’an but also on his extensive knowledge of other religions like Hinduism, Judaism, Christianity, Buddhism, Jainism and even Zoroastrianism. He very systematically argues both from Qur’anic perspective as well as on the basis of teachings of these religions and tries to validate the concept of Wahdat-i-din”. He further says: “Azad was writing in colonial India which was rocked by communal violence and in that background Maulana’s concept of Wahdat-e-Deen became much more important. Those talking of two nations both from amongst Hindus as well as Muslims were emphasizing irreconcilability of two religions i.e., Hinduism and Islam. And Maulana refers to basic teachings of Islam and Hinduism and contradicts the approach of those who found two religions non-reconcilable. It was really great contribution for the cause of unity of Hindus and Muslims and common nationhood”. Thus, it should now become a common knowledge that Maulana Azad’s focus on Wahdat-e-Deen(unity of religion) was primarily aimed at highlighting the essential and egalitarian messages of all religions as a uniting factor for Muslims and non-Muslims living in the colonial India. However, his theological position on Wahdat-e-Deen (unity of religion) was based on solid foundations and hence he was uncompromising on the basic Islamic postulates, as he categorically and unequivocally states in his famous commentary, Tarjuman-al-Quran. He writes: “Wahdat-e-Deen is the central idea, but this does not mean that all historical religions as they exist today are true or that there is truth in every religion. Rather, the case is that all religions as originally delivered are true”. But at the same time, in his endeavours to ideate and establish his concept of Wahdat-e-Deen, Azad has brainstormed novel ideas which were not familiar in his times in the Indian Islamic scholarship. As a well-established classical Islamic thinker, Azad emerged as the first and foremost pluralist theologian in India who propounded a unique synthesis of Islamic humanism and universal humanity based on his concepts of Wahdat-e-Deen(unity of religion), Wahdat-e-Khudawandi(unity of God) and Ukhuwat-E-Insani(brotherhood of mankind). His commentary on the first chapter of the Qur’an, Surah Al-Fatihah very particularly promotes theological pluralism and scriptural dialogue, an idea which can be deduced from his broader notion of Wahdat-e-Deen, which not only implies the unity of God and unity of religion, but actually religious unity per se. He writes in Tarjumān Al-Qur’ān: “Although religions walk and talk separately, their destination is one. The unity of [humankind] is the primary aim of religion. The message which every prophet delivered was that [humankind] were in reality one people and the one community, and there was but one God for all of them, and on that account, they should serve [God] together and live as members of but one family. Such was the message which every religion delivered”. This is further reinforced by Azad’s idea of Allah as "cherisher" and "nourisher" of all worlds (rabb al-'alameen) as enunciated in Surah Al-Fatiha. This concept of divinity transcends all fragmentations and divides among God’s best creation—mankind—in terms of race, colour, and creed and ethnicity, according to the findings and writings of Azad. According to Azad, all religions in terms of Deen are pervaded by the same spirit of truth, while the differences and apparent dichotomies in their theological realms do not influence the essentials of religion. The outward way (Shari’a or Minhaj) differs depending on the historical and territorial circumstances. Thus, Azad’s idea of pluralism focused on Wahdat-e-Deen doesn’t do away with the essential messages and universal values of world religions—including the Semitic and Christo-Judaic traditions as well as the non-Semitic religions and Aryan traditions such as Hinduism, Buddhism and Jainism. In fact, Maulana’s deep faith in religious pluralism and oneness of mankind was also inspired by the popular Sufi doctrine of Wahdatul Wujud(Unity of the Existence). The proponent of Wahdatul Wajud, Sheikh Mohiuddin Ibn al-Arabi has lucidly explained the idea of religious pluralism in his celebrated poetic work in Arabic, Tarjuman al-Ashwaq (translator of the desires). Ibn al-Arabi opens the doors for salvation and divine mercy for not just Muslims but also believers of God in various other ways. In a theological synergy with Ibn al-Arabi’s Tarjuman al-Ashwaq, Maulana Azad’s Tarjuman al-Qur’an, a celebrated exegetic work that he left incomplete, exhibits beautifully novel ideas on salvation. For instance, Maulana Azad writes in his explanation of the famous Qur’anic verses 45:27-29: “Despite the theological positions diametrically different from Islam, the Qur’an does suggest that there is hope for the salvation of Jews and Christians on the Last Day. Distinct communities will be judged according to “their own book” [Qur’an 45:27-29] and: “Those who believe [in the Qur’an], and those who follow the Jewish, and the Christians, and the Sabians, any who believe in God and the Last Day, and work righteousness, shall have their reward with their Lord, on them shall be no fear, nor shall they grieve” (Qur’an 2:62). But despite a flowing literary style in Urdu language, Azad’s Qur’anic exegeses could not win the hearts of many Muslim clergymen of his times, even of those who otherwise greatly liked him or his other masterpieces. For, Maulana, in his explanations of several Qur’anic verses, attempted to find common grounds between Islam and other religions. This was something that a great number of Muslim clergy could not put up with. Prominent scholar of Islam and comparative religion, Professor Imadul Hasan Azad Faruqi (former director, Centre for the Study of Comparative Religions and Civilizations, Jamia Millia Islamia) did a critical analysis of Maulana Azad’s approach to the understanding of the holy Qur’an. He says that Maulana’s pluralistic and inclusive interpretation of the above Qur’anic verses could not appeal to a large number of Muslim Ulema in India, whose minds are well-permeated with exclusivist and supremacist religious indoctrination. But Azad was a critical-traditionalist. While he was loyal to the intellectual Muslim tradition, he was at the same time, reluctant to be a blind follower and thus he shunned Taqleed-e-Jamid (uncreative adherence to the Islamic tradition). He rather carried out an interpretation of Islamic tradition which was robust and vibrant, not conventional. His independent re-thinking of the Qur’anic trajectories was supported by both spirituality and rationality. He greatly emphasized the need to adopt a critical posture towards tradition. For instance— in Ghubar-i-Khatir, Azad is critical to the ‘suffocating narrow-mindedness of theological literacy’, while at the same time highlighting the power of tradition. The two most important results of Maulana Azad’s pluralist theological ideas were (1) his vehement opposition to the two-nation theory (Do Qaumi Nazarya) which was promoted and theologically endorsed by the majority of traditionalist Ulema in India before the partition, and (2) his avid support to the national integration and unity among Muslims and non-Muslims in post-partition India. Azad despite being a classical Islamic scholar attached to his tradition, stood for the composite nationalism and Hindu-Muslim unity. His stand was so antithetical to the two-nation theory that, in one of his speeches, he spoke with a great conviction: “I have considered the scheme of Pakistan as formulated by the Muslim League from every possible point of view. As an Indian, I have examined its implications for the future of India as a whole. As a Muslim I have examined its likely adverse effects upon the fortunes of Muslims of India” (India Wins Freedom, Maulana Abul Kalam Azad, Maulana Azad’s statement on Muslim issues in India, April 15, 1946). URL: https://newageislam.com/islamic-personalities/maulana-azad-theological-pluralism-wahdat-e-deen/d/126858 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism

Sultan Shahin's Open Letter To Al-Qaida Chief Ayman Al-Zawahiri: Your Pathetic Braying Is Not Going To Have Any Impact On Indian Muslims

By Sultan Shahin, Founding Editor, New Age Islam 25 April 2022 Al-Zawahiri, your latest video message reveals the pathetic state of your half-a-century long campaign of seeking to radicalise Muslims around the world. Your once feared global Jihadi apparatus, the architect of 9/11, is now reduced to a state where it has to latch on to the Hijab of a 19-year-old college student in India to further its prospects. Not a single Indian Muslim has joined your terror organisation since it was formed in 1988. Yet you formed in 2014 a branch of Al-Qaeda specifically for the Indian sub-continent. You have had no success in inciting Indian Muslims to join your version of Jihad. Yet, you persist. Now you see an opportunity in the Hijab controversy. You say the Karnataka student Muskan Khan’s struggle for her right to cover her head while attending classes will kindle the “spirit of Jihad” among Indian Muslims. You say her fight for her human rights has exposed the illusion of Indian democracy and our respect for human rights. How ignorant you are, Al-Zawahiri, of the strength of both Indian Islam and Indian democracy. You have travelled to several Muslim counties on a fake passport. But you haven’t seen democracy in action anywhere. It’s difficult for you to imagine the strength of democratic institutions in India. We have several redressal mechanisms. Yes, Muskan has lost her case in one court, but she has gone to a superior court. If she loses even there, she will accept the verdict in good spirit. That is how the citizen of a democratic country behaves. In any case, she must have learned by now from the open discussion we have had that hijab is not an essential part of her religion. Most Muslim women don’t wear a burqa or hijab. Yes, it is a part of Indian culture. Many Indian women of all faiths cover their heads. Personally, I feel they should be allowed to if they feel comfortable doing so. But, finally, we all submit to judicial verdicts. I can hardly stop laughing, Al-Zawahiri, when I hear you talk about “the conflict between the chaste and pure Muslim Ummah and the degenerate and depraved polytheist and atheist enemies it confronts.” Which world do you inhabit I cannot understand? Where is this conflict going on? Yes, a few Islamist terrorists are killing some people, mostly Muslims on a sectarian basis. Since you lot started your terror campaign several million Muslims have been killed and a few thousand innocent non-Muslims too. But, of course, your blood-thirsty souls won’t feel any guilt or shame. And what is this pure and chaste Ummah? Where does it exist? When Syrian Arabs are displaced in the civil war, they get refuge in neighbouring Turkey and Christian Europe. Not a single Arab Muslim country accommodates them. The only countries that condemn the persecution of Uighur Muslims in China are the Western Christian nations. When a Muslim lives legally in a Western Christian nation for a few years, he or she gets citizenship rights, but even if a Muslim spends half a century serving an Arab Muslim country, he won’t get even permanent residence rights. You know Zawahiri, the concept of Muslim Ummah is absolutely bogus, yet you keep flogging it, because you have no other arguments to carry on with your terror campaign. Prophet Mohammad (pbuh) formed an Ummah in Madina bound by a constitution written in 622 (CE) called Meesaq-e-Madina that created a multi-religious state comprising Muslims, Jews, Christians, polytheists, and atheists. We Indian Muslims are part of an Indian ummah bound by our constitution which is considered the best in the world. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Also Read: What Is Wrong With 126 Moderate Ulema's 'Open Letter To 'Khalifa' Abu Bakr Al-Baghdadi’, And Why It Will Not Work? This Moderate Fatwa Does Not Leave Any Leg For Moderate Islam To Stand On ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Let me tell you why your Jihadi campaign has not and will not succeed in radicalising Indian Muslims. India is a land of saints and seers, Sufi and Bhakti poets. Ours is a land of composite culture, known as Ganga-Jamuni Tahzeeb. Have you heard of Guru Nanak and Guru Granth Sahib? Of course, you haven't? This inspirational scripture blends together India's Sufi and Bhakti traditions. It has inspired generations and continues to do so. India is a land of Rishis and Munis, Sufis and Saints who have all taught us to live together as a family. India's Sanatan Dharma, also called Hinduism is based on the concept of Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam, i.e., World is one Family. Hinduism considers all religions as valid spiritual paths to God. Ekam Sat VipraBahudhaVadanti is an Upanishadic statement, meaning One God Is Worshipped In Different Names. Muslims, of course, are guided by Quranic exhortations telling that the world is one; God has distributed people into different races only so as they can recognise one another. Islam teaches us repeatedly in the Holy Quran that all humans are equal before God, regardless of race, class or nationality. Muslims have internalised these teachings, which have also been made popular by Sufi masters like Ameer Khusro with his poetry, which is a beautiful blend of Hindustani languages and Persian. You al-Zawahiri, however, live in a narrow well. All your thoughts swirl around Ibn-e-Taimiyya, Ibn-e-Abdul Wahhab and Syed Qutb. Their desiccated, supremacist, violent version of Islam has been propagated in the Muslim world with the help of billions of petrodollars in the last four decades. But while it has somewhat affected Indian Ulema, it has not poisoned the minds of Muslim masses. They still live cheek by jowl with their Hindu, Sikh, and Christian brethren and will continue to do so, no matter what divisive tactics you try. URL: https://newageislam.com/radical-islamism-jihad/al-qaida-ayman-zawahiri-indian-muslims-/d/126860 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism

Sunday, April 24, 2022

Understanding The Political Ideology Of Salafism And Its Theology Of Supremacism, Exclusivism And Violence - Part 1

By Grace Mubashir, New Age Islam 24 April 2022 Salafi Movements (Often Referred To As Wahhabism) Represent A Diverse Community Main Points: 1. Salafism is a branch of Sunnite tradition. 2. Efforts of Salafi movements to institutionalize the new creed got materialized with the Establishment of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia in 1932. 3. Salafis are united by a common creed which provides guidelines for applying religious teachings to contemporary issues. ------ Salafism is a branch of Sunnite tradition. Salafi movements (often referred to as Wahhabism) represent a diverse community. All Salafi sects propound a puritanical approach to the religion intended to eschew innovation by strictly emulating the model of Prophet Mohamed and the first generation of Muslims. It is an ultra-conservative fundamentalist movement started with Ahmed ibn Hanbal (780-855). Later ibn Taymiyya (1263-1328) popularized the movement through his reform activities and put the postulates for the future evolutions. With the advent of Mohamed ibn Abdul Wahhab (1703-1792) in Najd (in present day Saudi Arabia) Salafism was transformed from passive theological discourses into active political activism with diverse strategies. Efforts of Salafi movements to institutionalize the new creed got materialized with the Establishment of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia in 1932 under the theological aegis of Salafi scholars and helped Salafism gaining ascendancy in the Muslim world. Imperial forces exploited the radical movement to fight against the soviet ambitions in the region. Osama bin Laden was an American protégé dispatched to expel the Red Bears from Afghanistan with the support of America, Pakistan and Saudi Arabia. Abundance of petro dollars of the Saudi Kingdom generously imported this hate ideology into various parts of Muslim world making serious fissures in the religious peaceful status quo. Salafis are united by a common creed which provides guidelines for applying religious teachings to contemporary issues. This creed concentrates on the stern adherence to the concept of pristine Tawhid (oneness of God) and emphatic rejection of human subjectivity in the jurisprudence, human reason and logic to interpret the religion. From this Salafi perspective there is only one true religion in the world and only one legitimate religious interpretation in Islam; Islamic pluralism does not exist. In terms of political participation and social engagements Salafi movements could be classified into three; namely · Purists: As the name suggests, “purists” are primarily concerned with maintaining the purity of Islam as outlined in the Qur’an, Sunna, and consensus of the Companions (Ijma). They believe that the primary emphasis of the movement should be on promoting the Salafi creed and combatting deviant practices, just as the Prophet fought polytheism, human desire, and human reason. Until the religion is purified, any political action will likely lead to corruption and injustice because society does not yet understand the tenets of faith. The proper method for implementing the creed is therefore propagation (Da’wa), purification (Tazkiyya), and religious education or cultivation (Tarbiya). · Politicos: Older scholars dominate the purist faction and attempt to monopolize religious authority by arguing that they alone have the depth of religious training, knowledge, and experience to render judgments about complex issues. Because the purists control the state religious establishment in Saudi Arabia, including the Council of Senior Ulama (Scholars), they enjoy considerable influence over government policy and have used their positions to promote purist interpretations of Islam. Their authority, however, was challenged during the 1980s and 1990s by a group of young, more politically minded Salafi scholars, here referred to as “the politicos.” The politicos argued that they have a better understanding of contemporary issues and are therefore better situated to apply the Salafi creed to the modern context. They generally stop short of declaring revolution, unlike the Jihadis, but are highly critical of incumbent regimes. Although the politicos control fewer resources and assets, they have clearly shaken the purist grip over Islamic interpretation and put the older generation of scholars on the defensive. · Jihadis: The jihadi faction, those supporting the use of violence to establish Islamic states, emerged during the war in Afghanistan against the Soviet Union. This conflict functioned as a dangerous incubator by exposing Saudi Salafis (and others) to the radical and politicized teachings of the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood and related splinter groups (the Islamic Group, Islamic Jihad, etc.) in a context of military training and warfare. Unlike the politico exposure to Ikhwani analysis at the universities, the Jihadis received their political training on the battlefield. As a result, their introduction was imbued with an emphasis on politics as warfare, something they later brought back to their own countries. To sum up, Split in Salafi movements is not in thought but it is in strategy while applying inherently subjective human interpretation to new issues and problems. Stubbornness of Salafi creed on monolithic manifestation of ultimate truth makes the Salafi movement good recipe for violence and hatred stunting national growth. As solution, Salafism needs to be reconstructed in order to complete is historical reform mission opposing many blind superstitions crept into the religion while neutralizing the radical elements posing threat to harmony and peace. Genealogy Of Salafi Movements: A History Of Religious Intolerance And Violence Is Islam compatible with the new global initiatives for peace and does Islam offer solution to the followers are well discussed. Islam which advocates peace has been falsely construed by radical elements to incite war and social antagonism. It is to be sadly admitted that Islamic sharia’ is abused to sanction physical annihilation of diversity, a requirement that God stipulated to work each other for mutual prosperity and to destabilize the democratic secular governments. As noted by Majid Khadduri, mass emotional appeal of fanatical scholars causes the occasional invoking of selective sharia’ laws to prop up the terrorism and spiritual aggression. Islam is rooted in universal peace and brotherhood, but historical Islam is abundant with incidents that demonstrate the theological support for pluralism and coexistence. Sufism, peaceful and assimilative spiritual stream of Muslims, enlivened the great pluralistic ideals of Islam wherever it is found. The great dilemma of Muslim world caused by Salafi distortion is about the nature of Islam, whether it is monolithic or pluralistic. According to mainstream Muslims, Islam is both universal in belief and local in practice. Islam suggests uniform and universal laws like belief in one God and Messenger but the practical manifestations are different in various parts to suit the legitimate concerns of the people. Thus, Islam allows for a great deal of integration into local culture and formation of indigenous traditions compatible with the universal teachings of Islam, a key reason behind the spontaneous spread of Islam. Negation of local cultural traditions preached by Sufis as bid’a (religious innovation) and perceiving imagined global communities faithful makes the core of Salafism. This approach disproving pluralism, compounded with other characteristics of radical revolutionary movements renders Salafism a great challenge to intra and interreligious dialogues and harmony, placing the religious chauvinism above national interests and peoples welfare. Salafi belief in exclusive religious truth leads the adherents to stamp tags of apostasy and heresy upon others making the opponents legitimate targets of violence. Doctrinal intransigence rid the Salafi movements of the religious responsibility of national integration and civilizational dialogues making them highly susceptible to elimination drive of perceived non-believers. Abdurrahman Wahid, former president of Indonesia, ascribed lack of development to the Salafi puritanical missions in Muslim world. Salafism has made inroads in all countries especially in places where Muslims are a minority or oppressed community. Through migration from Asia and Africa Salafism reached Europe in seventies. Fundamentalist Salafi scholars funded by Saudi Arabia were dispatched to all parts of world to preach the hate ideology of Salafism. Book by David Commins titled The Wahhabi Mission and Saudi Arabia has minutely tracked the trails of Wahhabi expansion in various parts of world. Physical violence, jihad, was widely exercised by Salafism to confront disbelief breaking away from the tradition of Islam engaging in intellectual discourses. Assaf Moghadam argues that violence and jihad are intrinsic to the puritanical teachings of Salafism as it believes non-believers deserve either submission or death. Salafi history began with the bloody warfare against Arabian tribal people being accused of innovative religious practices like Milad, celebration of prophet’s birthday and venerating the saints and holy graves. Salafi dogma of keeping a safe distance from the unbelievers in order to keep the faith unadulterated has triggered conflicts with Christians in Nigeria and Sudan and in many European countries. Al Qaeda, Lashkar e Taiba, Shabab ul Muslimeen, ISIS and other radical fundamentalists that constitute the new global jihadi movement are not theological outliers of Salafism. Detailed analysis of Salafi radical movements form political abstinence to violence has been deeply studied by Quintan Wiktorowicz in his study titled ‘A Genealogy of Radical Islam’. India has and will fall victim to the venomous ideology of Salafism. Lashkar e Taiba, Indian Mujahideen, student’s Islamic Movements of India (SIMI) are few organizations that occasionally cripple the peaceful life of Indians. This context solicits candid appreciation for various Salafi movements in Kerala which carried out many reform activities while developing moderate social approach to religious harmony. Strategies should be made to empower the moderate Salafism. Even Separatists movements in the Kashmir valley are linked to the growth of radical Islamism. Suicide bombings and civilian killings are allowed in jihadi Salafi ideology in conflicts against the infidels. Antique structures of global heritage are not exempt from the Salafi fury against the polytheism and shirk (association of partners with God) like ancient city of Timbuktu of Male, Palmyra buildings of Syria and Bamiyan Buddhist statue of Afghanistan. Intra religious conflicts caused by Salafi anti-Shiism and anti-Islamist movements still wreak havoc in the Middle East. A fortified invisible apartheid wall has been erected by Salafism as the region was bifurcated on the lines of two sects. Yemen and Syria bears the grave brunt of Salafi ideology as it produced trails of destruction. Salafism inculcates an ideology of religious hatred and antipathy that prevents successful religious engagements. Dogmatic Salafism And Religious Discords Salafi ideology rooted in ultra-conservatism exhorts religious divisions and pluralistic engagements are met with strong legal inhibitions. All Salafi factions hold same belief but are different in practical severity. It is highly imperative to understand these discourses in the Salafi Manhaj (method) to help concerned authorities to establish more accommodative moderate path based on intellectual engagements. To neutralize the people affected with radical Salafi ideology contextual reading of texts need to be enhanced. Contextualization of Islamic politics against the imitation of Prophet and disciples in letter and spirit is very critical due to the reason that Islamic violence is often ascribed to strict textual reading without regarding the social evolution. As nations after nations fall victim to Salafi outrages it is incumbent upon world communities to defuse the violent identity and transform into more moderate versions. Such a movement to soften the ideological vehemence of Salafism through an interfaith dialogue initiative was started by Saudi king Abdulla in 2008 but it failed to harmonize the Salafi adherents due to the staunchest criticisms by Salafi scholars accusing the Kingdom of deviating from the true monotheism. --- An occasional New Age Islam columnist, Grace Mubashir is a journalism student at Indian Institute of Mass Communication, Delhi URL: https://newageislam.com/islamic-ideology/ideology-salafism-theology-exclusivism/d/126850 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism

The Chronology Of The Issue Of Azan On Loudspeaker From India To Saudi Arabia

Muslims Grew Gradually Obsessed With The Use Of Loudspeakers For Religious Purposes Main Points: 1. Till late 20th century, loudspeakers were not used for Azan. 2. The trend of azan on loudspeakers caught up after 70s. 3. Until the 70s, mullahs called the loudspeaker the devil's voice. 4. Gradually more and more loudspeakers were used for azan. 5. Later loudspeakers began to be used for relaying sermons or prayers outside the mosque. ---- By New Age Islam Staff Writer 23 April 2022 Representational image. PTI ---- Islam stresses on sincerity and inner purity in matters of Deen. It opposes pomp and show in religious observances. Azan, one of the Essential Religious Practices of Islam was, therefore, remained an unnoticed and non-controversial practice of Muslims because it was called by a muezzin from the top of the Azangah without a loudspeaker. A human voice, however loud can not cause any disturbance and so the non-Muslims never had any problem with it. When the loudspeakers came into vogue around the 70s, the mullahs, averse to anything scientific and technological called the loudspeakers the devil's voice (Shaitan Ki Awaz) because during those times, loudspeakers or sound amplifiers were mostly used for playing film songs. But gradually, the Muslim community found out its utility in religious practices. Growing population and growing affluence necessitated the use of loudspeakers for azan. It also gave them the air of modernity and the Muslims also adopted it to show to the majority community that they did not lag behind in technological progress. But gradually, the obsession of Muslims with the use of loudspeakers for azan and for every religious practice grew enormously and the use of loudspeakers assumed the place of a necessary religious tool. No religious event was considered complete without the loudspeakers. Initially, ordinary amplifiers with low sound were installed in mosques and only one loudspeaker was tied to the minaret to relay the azan. But gradually, multiple loudspeakers facing different directions wete set up at the minarets. Now costly and powerful amplifiers replaced ordinary and cheap amplifiers. The number of loudspeakers increased to about ten. Since there was no restrictions on the volume of loudspeakers, Muslims did not need to ponder over the inconvenience it caused to the Muslims and non -Muslims of the neighbourhood. The non-Muslims also used the loudspeakers for religious and cultural events. And so the use of loudspeakers became rampant. But in the 90s, Shiv Sena supremo Bal Thackeray started opposing azan on loudspeakers. He had said that he could not tolerate azan on the loudspeaker for three seconds, leave aside for three minutes. Since he had extremist views on Muslims, the Muslims largely ignored his opposition considering it his own communal views based on political agenda In later years, rational people from both the communities started speaking against the rampant use of loudspeakers on religious festivals and cultural events and a general consensus on the use of loudspeakers among the polity emerged. In 2000, the Supreme Court said that no religion or religious community could claim that the use of loudspeakers for worship or prayer or for celebrating any religious festival was an Essential Religious Practice protected under the Article 25 of the Constitution.In 2009, the Supreme Court passed a judgment regulating the use of loudspeakers in public places. Since the courts had placed restrictions on the use of loudspeakers from 10 P.M. to 6 A.M. only the morning azan came under the restriction. However, the azan of Fajr (morning) went as usual as non -Muslims did not raise an objection to it. The restrictions on the volume of the loudspeaker was also not followed. The sound of azan blared from six to eight loudspeakers from the mosques five times a day including the morning azan. During the Ramadan, apart from azan, the announcements waking up the Muslims for Sehri was also made continuously for one and a half hour, disturbing the sleep of the non-Muslims of the locality. Apart from the announcements, religious poems were also recited causing a nuisance to the ill, the elderly and the children. This gave right wing Hindu organisations an opportunity to further their communal agenda. They started opposing azan on the loudspeakers. But their voice was strengthened by secular Hindus who raised their genuine concern over the azan on loudspeaker on the basis of their personal experience. In 2017, famous Bollywood singer Sonu Nigam, not known for his communal bias, objected to the azan on the loudspeaker and termed it "forced religiousness". Instead of empathising with him and doing introspection, the Muslims unleashed a villification campaign against him. Worse, a mullah announced a reward of Rs 10 lakh on anyone who shaved Sonu Nigam's head. In response, Sonu Nigam himself shaved his head. Recently, the Vice-Chancellor of Allahabad University, Sangita Srivastava complained to the DM that the dawn azan on loudspeaker disturbed her sleep. In2020, the Allahabad High court had ruled that no religion advocates the use of loudspeakers for worship. The petitioner had challenged an administrative order in the Jaunpur district of UP where the use of loudspeaker for azan had bee banned. This indicates that even secular non-Muslims also opposed azan on loudspeakers. In 2021, Karnataka High Court curbed the use of loudspeakers in religious places. In March 2021, the Karnataka State Board of Awqaf issued a circular to all the mosques and Dargahs of the state prohibiting the use of loudspeakers between 10 PM to 6 AM. Recently, Bajrang Dal and Sri Ram Sena demanded a ban on loudspeakers. The Karnataka government said that it need not impose a ban as the court orders already exist and the mosques will be asked to follow the court orders. The state police sent notices to all the mosques in the state to bring the sound of the loudspeakers to the prescribed level. The mosques complied and set up devices in mosques to keep the sound of loudspeakers low. In April 2022, the Hindu Janajagruti Sena delegation submitted a memorandum to the District Collector of North Goa. On the instruction of the Goa High Court, in response to a petition filed by Varun Pariolker the ADC, passed an order directing the mosques not use loudspeakers without prior permission. In Maharashtra, where the opposition to azan on the loudspeaker began in the 90s,it has peaked in April 2020. The MNS has upped the ante against the azan on loudspeakers. To diffuse the situation, Muslims have either stopped dawn azan on loudspeakers or have reduced the decibel to the prescribed level. The Muslims are doing this only under political pressure or under court order. The Muslims of India have described the restrictions as the result of the growing communalism and Islamophobia in India. There is no doubt that communalism and Islamophobia has grown in India but the restrictions on loudspeakers were not a communal issue. The restrictions on loudspeakers have been imposed on all the religious communities. As a result, the Jagran, a religious practice of Hindus was affected. Night long cultural programmes are not held any more. According to a news report, a temple in Mathura has turned off its loudspeakers. Its not that only Hindus of India are complaining about the overuse of loudspeakers. In Saudi Arabia, a section of Muslims had been complaining against the overuse of loudspeakers in mosques. The complainants included those from parents who said loudspeakers disturbed their children 's sleep. After considering their complaints and discussions on the issue for two years, in 2021, the Ministry of Islamic Affairs directed the mosques not not to use external loudspeakers for relaying sermons or prayers. The loudspeakers will be used only for azan and iqamat and the sound of the loudspeakers will be reduced to one third of the maximum sound. This decision was based on Shariah and a fatwa by two muftis. Earlier, the external loudspeakers were also used for prayers and for relaying sermons. The ministry said that communicating the imam's voice in prayer is limited to only those inside the mosque and that there is no legitimate reason to communicate the same to those at home. In addition to the fact that reading the Quran on external amplifiers was disrespectful to the Quran when it is recited loudly using external loudspeakers while no one is listening to and pondering on verses. This practice was followed in many places in India too. External loudspeakers were used for prayers, Taraweeh prayer in Ramadan or Friday sermons causing inconvenience to non-Muslims and causing disrespect to the Quran. Muslims, should therefore, realise that azan on loudspeakers are not in consonance with the Shariah. The government and the Muslims of Saudi Arabia have acted to regulate the use of loudspeakers in mosques. They have realised that the overuse of loudspeakers violates the rights of the neighbours and causes inconvenience and discomfort to the elderly and the children. Unfortunately, the Muslims of India have to act under the government and the courts. URL: https://newageislam.com/islamic-society/chronology-azan-loudspeaker-india-saudi-arabia/d/126848 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism

The Curvaceous Exquisiteness Of Persian

By Sumit Paul, New Age Islam 23 April 2022 April 23 is commemorated as the UN International Day of English, coinciding with the putative birthday of the Bard of Avon. While English is still the number one language in terms of its commercial viability, Persian remains the most mellifluous tongue and a repertoire of wisdom, mysticism and common-sense. Islamic mysticism is just incomplete without the copious references to Persian and Pahlavi (precursor to Persian; Avesta of Zoroastrianism is written in Pahlavi). I often wonder, why such a beautiful language has so few takers in India, considering the fact that it was Mughal India's court language and was also a colloquial and legal language of the sub-continent for nearly 400 years? Ghalib and Iqbal wrote their finest poetic works in Persian and not in Urdu. Ghalib called it the language of his linguistic consciousness and Iqbal called it : Mere Ruhani Ustaad Ki Zabaan Jo Mujh Pe Naazil Hui (the language of my spiritual master which descended upon me). En passant, his spiritual master was the redoubtable Maulana Jalaluddin Rumi Balkhi. But then, a language is more often than not a political tool. Its survival often depends upon political hobnobbing and patronage. Coming back to Persian's delectable beauty, it was aptly called ' a curvaceous language,' by none other than the legendary western scholar and the greatest authority on Rumi, the Cambridge Professor Sir Reynold A Nicholson, who taught Iqbal and also translated Iqbal's first philosophical Persian poetry book ' Asraar-e-Khudi ' into English as ' The Secrets of the Self. ' Apart from its euphonic aspect, Persian is steeped in nous. The maxims in Persian are used worldwide. Who can forget the famous Persian adage, ' Ze Gahvaare Taa Gur Daanes Bejuy ' ( Seek knowledge from the cradle to the grave) or ' Porsidan E'yub Nist, Nadaanestan E'yub Ast ' (He that nothing questions, nothing learns/Literally: The shame is not in asking; shame is in not knowing) or ' Co Istadehi Daste Aftaadeh Gir ' (So long as you're standing, give a hand to those who've fallen) or 'Gar sabr koni, ze yure halvaa saazi ' (With time and art, the leaf of a mulberry tree becomes satin/Literally: If you exercise patience, you may make a sweet-meat out of the sour grape). Lastly, ' Hic arzani bi e'lat nist ' (Nothing is cheap for no reason). And when you use the words like ' Haminastu' (It's here), Zeba (Beautiful), Maahtaab (moonlight), Dilshaad (Cheerful, remember, Delhi's famed Dilshad Garden), Firdaus (Jannat/Bahisht or Paradise), the listeners are transported to the highest plane of unadulterated bliss. So many words of Persian origin are now a part and parcel of our everyday conversation. Dil ( pronounced Del in Persian), Dehaat (village) and Deemak (termite) are Persian words which cannot be plucked out of our daily lingo. Even Zukaam (cold, influenza) came from Persian. Having spent quite a few years in Maharashtra, I wondered how so many Marathi words directly descended from Persian. Marathi words 'ashtpailu' (Hashtpahloo in Farsi for versatility; Hasht : Eight in Persian) and Hangaam (Time/Season/Session, pronounced Hengaam by Iranian native speakers of Persian) directly came from Farsi, albeit with a slightly different enunciation, but no change in their connotations. Reading Persian mystical poetry is an inebriating experience even for a nonbeliever like me as the very language is so lyrical and tailor made for this kind of poetry. I consider myself to be immensely fortunate to have read Hafiz, Rumi, Khaqani, Nizami, Attar, Bedil, Sanai and Anwari's poetry in original classical Persian without ever resorting to second-hand, diluted renditions and interpretations in English like those of Coleman Barks' Rumi. This American poet popularised Rumi but cannot read and write Persian! And when it comes to expressing love, Persian is simply unparalleled. I remember my Persian professor's immortal and ever-relevant advice: ' If you propose to a woman in chaste Persian, she won't be able to say no to you.' I followed the advice and found it to be true to the last syllable! Try it but do learn Persian! ---- An occasional columnist for New Age Islam, Sumit Paul is a researcher in comparative religions, with special reference to Islam. He has contributed articles to world's premier publications in several languages including Persian. URL: https://newageislam.com/islamic-culture/curvaceous-exquisiteness-persian/d/126849 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism

Friday, April 22, 2022

Why Salman Nadwi’s Lamentation Puts a Negative Spotlight on Islam

By Arshad Alam, New Age Islam 22 April 2022 A Call To Embrace Monotheism Does Not Necessarily Further The Cause Of Indian Muslims Main Points: 1. Salman Nadwi has produced a short video in the backdrop of Jahangirpuri clashes. 2. He argues that Muslims are facing this calamity because they have deviated from the path of Islam and become ‘grave worshippers.’ 3. He falsely argues that Sanatan Dharm and Islam proclaims monotheism. 4. He argues that India was gift given to Muslims by God to spread the light of Islam which they have squandered by behaving like the Hindu polytheists. ---- A short video by Salman Nadwi is enough to tell you what is wrong with the self-proclaimed Indian Ulama. The video has been made in the backdrop of Jahangirpuri clashes in Delhi which saw stone-pelting by Muslims after Hindus attempted to hoist a flag atop a mosque during the Ram Navami procession. Salman Nadwi analyses why this happened, how this is a lesson for Muslims to change their ‘deviant ways’, and how the provocateurs were not really the followers of Sanatan Dharma. > In the video, Nadwi makes a distinction between Sanatan Dharm and Hinduism, arguing that the former has always believed in monotheism (Allah/Ishwar ek hai). Hinduism, he says, was a pejorative designation given to Indians by the Persians. He may be correct that one of the usages of the word Hindu at that time was extremely negative, but should he be saying this at all in today’s religiously polarized context? What does he want to achieve by reminding the Hindus that they are still carrying the name given by Muslims? If today, a vast number of people want to call themselves as Hindus, then what is his problem? Why this urge to foist his own nomenclature on a billion who want to be known by that name. What it tells us about Nadwi is that he is still dwelling in the past, when the likes of his had the power to confer names and designations on people. Nadwi instead would like to use the word Sanatan Dharm to describe Hindus. But then he has a peculiar understanding of Sanatanis as well and it is not surprising why he prefers that word. His argument is that Sanatan Dharm is promotes monotheism rather than polytheism as is the popular Hindu practice. Thus, his preference for the word Sanatan derives from the fact that like Islam, the other faith also promotes monotheism. This tells us what is fundamentally wrong about Muslim religious leadership and their understanding of inter-religious co-existence. But more fundamentally, who told Nadwi that Sanatan Dharm is only about monotheism? There are strands within this religion which can be linked to monotheism, but there are other strands, equally valid, who don’t call themselves as monotheists. The whole Bhakti tradition imagined a personalized God, near to the self, with or without the image or the idol. Within the Hindu philosophy, they are manifestations of different attributes of the Almighty, the Creator. Not just this, Hinduism also has space for atheistic doctrines like Buddhism, early Jainism and even the Ajivikas, where there is no concept of God or becomes irrelevant within their larger philosophies. Such spaces of internal pluralism are simply absent in Islam and would probably attract the charges of blasphemy. Nadwi’s Islam can only relate to that strand of Hindu religiosity which imagines God as one. His Islam can only get into a conversation with a religious worldview which shares its assumption about the creator, not with those who are coming from a different philosophical location. And that perhaps is the biggest challenge which Islam, in a diverse society like India, hasn’t been able to solve. Ultimately all mythologies are arbitrary. If Islam can live by the myth that its Prophet split the moon into two, why can’t it believe in mythologies of Ganesha and Krishna? Nadwi’s problem, and of many Muslims like him, is that only their arbitrariness should be valid and all others should be declared as false. Why should there be just one way of expressing religiosity? What is the problem if one is believing in many headed Gods or no God at all? And is there any guarantee that when the whole world become monotheist, problems between communities will cease to exist. There is a lot of common ground between Islam and Christianity but they have fought long and bitter battles simply over whose version of monotheism is the correct one. Nadwi will do well to study the history of monotheistic religions in order to understand that it is hardly a recipe for peace. Nadwi doesn’t stop there. He argues that those who indulged in arson and looting in places like Khargone and Delhi should be called hooligans who have come from the jungle and do not know how to behave in civilized spaces like cities. Since Muslims are predominantly urban, it does not escape attention that he is trying to say that Muslims were the first to create cities and civilized spaces in this country. This is not the place to get into argument about urbanization in medieval India but the haughtiness underlying the assertion that Muslims brought civilization in this country needs to be called out. Such a demeaning understanding of the country’s Hindu civilizational heritage does not augur well for pluralism. Nadwi also gets into the causes of why Muslims are at the receiving end today. He starts by saying that the subcontinent was ‘given’ to Muslims to bring the light of monotheism. But given by whom? What he means is that India was gifted to the Muslims by God to make the Hindus realize the falsity of their religion. This is not just hubris but also shows the contempt in which Hinduism is held at by the likes of Nadwi. In a similar vein, he also argues that till the time Muslims do not openly preach Tauheed (oneness of God) to others, they will remain a damned community in the eyes of Allah. What really does he mean? Instead of exchange of religious ideas, Nadwi would very much like Muslims to invite each and every Hindu to the fold of Islam. This attitude of ‘my way or the highway’ is one of the many reasons why Islam appears alien and uncompromising, not just to Hindus but now also to many Muslims. Nadwi laments that Muslims couldn’t hold the light properly as they indulged in grave worship (Yahan Sajda, Wahan Sajda). Here Nadwi, true to his revivalist leanings, is accusing the majority of Indian Muslim population who are Barelwis of being too close to Hindus because they visit and pray at the shrines. In other words, Muslims indulged in shirk (associating partners to God) and hence God decided to punish them. Apparently, one of the ways that God is adopting to punish Muslims these days is by unleashing Hindu mobs on their meagre properties and homes, and even their mosques. It is clear that Nadwi has no empathy for any Muslim loss of life or property since he has declared them Mushrik anyway. And yet the irony is that lakhs of Muslims will continue to follow him. But what should worry Indian Muslims most is that despite so many centuries of living together with Hindus, we haven’t been able to evolve a theology of religious pluralism. Nadwi is just a crass expression of this failure. ----- A regular contributor to NewAgeIslam.com, Arshad Alam is a writer and researcher on Islam and Muslims in South Asia. URL: https://newageislam.com/the-war-within-islam/nadwi-lamentation-negative-spotlight/d/126840 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism

Wednesday, April 20, 2022

Burning the Quran in Sweden: How Should Muslims Respond?

By Arshad Alam, New Age Islam 20 April 2022 It Is A Definite Provocation But Should They Be Burning The Streets? Main Points: 1. Far right Swedish politician Rasmus Paludan is provoking Muslims again by burning the Quran. 2. Muslims have responded by burning the streets in some cities. 3. They should have adopted civic ways of protesting instead of burning property, thereby alienating the state and the common citizens. 4. They also need to ask some hard questions about their own religious and cultural assumptions. ----- Muslims in Sweden are protesting against an attempted burning and defilement of the Quran in various cities of the country. According to reports, a far-right party, Stram Kurs (The Hard Line) had proposed to burn the Quran at different places in Sweden. In one of the suburbs of Stockholm, they succeeded in putting the Quran on fire, but in others it was a no show. Certainly, this is a deliberate provocation, but shouldn’t Muslims have acted with more sagacity and restraint? Rioting in the streets, burning public property and injuring police gives a bad name to Muslims, who are already reeling with a very negative image of Islam. Rasmus Paludan has been appealing his prison sentence following a district court conviction last year of hate-speech, discrimination and racism (photo: News Øresund / Johan Wessman) ----- With the re-emergence of far-right in Europe, there are many individuals who want to capitalize on anti-Islam rhetoric. At times, it has gone beyond rhetoric and has targeted Muslim lives and properties in a spate of hate attacks. One such individual is Rasmus Paludan, the leader of the Hard Line party. A dual citizen of Denmark and Sweden, Paludan first’s brush with (in)fame was in 2017 when he produced anti-Islam YouTube videos. In one of his most provocative stunts, he wrapped the Quran in bacon and burnt in on Facebook and justified his act as a tribute to freedom of speech. But rather than a free speech absolutist, he easily crosses over as a Muslim hating racist. In one of his speeches, he stated, “the enemy is Islam and Muslims. The best thing would be if there is not a single Muslim left on this earth, then we would have reached our final goal”. It is one thing to criticize Islam as a set of ideas, but quite another to declare an entire community as the enemy. His speeches and actions, for which he has been jailed briefly from time to time, is a clear incitement to racist hatred against Muslims, rather than a proclamation of free speech. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Also Read: Islamophobia In Europe: Quran Burning And Hijab Ban Become Political Tools For Winning Elections --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- In a fundamental sense, the Swedish authorities have failed to evolve a clear strategy to tackle such issues. On the one hand, they gave permission to Paludan to hold his Quran burning rally; on the other, they are quite at a loss to understand the Muslim violence that ensued. A number of policemen have been injured in the Muslim arson; some authorities state that by far this was the most serious incident of arson which they have seen. It is baffling that the police cannot understand Muslim sentiments in relation to the Quran which is their holiest book. Burning it in the holy month of Ramzan would have serious repercussion and clearly such a permission shouldn’t have been given in the first place. The Swedish state seemed at first to flirt with this racist demagogue and that must have created an anti-state sentiment within Muslims. On the other hand, it is also true that the European tradition considers ‘freedom from religion’ an important value; something which is an anathema to most Muslims. But should Muslims have protested in such a fashion? After all, hasn’t God promised that He will save and protect His holy book? Then why should Muslims arrogate themselves the power of God? It is quite understandable that they are aggrieved but couldn’t the protests be organized without loss of property and inflicting injury on others? As minorities, Muslims must always try to be within the ambit of law. Certainly, they have a right to protest, but should that protest rile the state and other citizens or should they be designed in such a way that these forces become the ally of Muslims in their fight for dignity? Muslims in Sweden need to ask these questions of themselves urgently otherwise they are risking alienating the state as well as common citizens who are not right-wing supporters. Medieval religions, whether Christianity or Islam, have always burnt books. In the self-righteousness, they have destroyed knowledge systems throughout the world. It is only with modernity that good sense prevailed under immense pressure which was brought by a secular state and citizens who grew wary of religion and its associated violence. Unfortunately, Muslims seem to have escaped this secularizing gaze and ended up burning the Satanic Verses as a mark of protest. It was the first time in many centuries that a book was being burnt in public and Muslims were at the forefront of it. The way in which European history has evolved, books have become sacred objects. They associated the burning of the novel with a return of medieval horror and hence an association of Islam and medievalism was created in their minds. Muslims do get affronted over what they consider as sacred but have no regard for what others consider sacred. Till we get over this narcissism, we will keep fighting the perception that Muslims are intolerant and ethnocentric. Sweden has been rocked by days of violence triggered by far-right Danish-Swedish politician Rasmus Paludan/ Photo: DW Made for Minds ---- Living in diverse societies demand that one lives by rules which not just maintain but enhance pluralism. Unfortunately, a Muslim credo which demands solidarity only with Muslims but expects others to always respect them is not a good example of shared co-existence. What is happening in Sweden has its echo all over Europe and Muslims will be the worst sufferers with the rise of right- wing politics. Paludan and Marine le Pen must be condemned for their actions but Muslims also need to ask deep questions about their religiosity and way of life. ---- A regular contributor to NewAgeIslam.com, Arshad Alam is a writer and researcher on Islam and Muslims in South Asia. URL: https://newageislam.com/muslims-islamophobia/burning-quran-sweden-muslims/d/126826 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism