Pages

Saturday, May 14, 2022

Akbar Never Forced Tansen to Embrace Islam

By Naseer Ahmed, New Age Islam 14 May 2022 The Role of Cognitive Dissonance Philosopher Alfred North Whitehead said in his 1925 book, Science and the Modern World: “It is easy enough to find a [self-consistent] theory . . . , provided that you are content to disregard half your evidence. The moral temper required for the pursuit of truth, includes an unflinching determination to take the whole evidence into account.” When it comes to those who reject Islam, you will notice that these rejecters show an unflinching determination to disregard all of the relevant evidence! For example, if you are looking for evidence whether the Quran is truly Allah’s word, you will find it easily in many of the verses of the Quran. In my article, The Al Furqan Prevails As It Must, I have covered a few of them. What could be more clinching than the evidence that the Quran talks of creation of the universe in terms discovered by science only in the 20th century? It was beyond anyone’s imagination that the Universe at one time was squeezed tightly together (to a size less than that of an atomic sub-particle) before the expansion, or the idea that our universe is forever expanding, or of the property of Time that it is relative to the frame of reference of the observer, and, therefore, a cosmic day that the Quran talks about, is not our 24 hour day, but could be one thousand, fifty thousand or even hundreds of thousands of years, that the predominant component of all living beings is water? These are the Ayats or the astonishing signs of Allah for the people of today. Such Ayats are not to be found in any previous scriptures. These Ayats not only provide evidence that the Quran is the word of Allah but that Muhammad (pbuh) was a true prophet and not an impostor plagiarising the previous Books as alleged by the enemies of Islam. Do we need any more evidence than this? Is it not enough? Can a mountain of lies heaped against it be of any consequence? Will such Ayats make all those who read them, accept the Message? The Quran informs us that while a few may, many of those who are wilful rejecters will not. The Quran provides several examples, the most graphic being that of the pharaoh of Moses times, to whom were sent about a dozen signs but remained a rejecter which made Moses pray for his destruction. (10:88) Moses prayed: "Our Lord! Thou hast indeed bestowed on Pharaoh and his chiefs splendour and wealth in the life of the present, and so, Our Lord, they mislead (men) from Thy Path. Deface, our Lord, the features of their wealth, and send hardness to their hearts, so they will not believe until they see the grievous penalty."(89) Allah said: "Accepted is your prayer (O Moses and Aaron)! So stand ye straight, and follow not the path of those who know not."(90) We took the Children of Israel across the sea: Pharaoh and his hosts followed them in insolence and spite. At length, when overwhelmed with the flood, he said: "I believe that there is no god except Him Whom the Children of Israel believe in: I am of those who submit (to Allah in Islam)."(91) (It was said to him): "Ah now! - But a little while before, wast thou in rebellion!- and thou didst mischief (and violence)!(92) "This day shall We save thee in the body, that thou mayest be a sign to those who come after thee! but verily, many among mankind are heedless of Our Signs!" How do people manage to reject such clear evidence? In Psychology this is called cognitive bias where people pay attention only to facts that support their prejudices and passions. Uncomfortable evidence that contradicts their passionately held position causes what is called cognitive dissonance. An honest way of dealing with cognitive dissonance is to revise their opinion/theory taking the full facts of the case into consideration. Dishonest ways are by way of discounting, falsifying, or by ignoring altogether the evidence that does not suit their purpose. When their most passionately held position is challenged, they react violently and resort to slander and calumny such as the Islamohobes do. The Islamophobes have a toolkit ready for attack when they stand exposed. They are determined in their mission. Ad hominem is common except that for the Islamohobes, the Prophet is their target. They also have a collection of what they think is indefensible in the Quran such as the permission to have sex with own slaves without marrying them first. Such, ayats shake up the believers of our times also, who with their sensibilities of a world at peace and free of legalised slavery, are unable to accept these as right. The Quran has enough to test the believers as well as the disbelievers. However, the promise of Allah, that those who place their trust in Him and seek His help, will find guidance, is unfailing. There is no arrow that these wretched Islamophobes can shoot that will ever find its mark. The morality of the permission to have sex with own slave is covered in my article: The Morality or the Immorality of the Institution of Slavery and the Quranic Permission That Allowed Sex with Female Slaves Degrees of Cognitive Dissonance Not everyone feels cognitive dissonance to the same degree. People with a higher need for consistency and certainty in their lives usually feel the effects of cognitive dissonance more than those who have a lesser need for such consistency. People who have not trained themselves to deal honestly with cognitive dissonance become habitual liars and feel nothing. It is about these people that the Quran says: (2:16) These are they who have bartered Guidance for error: But their traffic is profitless, and they have lost true direction,(17) Their similitude is that of a man who kindled a fire; when it lighted all around him, Allah took away their light and left them in utter darkness. So they could not see. (18) Deaf, dumb, and blind, they will not return (to the correct path). People who have learnt to suppress cognitive dissonance will rarely change their stand on any issue no matter even if they are proved wrong. This is so since their decision in the first place is not based on an objective analysis and the truth in any case is unimportant to such people. Pride and arrogance prevent such people from changing their stand even if proved wrong. The Quran says about such people: (6:109) They swear their strongest oaths by Allah, that if a (special) sign came to them, by it they would believe. Say: "Certainly (all) signs are in the power of Allah: but what will make you (Muslims) realise that (even) if (special) signs came, they will not believe."? (7:101) Such were the towns whose story We (thus) relate unto thee: There came indeed to them their messengers with clear (signs): But they would not believe what they had rejected before. Thus doth Allah seal up the hearts of those who reject faith. (7:146) Those who behave arrogantly on the earth in defiance of right - them will I turn away from My signs: Even if they see all the signs, they will not believe in them; and if they see the way of right conduct, they will not adopt it as the way; but if they see the way of error, that is the way they will adopt. For they have rejected our signs, and failed to take warning from them. That unchecked cognitive bias will take a person down a spiral, is an unchanging law of human behaviour. Can A Person Suffering From The Disease Of Suppressing Cognitive Dissonance Change Himself? A person has to first accept that there is a problem and make a moral choice to change and seek God’s help for changing. People must realize that refusing to learn to deal honestly with cognitive dissonance in its most basic form, is a lie to oneself and self-deception. Matz and his colleagues (2008) found that people who were extraverted were less likely to feel the negative impact of cognitive dissonance and were also less likely to change their mind. Introverts, on the other hand, deal more honestly with cognitive dissonance. This is hardly surprising since introverts are concerned with self-image and telling a lie to one self is more difficult and the extraverts are more concerned with what others say about them. The cronies, side-kicks and sycophants of the extraverts are there to heap praise on them whatever they say or do and join them in their attacks on truth. If there are people who confront them with their lie and embarrass them, they will respond by categorizing them with some odious labels and try to cover the truth with more lies. These people will never change when they have people who support them in their lie. Politicians therefore are some of the most adept liars and practitioners of systematic deceit and the most shameless among all the liars. Self-awareness and a desire to change is the key to changing oneself. You know when you are disregarding information that contradicts your stand on any issue. As Socrates said “An unexamined life is not worth living.” Develop self-awareness which is the first step to change. If there is a conflict between what you desire and what you consider right then consciously choose what is right. Learn to admit past mistakes, repent, apologize for these and learn to move forward. People who talk about morals speak about the ‘conscience’ or the inner voice which is nothing but the cognitive dissonance that we experience when our action does not match what we consider to be right. Can Prayer Help? Prayer is a form of self-conditioning or priming and is most effective in changing one’s behaviour. Belief in God helps but it should work even without such belief if the prayer is changed to a daily resolution or pledge. This prayer (of the Prophet) is my daily morning prayer: O Allah! Purge my heart of hypocrisy, My conduct from dissimulation, My tongue from falsehood, And my eyes from treachery, For You indeed know the treacherous glance of the eyes And that which the heart conceals. You will notice that the Quran describes the laws of human behaviour but puts the same across as what God does. This is so since these are nothing but the unchanging laws of God which work inexorably in the most consistent and unchanging fashion. If you notice, even the laws of nature are described as if God is actively doing something for example, holding a bird in flight and preventing it from falling. People take this literally and say that if God is allowing people to go astray or sealing up their hearts, or causing them to be “deaf, dumb and blind”, how can they be blamed? This is again more of self-deception and inability to take responsibility for the moral choices they themselves make or for the path that they have chosen even though God constantly reminds them that: (4:120) Satan makes them promises, and creates in them false desires; but Satan’s promises are nothing but deception. (35:5) O men! Certainly the promise of Allah is true. Let not then this present life deceive you, nor let the Chief Deceiver deceive you about Allah. (6) Verily Satan is an enemy to you: so treat him as an enemy. He only invites his adherents that they may become Companions of the Blazing Fire. ----- A frequent contributor to NewAgeIslam.com, Naseer Ahmed is an Engineering graduate from IIT Kanpur and is an independent IT consultant after having served in both the Public and Private sector in responsible positions for over three decades. He has spent years studying Quran in-depth and made seminal contributions to its interpretation. URL: https://newageislam.com/islam-science/quran-psychology-human-behaviour/d/127006 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism

Friday, May 13, 2022

The Profundity of Arabic Language and Its Encapsulated Wisdom

By Sumit Paul, New Age Islam 13 May 2022 Monotheistic Arrogance of Semitic Faiths Plagued Islam As Well And Muslims Thought That Pagan And Polytheistic Arabs Were Absolute Jahilaan (Plural Of Jahil), Not Being Aware That Pagan Arabia Produced The Finest Odes (Qasidah) Main Points: 1. Think twice before calling them (Arabs) uncultured and unsophisticated. 2. The advancement of a race is judged by its ability to use and create proverbs.' 3. List of superlative Arabic proverbs is endless. ----- I've always wondered as to why Arabs are often perceived as uncouth, boorish and desert-dwellers and their language (Arabic) is viewed as phonetically inferior? Agreed, Arabic, like Pashto, may not sound phonetically euphonic like Persian, it's a magnificent language and a repository of great wisdom. As for its robust hoarseness and being guttural, the existing geographical reasons can be adduced for that. Both Pashto and Arabic are guttural-fricative tongues as both originated from geographically harsh terrains; Arab Peninsula and Afghanistan. The problem with the world is that Arab culture and civilization is always seen with respect to the advent of Islam in the 7th century. Any development in any sphere in the Arab world, prior to Islam, is deliberately not considered worthwhile. Muslim 'scholars' are responsible for that as they concocted a pejorative term like Pre-Islamic Jahaliya (Qable-Islam Jahalat). The rest of the world thought that it was a benighted period for that region and Arabs had no significant history before Islam. The greatest western scholar of Arabic, Professor Sir Hamilton Gibb, who taught Arabic at Oxford and Cambridge, never liked the contemptuous term Pre-Islamic Jahiliya and eschewed using the word Jahiliya for Arabs throughout his life. Muslims may fallaciously think that it was Islam which 'educated' and 'enlightened' the desert yokels just like the condescending Brits thought that they 'educated' the 'savage' Indians and humanised the 'feral' non-whites of the continent of Africa. Totally wrong. The indigenous Indians and Arabs were already advanced before the marauding Muslim invaders attacked and spread Islam by all means in the sub-continent in 712 CE (when Muhammad Bin Qasim invaded Sindh) and Islam took roots in the Arab Peninsula a little over 1400 years ago. Sorry for the (relevant) digression, let me focus on Arabs. The Monotheistic arrogance of Semitic faiths plagued Islam as well and Muslims thought that Pagan and Polytheistic Arabs were absolute Jahilaan (plural of Jahil), not being aware that Pagan Arabia produced the finest odes (Qasidah): Seven Odes of Pre-Islamic/Pagan Arabia and the greatest Greek philosophers like Socrates, Aristotle, Plato, Diogenes, among others were either atheists or Pagans. Even the earliest Arab philosopher Moshef was a Pagan. Such patronising demarcation between the polytheists and monotheists was further strengthened by the sub-continental poet Dr Muhammad Iqbal's disparaging couplet in his Shikwa (Complaints): Tujh Se Pahle Tha Ajab Jahan Ka Manzar/Kahin Ma'abood Thay Patthar, Kahin Masjood Shajar (The world was in a state of veritable shambles before you/ People were worshipping and genuflecting before stones and trees.......a totally unnecessary and highly disdainful Sher that demeans all idolaters; whereas Iqbal's own ancestors were Sapru Brahmins from the Valley). So, Arabs were woefully Jahil (ignorant/benighted) in terms of not knowing Islam and its perceived 'greatness'. But the Arabs have always been intelligent people. By the way, Arabic is considered a West Semitic language, and it belongs to the family of languages with alphabetic scripts (such as Hebrew, Aramaic and Ethiopic) that all ultimately descend from ancient Phoenician. British scholar of Arabic literature and Persian Studies, Sir Arthur John Arberry collected thousands of Arabic sayings prior to Islam and also a cornucopia of Arabic aphorisms after Islam. It's very interesting to know that Arabs have always been adept at using Kahvatein (Masal in Arabic) and maxims. And according to philologists like Dr Suniti Kumar Chatterjee, ' The advancement of a race is judged by its ability to use and create proverbs.' Arabs were very advanced on this count. Can you believe that there've been more than 2,600 sayings in Arabic that are based on fools and their foolishness! My personal favourites are: Stupidity is contagious! Even Iblees refrains from arguing with a fool. One must follow the sense and spirit of this proverb in toto and never argue with those whose craniums are filled with the essence of bovine. Look askance when a fool speaks (a 5th century Arab saying). Compare this with Jawaab-E-Jahilan Baashad Khamoshi in Persian (The answer to ignorant is silence) or when you argue with a fool, you become two. It needs elaboration. The infectious stupidity of one will invariably rub off on you and you too will become like that. In other words, as if one wasn't enough that you've added yourself as well (Yak Na Shud, Do Shud in Persian)! Ponder over this brilliant Arabic proverb: He who doesn’t know, says “lentils.” Explanation: Those who don’t know the true story will just say anything as an explanation. This is particularly true about believers of any man-made faith, whose understanding (of faith) is awfully limited, but who try to defend it tooth and nail. Remember this in a larger context that there's no worldview so dangerous as the worldview of those who've not viewed the world. They've a cognitive dissonance with their own worldview. Or cogitate over this 6th century (before Islam) Arabic saying: Blood doesn't become water (Blood is thicker than water in English) or a pebble can support a barrel (Even a small effort can go a long way). The Crown of all is this 8th century Arabic idiom: Those without a pedigree, argue and abuse (English equivalent: A bumpkin is forever ready to fight). The list of superlative Arabic proverbs is endless. I gleaned just a few gems out of the ocean to make the readers realize the profundity of Arabic language, culture and civilization. Now think twice before calling them (Arabs) uncultured and unsophisticated. ---- An occasional columnist for New Age Islam, Sumit Paul is a researcher in comparative religions, with special reference to Islam. He has contributed articles to world's premier publications in several languages including Persian. URL: https://newageislam.com/islamic-society/arabic-language-encapsulated-wisdom/d/126996 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism

A New Face for Madrasas: Islam Is Not a Monolith and Madrasas Owe Allegiance to Diverse Schools Of Thought, Which Are Hybridising Into Further New Strains

By Moin Qazi, New Age Islam 13 May 2022 Indeed The Very Idea Of A University In The Modern Sense ‒A Place Where Students Congregate To Study A Variety Of Subjects Under Eminent Scholars, Is Generally Regarded As An Innovation First Developed At Al-Azhar Children studying in a Madrasa (representational image) | PTI ------- The Lodestar The silhouette of the large mosque, brick-like but for a bulbous dome, looks blurry in the downpour past the minarets as the imposing wide red brick gates herald you into the hallowed precincts of one of the most influential Islamic institutions in the world that frames Islamic discourse in the subcontinent. This is Darul Uloom, the hallowed seminary. It is the spiritual lodestar for South Asia’s 500 million Muslims and is considered a “citadel of Islam” amid the westernisation of the sub-continent. Inside, room after room is filled with students wrapped in shawls against the winter chill and wearing crocheted skullcaps. They squat cross-legged on mats, reading from Qur’ans that lie open before them, resting on low wooden bookstands. They are supervised by teachers, most of them respected elders, with shaved upper lips and faces framed by scraggly beards, many of them dyed with henna. A Muslim who has memorized all 6,236 verses of the Qur’an earns the right to be called a hafiz. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Also Read: Madrasa Education is a Clear Violation of the Human Rights of Children: Sultan Shahin asks UNHRC to make Muslim Countries Stick to their Pious Declarations ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Religious schools are a common feature of Muslim life. The most common of these schools are known as a madrasa. In general, madrasas focus on teaching the Qur’an, the recorded sayings of the Prophet Muhammad, sacred law and other Islamic subjects. Madrasas have a long and rich history. These schools were distinct from madrasas today. In addition to teaching the Qur’an and hadith, they also taught mathematics, science, and literature. The curriculum in these madrasas was taught invariably in Arabic, comprised usually Tafsir (Qur’anic interpretation), Shariah (Islamic law), hadith (sayings and deeds of Prophet Muhammad), Mantiq (logic) and Islamic history. The madrasa system is a thousand years old. The first major academic institution in the Muslim world, however, was founded by Nizam al-Mulk Abu Ali al-Hasan al-Tusi (1018-1092), the celebrated Persian scholar and vizier of the Seljuk Empire. Later, Nizam al-Mulk established numerous madrasas all over the empire that, in addition to providing Islamic knowledge, imparted secular education in the fields of science, philosophy, public administration, and governance. The earliest recorded South Asian madrasa was established in Ajmer, India in 1191 A.D. The Golden Age Madrasas have played an important role in the history of Islamic civilisation. They have been powerful nodes in the learning system and have been harbingers of several revolutionary achievements in fields as diverse as jurisprudence, philosophy, astronomy, science, religion, literature and medicine. It was only when the Golden Age of Islam began to decline that the madrasas lost their academic and intellectual purity, and ceded prime space to western-oriented education. The spread of madrasas played a key role in the consolidation of doctrinal positions and legal thinking, which now form the dominant position among Sunnis. In time, the Shias developed their religious seminaries, called Hawzas, which play a similar role. Some of the most famous madrasas are the Deoband in India, al-Azhar in Egypt, Hawzas of Qum in Iran and the Zaytunia in Tunisia. Negative Profiling Madrasas across the world have suffered a great loss of reputation in recent decades, thanks to a wave of extremism. They have been continually targeted with an avalanche of searing and strident critiques. In secular countries, the state has not only castigated madrasas but has attempted to wrest exclusive control over them. Some madrasas are indeed guilty of fostering extremism, but most aren’t. However, the negative stereotypes presented in some sections of the media do not present the true picture. The majority of madrasas present an opportunity, not a threat. For young village children, these schools may be their only path to literacy. For many orphans and the rural poor, madrasas provide essential social services: education and lodging for children who otherwise could well find themselves the victims of forced labour, sex trafficking, or other abuses. Rather than undermining the madrasa system, policymakers should engage it because the negative stereotyping has distracted us from the vast potential they possess to nurture the children and instill the right moral and civic values; Beards and bombast may make for good newspaper copy, but the reality of the madrasa system is far different: it is characterized by both orthodoxy and diversity and once we modernized them through meaningful convergence of all stakeholders, they would be an ally for India’s unmanageable educational infrastructure. Madrasa Curriculum It was the eighteenth-century scholar Mulla Nizamuddin Sahalvi who designed the educational curriculum for the mainstream Indian madrasas. Thus, the curriculum was named after him as “Dars-e-Nizami”. Madrasas generally taught calculation, grammar, poetry, history, and above all the Qur’an and sacred law. At a higher level, they taught literary subjects and arithmetic. While memorization of texts was emphasized, personal instruction, lectures, and imitation of the teacher by students were also held to be crucial to minimize errors in religious understanding. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Also Read: Evolution of Hadith Sciences and Need for Major Paradigm Shift in Role of Hadith Corpus and Scope of Madrasa Education ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ When the East India Company purchased the right to collect revenue in the Mughal provinces of Bengal, Orissa and Bihar from Emperor Shah Alam, one of the clauses in the purchase agreement was that the British company will not change the legal and administrative systems in those provinces. Obliged by the need to train judges and administrators to run those systems mostly operating under Hanafi Muslim laws, the company needed to devise a curriculum for the schools that it wanted to set up for its prospective employees. The British schools also adopted this syllabus. This syllabus was an adapted version of the original Dars-e-Nizami devised by Abu Ali Hasan ibn Ali Tusi, known as Nizam al-Mulk, for the higher education institution. The most notable contribution of the school is the formulation of Dars-i Nizamiyya, the standard education pattern of curriculum it pioneered in the mid-eighteenth century. The scholar who shepherded the design of the course was Maulana Nizamuddin Sihalvi of Lucknow. It is important to underline the innovative features of the new syllabus. Islamic education was normally divided into two categories: Manqulat or the transmitted sciences such as exegesis (Tafsir), traditions (hadiths) and jurisprudence (fiqh); and maqulat or the rational sciences in which logic, philosophy, theology, rhetoric and mathematics were taught. Without undermining the importance of Manqulat, which had previously dominated the curriculum, the Firang Mahal shifted the emphasis to Maqulat. Grammar, logic and philosophy acquired greater weightage in the teaching. Madrasa curricula, in most cases, offer courses like “Koran-i-Hafiz” (memorization of the Qur’an), Alim (allowing students to become scholars on Islamic matters), Tafsir (Qur’anic interpretation), Sharia (Islamic law), Hadith (injunctions of Prophet Muhammad), Mantic (logic), and Islamic history (mostly constructed and invariably avoiding any discussion on weak points of old Muslim leaders. Education being on the concurrent list, madrasas are in the domain of the state governments, officials in the HRD Ministry say. (Source: PTI file photo) ----- The Transformation Of Teaching Pedagogy From the eighteenth century, large parts of the Muslim world engaged with modernity in its colonial form, an encounter that transformed almost all aspects of Muslim societies. Modern schools, higher education institutions, new official languages, and, above all, a new epistemology was introduced. Madrasas continued to provide religious instructions, though in the process they went through remarkable transformations in form, teaching, and to some extent, content. The social composition of madrasas began to change, becoming less affluent and more rural, with the more inspirational Muslims joining western educational streams. The madrasas lost intellectual vitality and teaching became pedantic with hardly any scope for creative or intellectual development. Madrasas no longer retained the cutting-edge educational philosophy. The most important change was the shift from imparting knowledge of Manqulat (the branches of knowledge relating to belief and religion) and Maaqulat (branches relating to reason and wisdom) The First War of Indian independence of 1856 A.D. marked a division of the composite madrasa education into secular and religious spaces. This division can be seen in the Deoband and Aligarh traditions, where Sir Syed Ahmed Khan emphasized the development of an educational system according to the need of the time while Deoband insisted on preserving religious values and tradition in the Indian subcontinent. Sir Syed Ahmad Khan, who founded the Anglo-Mohammedan Oriental College in Aligarh in 1877 A.D., studied under the same teachers as the founders of Deoband. But he believed that the downfall of India's Muslims was due to their unwillingness to embrace modern ways. He decoupled religion from education and sought to emulate the culture and training of India's new colonial masters in his school. But Sir Syed’s intentions were vastly different from what others perceived. The purpose of this new school was not just to prepare students for jobs, Sir Syed’s key objective was that students should imbibe the new vision of knowledge-seeking which was changing civilizations elsewhere. Sadly it took us so many years to clear the misunderstandings about Sir Syed’s true mission. . The model received support from the British, although it was castigated by orthodox religious leaders who were hostile to any modern influences. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Also Read: RESTRUCTURING MADRASA EDUCATION: Muslim Opponents of India’s 'Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act' are Enemies of Indian Muslims ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Darul Uloom Deoband was founded in 1866A.D.to preserve Muslim identity and heritage in the face of British imperialism, which had replaced the rule of the Mughals. The Deoband leaders went back to Qur’anic basics and rigorously stripped out anything Hindu or European from the curriculum. Deoband’s founders made it the centre for “newfound scriptural conservatism in Islam,” according to Alexander Evans, a British diplomat who has researched south Asian madrasas The leaders of Deoband, therefore, went back to Qur’anic basics and rigorously stripped out anything Hindu or European from the curriculum. Deoband’s founders made it the centre of a “newfound scriptural conservatism in Islam”, The ideological foundations of the seminary have been distilled into a set of seven cardinal principles that define the school’s charter (Maslak). These are (1) Conformity with Islamic law (shari’a). (2) Sufi-inspired self-purification and the search for spiritual perfection (Suluk-I Batin). (3) Conformity to the principles that guided the Prophet and his companions (Sunna). (4) Reliance on the Hanafi law school. (5) Certitude and stability in true beliefs concerning the Hanafi theologian al-Maturidi. (6) Removal of unlawful things (muskrat), and especially the refutation of polytheism, innovations, atheism, and materialism. (7) Adherence to the principles personally embodied by the founders of the school, Muhammad Qasim and Rashid Gangohi. Nadwatul Ulama was launched in 1898 A.D. by a broad spectrum of ulema, traditionalists to modernists, who all believed that the Deoband-type madrasa education did not equip students for the challenges of modern life. Placing a greater emphasis on the liberating message of the Qur’an, Nadwa favoured certain departures from the traditional curriculum and emphasized the study of history. Nadwa’s tolerance to intra-Sunni differences made it attractive. Firang Mahal (foreigner’s palace, which is located in Luck now) is closely identified with the evolution of the educational pattern of madrasas in the Indian sub-continent. Firang Mihalis(scholars inhabiting Firang Mahil) trace their descent to the eleventh-century scholar and mystic Abd Allah Ansari of Herat, who in turn was a descendant of Ayyub Ansari, a close companion of Prophet Muhammad. Its scion, Mullah Hafiz grew into prominence during Mughal rule. In 1559 A.D. Emperor Akbar endowed him with madam-I-ma’ash, or revenue-free grant. In 1692 A.D., His great-grandson, Qutb al-Din was murdered during a land dispute (1695 A.D.) and the family suffered a financial jolt. Emperor Aurangzeb gifted them the present house which became known by the name Firangi Mahal. Scholars congregated here from all parts of India and Arabia, central Asia, and China. In 1896 A.D., Shibli Numani, the legendary Islamic scholar referred to Firang Mahalas as “The Cambridge of India.” In the late nineteenth century, a madrasa was formed and in 1905 A.D. a formal institution took shape under the name, Madrasayi Aliya Nizamiyya, which continued until 1969 A.D. While Deoband and its clones did not compromise on puritanism, there was a movement of educational reforms from within the realms of Islamic educationists that strongly believed that in the absence of modern education, Muslims will be unable to compete in the global employment market. These educationists were driven by social and economic concerns and believed that the community should adapt itself to the new currents. The Critique Critics often charge the madrasa system of anachronism, citing its insistence on the supreme pedagogical value of the old texts. The traditionalists argue that, apart from connecting students to the canonical tradition, the “Nizami curriculum” enhances the student’s mastery of every discipline and enables scholars to solve any contemporary problem. One of the most accomplished modern products of madrasas, who had a very close association with the Deoband seminary, Ebrahim Moosa, avers, “Few have been able to rebut the charge that the texts used are redundant and at times impenetrable, save to a few scholars who have spent their lives mastering them. Indeed most texts are frustratingly terse, forcing teachers and students to scour commentaries and super-commentaries for help.” He further argues, “For decades critics have petitioned for more lucid texts. But inertia has turned the texts and syllabus into inviolable monuments to the past. The result is that students are poorly prepared and lack the confidence to engage the tradition critically to meet the needs of a changing world. At its worst, the system recycles intellectual mediocrity as piety.” The modern Muslim reformist thinker, Fazlur Rahman, believed that the cultural isolation of madrasa students would lead to stagnation. Indeed, the puritan madrasas are already bellowing signs of a deeper dissatisfaction and fatigue with a redundant learning system. Rahman contextualized and described madrasa learning as follows: “With the decline in intellectual creativity and the onset of ever-deepening conservatism, the curricula of education… shrank and the intellectual and scientific disciplines were expurgated, yielding the entire space to purely religious disciplines in the narrowest sense of the word. Mechanical learning largely took the place of original thought. With the thirteenth century, the age of commentaries begins and it is not rare to find an author who wrote a highly terse text in a certain field, to be memorized by students and, then, to explain the enigmatic text, he authored both a commentary and a super commentary!” Shibli Nu’mani, a renowned twentieth-century scholar from within the madrasa circles has himself noted, “For us, Muslims, mere English [modern] education is not sufficient, nor does the old Arabic madrasa education suffice. Our ailment requires a ‘compound panacea’ (Maʿjun-I Murakkab)—one portion eastern and the other western.” These sentiments are true even though the local custodians of madrasas don’t acknowledge them. The curriculums are often fossilized, with some science and philosophy texts dating back to the thirteenth or fourteenth centuries. The Way Forward The issue of reforms of madrasas is however quite complex and the adoption of state-led modernisation has a complex interplay of several factors such as trust, financial incentives, the impact of state-led policies on the functioning of madrasas and its implications on the community resources, which the madrasas are now accessing for their finances, need to examine. Islam is not a monolith and madrasas owe allegiance to diverse schools of thought, which are hybridising into further new strains. The government’s understanding and strategy for dealing with madrasas need to evolve and transform from a black-and-white perception to a more wholesome one. The policymakers need to be more sensitive to the sentiments of Islamic clerics and attempts must be made against allowing the discussion to get reduced to “Secular versus Non-secular” and “Pro-Hindu versus Anti-Muslim” debates. The deep reservations of madrasa managers about the government are all not ill-founded and several of the duplicitous actions and policies of the state give enough ground for a creeping scepticism. Efforts to stay, “politically correct” have obfuscated the debate and discussion on how best to make modern education accessible to millions of poor Muslim youths so that they join the mainstream. The government understands that a proper strategy for dealing with madrasas needs to evolve from a black-and-white perception to a more wholesome one. Madrasas are multi-layered institutions and have a depth and diversity that requires a much-nuanced understanding on part of policy wonks. The government machinery needs to be properly sensitized to the sentiments of madrasa custodians and should refrain from reducing the whole issue to “Secular versus Non-secular” and “Pro-Hindu versus Pro-Muslim” debates. Madrasas are however not immune to change. Many of them are trying to forge a Muslim identity that is compatible with modern culture and resistant to the blandishments of radicalisation. What we should attempt is to make new madrasas, as well as universities, be patterned on ancient Samarkand or Bokhara rather than stressing only madrasa modernization. Let us take madrasas centuries back in history to their glorious traditions of the Islamic Golden Age. That may be more successful in winning the hearts and minds of the custodians of madrasas. Indeed the very idea of a university in the modern sense ‒a place where students congregate to study a variety of subjects under eminent scholars, is generally regarded as an innovation first developed at al-Azhar. Since the students are schooled in classical and modern science as well as secular and religious thought, they are better able to spot scriptural distortions. They also tend to be more connected to their communities as well as to the mainstream society and their stable sense of identity, religious and otherwise, shield them against radicalism. These madrasas are allies in India’s transition to modernity. ------ Moin Qazi is the author of the bestselling book, Village Diary of a Heretic Banker. He has worked in the development finance sector for almost four decades. URL: https://newageislam.com/islamic-society/madrasas-monolith-diverse-thought/d/126993 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism

Thursday, May 12, 2022

Why Don't Muslims Openly Condemn Female Genital Mutilation Or Female Genital Cutting Among Bohras?

By Sumit Paul, New Age Islam 12 May 2022 Religion Is a Relatively New Phenomenon in the Scope and Scheme of Human Civilization in Which Traditions Predated Organized Religions Main Points: 1. Female Genital Mutilation has roots in traditions, regions and cultures. 2. Gujarati-speaking Bohras still call a clitoris: Haram Ni Boti (a flesh of sin). 3. Whatever may be the reason, Islam, in a larger perview, practice and perspective, doesn't approve of female circumcision at all. ------ At the outset, FGM (Female Genital Mutilation) or FGC (Female Genital Cutting) is the practice of removing parts or all of a woman’s external genitalia for various purposes. This reprehensible practice is still prevalent among Bohras, a Shia sub-sect (Dawoodi Bohra Community and other smaller sub-sects, including the Suleimani and Alavi Bohras). Though Islam and its scriptures, Quran and Hadees, don't approve of clitoral removal or tampering, a 2017 investigation by Sahiyo found that FGC is also being done by some Sunni communities in parts of Kerala in southern India. This entails further research. Much more than being religious, this obnoxious practice has roots in traditions, regions and cultures. Religion is a relatively new phenomenon in the scope and scheme of human civilization in which traditions predated organized religions. French philosopher and professor of Islamic Studies, Henry Corbin (1903-1978), opined that cult and pre-cult practices percolated down to organized religions which came roughly 4,000 years ago. Even circumcision and clitoral cutting sneaked into Semitic religions as pre-religious customs and also as totem practices (Read, Le Coran and L'Islam by Roger Arnaldez). That Abraham was circumcised, so the followers of all three Abrahamic faiths also undergo circumcision is religiously incorrect. Or else, how’ll one explain why Christians completely stopped the practice of (male) circumcision after the 9th century? North African and East African tribes, Pagan cults as well as Coptic Christians of Egypt used to practise female circumcision and viewed a clitoris as a physical aberration (Binqaff: Yiddish word for Satan/Devil's Sore Thumb!). Now coming back to Bohras, who trace their roots back to the Fatimid dynasty of Yemen in the 11th century, obscure Pagan and Christian cults in that region were removing their girls' bazar (Arabic for clitoris) as a sinful growth (alnumuu alatham). That's why, Gujarati-speaking Bohras still call a clitoris: Haram Ni Boti (a flesh of sin). So, it must be cut or damaged. From a religio-feministic perspective, anthropologists like Lucas and Greer believed that man being forever scared of a woman's capacity of enjoying multiple orgasms, resorted to cutting her love-button because it (clitoris) exists solely for pleasure purpose having a dense network of nerves. Whatever may be the reason, Islam, in a larger perview, practice and perspective, doesn't approve of female circumcision at all. In fact, Muhammad Abdul Muzdar Mehdune's Urdu/Persian treatise Lazzat Un Nissa (Pleasure of Women) has a full chapter on Shifniq (Persian for clitoris. Its Sanskrit equivalent is 'shishnika'. See the close relation between Sanskrit and Persian) and its pleasure. In Pernilla Myrne's ' Female Sexuality in the Early Medieval Islamic World: Gender and Sex in Arabic Literature' one finds that Arabs, the most virile and sexually adventurous people on earth, gave utmost importance to a woman's pea (euphemism for a clitoris). So, in the light of such an exalted position of clitoris during love-making and original Islam's insistence on retaining it, why don't Muslims raise their voice against this primitive practice among Bohras? Why is Syedna silent on this sensitive issue? Isn't it time to stop it completely as an outright un-Islamic practice? Pakistan's legendary English columnist with The Dawn, Ardeshir Cowasjee, a very rich Parsi, once wrote a tongue-in-cheek piece on the female circumcision among Bohras. Though Bohras, like Ahmadiyyas, are almost non-Muslims in Pakistan, it needed gumption to write a piece on this quasi-tabooistic subject revolving around female genitalia. It wasn't offensive but laced with his characteristic acerbic wit. Bohras in Pakistan got the drift. Here in India, late Asghar Ali Engineer criticised this practice but his entreaties fell on deaf ears. This community is badly in need of reformers like Asghar Ali Engineer. ---- An occasional columnist for New Age Islam, Sumit Paul is a researcher in comparative religions, with special reference to Islam. He has contributed articles to world's premier publications in several languages including Persian. URL: https://newageislam.com/islamic-society/muslims-female-genital-mutilation-bohras/d/126987 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism

The Shaltoot Fatwa of Al-Azhar University, Shia-Sunni Conflict and Road to Peace

By Ghulam Ghaus Siddiqi, New Age Islam 12 May 2022 Theological Differences, Curbing the Rising Violence between Sunnis and Shias Is Possible Main Points 1. Al-Azhar University has always condemned extremism, Takfirism, and terrorism. 2. The goal of the Shaltoot Fatwa of Al-Azhar was to establish peace and harmony between Sunnis and Shias. 3. Reaffirming the Shaltoot Fatwa, Ahmed El-Tayeb, the leading Sunni Islamic scholar and the current Grand Imam of al-Azhar, rejected the notion of Takfir concerning Shia Islam. 4. True, the theological differences between Sunnis and Shias will continue, but the scholars of the two sects can work to create peace and harmony and curb suicide bombing. ---- Al-Azhar, the famous historical religious seminary of Egypt, is the only university in the Islamic world that is highly regarded throughout the Islamic world. Prominent scholars from around the Muslim world turn to this magnificent historical seminary and proudly add "Al-Azhari" to their names after completing their higher education. This university has always been known for its crucial role in the promotion of moderation in the Muslim world. The efforts of the university to bring people of different religions together are admirable. Extremism, Takfirism, and terrorism have always been condemned. The Al-Azhar Shia Fatwa is one such effort to combat rising Sunni-Shia extremism, Takfirism, and terrorism. The Al-Azhar Shia Fatwa, known in Arabic as the Shaltoot Fatwa, is reported to be an Islamic fatwa issued in 1959 on the topic of Shi'a–Sunni relations by Sunni scholar Shaikh Mahmood Shaltoot. The fatwa, as an outcome of a decade of collaboration between Sunni and Shia academics, was promulgated at the theological centre of Al-Azhar University, Dar al-Taqreeb al-Madhahib al-Islamiyyah (Centre for bringing together the diverse Islamic schools of thought). The Fatwa recognized Twelver Shi’ism as a ‘legitimate Islamic school of law’. The goal of this fatwa was to bridge the gap between different Islamic schools of thought, as well as create mutual respect, understanding, and appreciation for the contributions of each school to the development of Islamic jurisprudence. Despite the ecumenical fatwa, while Shaltoot was Grand Imam of Al-Azhar, he refused to establish an autonomous Shia chair at the university, which was one of the greatest wishes of Shia members of the theological centre of the university. Egyptian President Gamal Abdel Nasser is credited with inspiring this exceptional fatwa, which allows Shias, Alawites, and Druze into mainstream Islam after centuries of being deemed heretics and idolaters. Nasser envisioned it as a means of expanding his appeal and influence throughout the Arab world. The Fatwa, originally issued in Arabic, reads: السؤال «إن بعض الناس يرى أنه يجب علي المسلم لکي تقع عباداته ومعاملاته علي وجه صحيح أن يقلد أحد المذاهب الأربعة المعروفة وليس من بينها مذهب الشيعة الإمامية ولا الشيعة الزيدية، فهل توافقون فضيلتکم علي هذا الرآي علي إطلاقه فتمنعون تقليد مذهب الشيعة الإمامية الإثنا عشرية مثلاً» الجواب «1- إن الإسلام لا يوجب علي أحد من أتباعه اتباع مذهب معين بل نقول: إن لکل مسلم الحق في أن يقلد بادئ ذي بدء أي مذهب من المذاهب المنقولة نقلاً صحيحاً والمدونة أحکامها في کتبها الخاصة، ولمن قلد مذهباً من هذه المذاهب أن ينتقل الي غيره أي مذهب کان ولا حرج عليه في شيء من ذلك» «2- إن مذهب الجعفرية المعروف بمذهب الإمامية الإثنى عشرية، مذهب يجوز التعبد به شرعاً كسائر مذاهب أهل السنة، فينبغي للمسلمين أن يعرفوا ذلك، وأن يتخلصوا من العصبية بغير حق لمذاهب معينة، فما كان دين الله وما كانت شريعته بتابعة لمذهب أو مقصورة على مذهب، فالكل مجتهدون مقبولون عند الله تعالى، يجوز لمن ليس أهلا للنظر والاجتهاد تقليدهم والعمل بما يقررونه في فقههم، ولا فرق في ذلك بين العبادات والمعاملات.[ "الشيخ محمود شلتوت". المُعجَم الإسلامي. 2006. مؤرشف من الأصل في 24 سبتمبر 2015.]» English Translation of the Shaltoot Fatwa Question: Some believe that a Muslim must follow one of the four main schools of thought to practice religiously proper prayer and dealing, but Twelver Shia and Zaidi Shia schools of thought are not among them. Do you agree with this viewpoint and, for example, forbid adopting the Twelver Shia school of thought? Answer: 1) Islam does not require a Muslim to follow a particular Madhhab (school of thought). Rather, we say: that every Muslim has the right to follow one of the schools of thought which has been correctly narrated and its verdicts have been compiled in its books. And, everyone who is following such Madhahib [schools of thought] can transfer to another school, and there shall be no crime on him for doing so. 2) The Ja'fari school of thought, which is also known as "al-Shia al- Imamiyyah al-Ithna Ashariyyah" (i.e., The Twelver Imami Shi'ites) is a school of thought that is a religiously valid school of thought to follow in worship, just like other Sunni schools of thought. Muslims must be aware of this and therefore avoid unfair prejudice toward any one school of thought, because Allah’s Religion and His Divine Law (Shari'ah) were never limited to one school of thought. Almighty Allah accepts their jurists (Mujtahidoon), and it is permitted for "non-Mujtahids" to follow them and follow their teachings in worship (Ibadaat) and transactions (Mu'amilaat). Signed by Mahmood Shaltoot Original copy of the Fatwa: As a result of a slide toward Islamism in Al-Azhar and the rise of the Muslim Brotherhood in power in 2012, the head of the Faculty of Islamic Studies at Al-Azhar fiercely condemned the Shaltoot Fatwa (1959). He forbade worship according to the Shia tradition and condemned as heretics anyone who insulted the wives or companions of the Islamic prophet Muhammad. Al-Azhar also produced a book denouncing Shias during the time. However, Shaykh Ahmed el-Tayeb of Jamia Al-Azhar reaffirmed Shaikh Shaltoot's views in an interview after the Egyptian coup d'état in 2013. Ahmed Mohamed Ahmed El-Tayeb is a leading Sunni Islamic scholar and the current Grand Imam of al-Azhar and former president of al-Azhar University. He was appointed by the Egyptian President, Hosni Mubarak, following the death of Mohamed Sayed Tantawy in 2010. Reaffirming the Shaltoot Fatwa, he rejected the notion of Takfir concerning Shia Islam. The following is a transcript of his interview with the Egyptian television channel ‘Al Neel’. Question: Do you believe there is a problem with Shia beliefs? Answer: Never, 50 years ago, Sheikh Mahmoud Shaltoot, the then-Chancellor of Al Azhar, issued a fatwa stating that Shia School is the fifth Islamic school and equal to the others. Question: What should we do if our children convert to Shia Islam? Answer: Allow them to convert and embrace the Shia School. Do we condemn someone who abandons the Maliki or Hanafi schools? These students are just leaving the fourth school and joining the fifth. Question: Is it right that the Shias are becoming our relatives and marrying our children? Answer: What's the big deal about this? Marriage between people of two different schools of Islamic thought is legal. Question: Is it true that Shias have their own Quran? Answer: These are the old women's myths and superstitions. The Shia Quran is identical to ours, and even the script of their Quran is similar to our alphabet. Question: 23 clerics of a country (Saudi Arabia) issued a fatwa declaring Shias to be unbelievers (Kafirs) and heretics? Answer: Because Al-Azhar is the only authority that can issue fatwas for Muslims, the fatwa mentioned above is invalid and untrustworthy. Question: So what does the difference—being raised between the Shia and the Sunni—mean? Answer: These discrepancies are the result of foreign forces seeking to foment war between Shia and Sunni Muslims. Question: I have a serious question: "If the Shias reject Abu Bakr and Umar, how can you call them Muslims?" Answer: Yes, they do not accept them. But is the belief in Abu Bakr and Umar a part of the foundations of Islam? The narrative of Abu Bakr and Umar is historically significant, but it has nothing to do with religious foundations. Question: (Surprised by the response, the reporter inquires) Shia has a basic problem, which is that “they claim that their Imam of the time (Imam al-Asr) is still alive after 1,000 years.” Answer: Why isn't it feasible that he's still alive? But there's no reason why we, as Sunnis, should believe the same way they do. Question: (Referring to Shia Imam Mohammad Taqi al-Jawad, the 9th Imam, the reporter asked) The Shias believe that one of their Imams was only eight years old when he became Imam; is it feasible that an eight-year-old child could be the Imam? Answer: Why can't an eight-year-old child be the Imam if an infant in a cradle can be a prophet (Hazrat Jesus/Isaa peace be upon him)? It's not unusual. Although we as Sunnis may not embrace this belief, it does not harm their Islam, and they are Muslims. [End of Interview] The Shaltoot Fatwa and Shaykh Tayeb’s Interview must have been an attempt to curb the growing violence between Sunnis and Shia and bring them together on the path of mutual peace and respect. On the ground, however, they have not yet been shown to be effective. Suicide bombers continue to target Shia mosques and Imambaras. All of this is a product of the doctrinal and theological divide between Shias and Sunnis, as well as the concept of Takfir. True, there will always be theological differences between Sunnis and Shias, but earnest attempts can be made to raise awareness among the two sects of Islam that those differences should not be exaggerated to the point of murder, bloodshed, or suicide bombing. Scholars from both sides should work together to launch a campaign to educate ordinary Shia Sunni Muslims about the risks of permitting doctrinal disagreements to turn into bloodshed, suicide bombings, and violence. This is the platform on which Shias and Sunnis can agree and develop a unity-in-diversity relationship. ----- A regular Columnist with NewAgeIslam.com, Ghulam Ghaus Siddiqi Dehlvi is an Alim and Fazil (Classical Islamic scholar) with a Sufi background and English-Arabic-Urdu Translator. Related Article: If Shias And Sunnis Cannot Be United On Theological Grounds, What Is The Possible Approach To Prevent Bloodshed And Suicide Bombings Against One Another? URL: https://newageislam.com/islamic-ideology/shaltoot-fatwa-azhar-shia-sunni-/d/126986 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism

Wednesday, May 11, 2022

The Truth about Tolerance: Much of the Strife and Misunderstanding of the Qur’an Is On Account Of Selective Reading of Verses That Promote the Adversaries’ Agenda

By Moin Qazi, New Age Islam 11 May 2022 Islam Prescribes the Principles of Justice and Equity for Peace and Human Development and Compassion for All of Mankind Main Points: 1. Islam is a universal religion speaking to humanity. 2. For some, the peace of God is through his sword; for others, it is found in his unbounded mercy. 3. If you want peace, you can find peaceable verses. ------ Islam is a religion of peace. That is its aim and goal. The Qur’an's powerful commandment should leave one in no doubt, "Whosoever killeth a human being for other than manslaughter or corruption in the earth, it shall be as though he had killed all of mankind, and whoso saveth the life of one, it shall be as if he had saved the life of all mankind" (Q5:32). At its very core, Islam prescribes the principles of justice and equity for peace and human development and compassion for all of mankind. Not to mention that the very root word of Islam itself is derived from the word salaam (peace). Islam is a universal religion speaking to humanity. The Prophet in his last great address at Arafat summed up his philosophy by decrying barriers between people. Islam, for him, transcended divisions of caste, colour, and race. “All mankind is from Adam and Eve, an Arab has no superiority over a non-Arab nor a non-Arab has any superiority over an Arab; also a white has no superiority over a black nor a black has any superiority over white except by and good action.” Much of the strife and misunderstanding of the Qur’an is primarily on account of selective reading of verses that promote the adversaries’ agenda. The voice of the text is the fruit of dialogue. For some, the peace of God is through his sword; for others, it is found in his unbounded mercy. The entire paradigm is built around human interpretation. The pacifists and the terrorists read the same text but present fundamentally different interpretations. It is important to consider the reader and interpreter of the Qur’an. The voice of the Qur’an heard by Islamic fundamentalists is not the same as the voice heard by progressive Muslims. The entire verses of the Qur’an must be read and understood in conjunction with each other. Reading and interpreting verses in isolation is an incorrect way of engaging with the Qur’an. It would yield a meaning that conforms to your own worldview. The Qur’an contains injunctions that call both for peace and for violence. The problem is that non-violent and militant Muslims appear equally justified by the logic they expound for their actions in the particular situation in which they have to interpret the words of the Qur’an. Part of the problem is that there are concerns about religious content that are not dealt with openly. There are just too many hard conclusions made about religious texts often made by those who know less than they claim. Many of them may be outright non-believers of any organised religion. The entire dilemma can be resolved by using a simple understanding which can be used for avoiding too much of unnecessary bitterness. The fact is that a religious text contains violent verses doesn’t make it a violent religion. The enemy of peace is not religion, but those who pursue acts of terror and violence against the innocent in the name of religion. For them, their religion is not their guide; it is more of a tool for justifying their own selfish and ill-intentioned concerns. There have been several strands of thought on the fate of people who abandon Islam. But even here the last word is still awaited. Moreover, the entire issue has been discussed widely over the last many years and there are clear and convincing opinions from jurists. The scholars are still combing historical chronicles and their own expertise in reaching a consensus that is just and at the same time doesn’t tinker with the basic Qur’anic injunctions on apostasy. At the same time Muslims endorse that people in every country should be free to choose and live their faith based upon the persuasion of the mind and the heart and the soul. Freedom of religion is central to the ability of people to live together. Faith is an intensely personal issue and each person should be allowed to find their path in life. An oft-quoted Qur'anic passage (2:256) famously declares, "There is no compulsion in religion, the right direction is clearly distinguished from the wrong." It is probably true that in every faith ordinary people will pick the parts they like best and practice those, while the scholars will work out an official version. In Islam, the scholars had a particularly challenging task, given the mass of contradictory texts within the Qur’an. To meet this challenge they developed the rule of abrogation, which states that wherever contradictions are found, the later-dated text abrogates the earlier one. To elucidate further the original intention of Prophet Mohammed, they referred to traditions (hadith) recording what he had said and done. Sadly for the rest of the world, both these methods led Islam away from peace and towards war. At this point, we must understand that the Qur'an was revealed over a long time? We will explore the ones provided by Allah in the Qur’an itself. “And said those who disbelieved, ‘Why has the Qur’an not been revealed to him all at once?’ (It has been sent down) in this way (i.e. in parts) so that We make your heart firm, and We revealed it little by little.” (Qur’an 25:32) “And We have divided the Qur’an into portions, so that you may recite it to the people gradually, and We have revealed it little by little. (Qur’an 17:106) The main bone of contention between those who represent the pacifist face of Islam and those who talk of violence is that many of them are not aware of the context. There is no hierarchy of verses in the Qur’an. Those who privilege the first verse over the second will wage war to fight injustice. And most militant Muslims invoke this verse in the defence of their actions. But then there are Muslims who privilege the second verse and seek a diplomatic end to persecution through forgiveness. The two verses above are exemplary of the tension between realism and idealism in Islam. But in the final analysis, Islam is what Muslims make of it. Some verses are very often snipped out of context by mischief-makers to inflame emotions, foster misunderstandings, and perpetuate violence on all sides. For example, the current modern definition of jihad is contrary to the linguistic meaning of the word and also contradicts the beliefs of many Muslims, who equate it with religious extremism. The word jihad stems from the Arabic root “J-H-D” which means “strive”. Other words derived from this root include “effort,” “labour” and “fatigue”. Essentially, jihad is a struggle to stand by one’s religion despite persecution. Prophet Muhammad explained that true jihad was an inner struggle against egotism. There is a lot of misunderstanding on account of this verse, “Slay them wherever you catch them…” (Chapter 2, verse 191). But who is this referring to? Who are “they” in this verse? They are those who persecute and kill the innocent for their faith. By far the majority of Muslims today live their lives without recourse to violence. If you want peace, you can find peaceable verses. If you want war, you can find bellicose verses. You can find verses that permit only defensive jihad, or you can find verses to justify offensive jihad. In chapter three verse eight the Qur’an calls out people who cherry-pick verses as “perverse”. It is this reason why modern Islamic reformers like Fazlur Rahman have asked for a contextual understanding of the Qur’an and pleaded for differentiation between historical and normative Islam. The adversaries of Islam draw on selected Islamic texts and examples that suggest a militant Islam bent on conquering the world for Allah. This is a false narrative, one that misses the variegated mixture of ideas, doctrines and historical experiences that exist in Islam—as in every major religion. In particular, it ignores the innumerable positive developments large and small, grassroots and doctrinal, that in our time is leading to a more tolerant Islam. Islam promotes and teaches humans to practice balance in all aspects of life with moderation. As humans we are influenced by our culture and traditions; political, economic, and psychological experiences not only shape our attitudes and behaviours but separate and divide us. Consequently, our world views and religious views differ from place to place, era to era, and across cultures and thereby irresponsibly link religion, in this case, Islam, to the oppression of women. The alleged retrograde practices of the community take the world’s focus away from understanding the overwhelming problems of the Muslim world and the cause of its troubles. Not to mention, it provides an easy scapegoat for those looking to legitimize their illegitimate actions which are detrimental to humanity. This is one of the reasons for this unnecessary bitterness over plainly innocuous customs and practices like hijab, which have culturally bonded these cultures over the years. When the Prophet Muhammad returned victorious to Mecca after twenty years, he bore no animosity for those who had persecuted him and his followers and forced them to migrate. The only condition he imposed was that universal freedom of conscience should be accepted in Mecca. Historian Stanley Lane-Poole said, “The day of Muhammad’s greatest triumph over his enemies was also the day of his grandest victory over himself. He freely forgave the Quraysh all the years of sorrow and cruel scorn in which they had afflicted him and gave an amnesty to the whole population of Mecca.” We have denuded religion of its humanist content, compassion, piety, tolerance and fairness, and reduced it to a rigid set of social codes and practices considered the only valid credentials for attaining salvation. Fake religious leaders have adopted the responsibility of collective salvation, freeing humanity of its own individual moral and spiritual accountability. We need to think and act at our level and abandon this trend of seeking salvation in herds if we want to achieve our moral redemption. This is the distilled essence of all divine revelations. The divine books are the work of an infallible God, but human-mandated practices that have shrouded the original divine message are products of the minds of fallible human beings. This is the root cause of misunderstanding about religions and the wrong beliefs that abound in adherents, most of whom are illiterate or are intellectually incapable of comprehending the scriptures. History tells us that politics plays a vicious role when there is a clash between beliefs and truth. Society has paid a heavy price for allowing politics to have its sway. We should grow wiser from the lessons of history. Let history not repeat itself. Let us not play with precious human lives. Iranian poet Sa'adi, from the 13th century, is one of the major influential Persian poets of the medieval period. He is recognised in the literary world for the quality of his writing style and in the spiritual realm for the depth of his thoughts. Sa'adi is best known for his works 'Gulistan' and 'Bostan', where his poetry emphasised unity in mankind, and independence for every individual regardless of social barriers and labels. Many of his poems greatly impacted India and influenced Central Asia. One particular poem written eight centuries ago became a motto and decorates the gate of the United Nations building entrance. Bani Adam, the Children of Adam, is an aphorism calling for the breaking of all barriers and was quoted by President Obama in a meeting with Iranian leaders. A simpler translation of the poem goes like this: The sons of Adam are limbs of each other, Having been created of one essence. When the calamity of time affects one limb The other limbs cannot remain at rest. If you have no sympathy for the troubles of others, You are unworthy to be called by the name of a Human. Then we have the famous verse signifying the essence and spirit of dialogue: Guftagu Band Na Ho Baat Se Baat Chale Subah Tak Sham-E-Mulakaat Chale... Regzaron Se Adavat Ke Guzar Jayenge Khoon Ke Dariyaon Se Hum Paar Utar Jayenge (Keep the dialogue going, one word leading to another, The evening rendezvous lasting till dawn We shall cross the deserts of hate And bridge the rivers of blood). (Ali Sardar Jafri-Sarhad) ------ Moin Qazi is the author of the bestselling book, Village Diary of a Heretic Banker. He has worked in the development finance sector for almost four decades. URL: https://newageislam.com/islamic-ideology/tolerance-quran-verses-adversaries-agenda/d/126977 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism

Tuesday, May 10, 2022

A Rejoinder with Proofs

By Sumit Paul, New Age Islam 19 May 2022 Bashar Ke Zehan Pe Qarnon Se Jo Musallat Hain/Badal Raha Hoon Gumaanon Mein Un Yaqeenon Ko -Shabbir Hasan Khan 'Josh' Malihabadi (I’m turning the so-called truths into doubts that have clouded the human minds for ages). I usually refrain from replying, let alone hitting back, lest the decorum of a debate or a discourse should degenerate into a state of outright mud-slinging and shambles. But, I felt constrained to reply to Mr Naseer Ahmed's long drivel that amounts to zilch and smacks more of a personal attack. At the outset, let me make it clear that my rejoinder ain't a personal attack. It's an educated man's courteous reply to a gentleman who cannot see beyond his religion and its scriptures, whom he considers as oracular, nay Gospel, truths. Well, I don't resort to translations of Quran. I know enough Arabic to write articles in this Semitic tongue. That's why, I can dare say that Quran is NOT a monoglot screed. I'm sure, Mr Naseer Ahmed doesn't know Arabic like a native speaker and writer. So, I suggest that he must read Christoph Luxenburg's ' The Syriac-Aramaic Version of the Quran.' A serious reader or researcher can comprehend once it's conceded that many of Quranic words are Syriac-Aramaic rather than Arabic. The quintessential example being: The rewards of a “martyr" in paradise: when rendered and redacted, the heavenly offering consists of sweet white raisins rather than virgins! Now tell me, isn't a classic Catch-22 situation for a (devout) Muslim? If he argues that no, it's virgin, then is Allah so frivolous as to tempt you like a human with something so fleshy and carnal and if it's indeed 'sweet white raisins', what's so great about it? --------------------------------------------------------------- Also Read: Let's Scrutinise Certain 'Facts' In the Al-Furqan --------------------------------------------------------------- Furthermore, your self-detonating 'crusaders' of Islam have been blowing themselves off for mere 'sweet white raisins'? What a humungous let down! When there's so much ambiguity in deciding whether one gets virgin Houries or just Kishmish in heaven for killing Kafirs, shouldn't the Book be criticized for such semantic confusions and conundrums? And when Quran speaks about virgins, I wonder, is their hymen forever intact despite the interminable sessions of love-making with Mujahids? Or else, what does a virgin mean? On the verge, but not in? In short, the fact remains that Islam's core claim-to be unimprovable and FINAL-is at once preposterous and unalterable. --------------------------------------------------------------- Also Read: The Al Furqan Prevails As It Must --------------------------------------------------------------- Its many warring and discrepant sects, from Ismaili to Ahmadi, all agree on this indissoluble claim. The Quran claims that god is absolute. He doesn't include anyone in his scheme of things. There's not a single interpolation and all that jazz. Yet, I'm afraid, Muslim scholars acknowledge that at least fifty of the second caliph Umar's own ideas were incorporated into the Al-Furqan. These include ordering women to wear veils, which was a custom copied and percolated from the Byzantine Christians, and other doctrines that have had an emphatic impact on Islam. In spite of these anomalies, the Quran declares itself to be free from discrepancies. --------------------------------------------------------------- Also Read: Qur'an 5:51 - A Humanistic Interpretation --------------------------------------------------------------- Many of the 'revelations' in the Quran are there to suit Muhammad's own agenda. The Quran itself tells us that some of Muhammad's followers regarded his meddling with the revelations as nothing less than forgery. And what about the rampant misogyny in the 'Holy' Book? All too often, textual reality (the Quran) matches up with the historical reality of seventh— century Arabia. Gender inequality and oppression in the Quran reflect the culture of seventh century desert nomads. A couple of examples are enough to give you a peek into the misogynistic mind of Allah or Muhammad: The Quran in Sura (Chapter) 2:223 says: Your women are your fields, so go into your fields whichever way you like . . . . (MAS Abdel Haleem, The Qur'an, Oxford UP, 2004) We should make no mistake about this verse. It includes sexual positions. In a footnote to this verse, Haleem says that Muslims in Medina heard from the Jews that 'a child born from a woman approached from behind would have a squint.' Slave—girls are sexual property for their male owners. The Quran in Sura 4:24 says: And forbidden to you are wedded wives of other people except those who have fallen in your hands [as prisoners of war] . . . (Maududi, vol. 1, p. 319). And what about Muhammad’s scandalous love affair with Mariyah the Copt who was one of the prophet’s wives’ maids. Muhammad slept with her without any ceremony, which caused uproar among his wives and had to be settled through the “Divine intervention.” I don't believe in stretching my arguments a tad too far. Ergo, I rest my case. Don't we say, if you try to dig out earthworms, snakes will come out, venomous at that? So, we had better stop here before things get too murky and volatile for all to digest. Beware of the fury and wisdom of a patient man. Never provoke anyone without doing proper homework. Remember, people who live in glass houses ought not to throw stones at others. Lastly, thanks, Mr Naseer for stirring my erudition. Please learn a lesson in humility and acceptance from Messrs Sultan Shahin and Ghulam Mohiyuddin. Stop being a zealot. ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Also Read: According To Quran 5:51, Can Muslims Not Accept Non-Muslims As Friends? ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Well, before I forget, I must mention that I didn't study religions to make fun of them. I studied them (religions) to know their cumulative ill-effects on mankind. Scriptures of all the man-made faiths are already funny. They invariably make even a sullen person laugh. I'm no exception. I'm an apatheist. I've gone beyond theism and atheism. Religion and god make NO sense to me. ---- An occasional columnist for New Age Islam, Sumit Paul is a researcher in comparative religions, with special reference to Islam. He has contributed articles to world's premier publications in several languages including Persian. URL: https://newageislam.com/islam-pluralism/furqan-humanistic-interpretation-quran/d/126969 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism

Islam and Modern Age: Is There Light at the End of the Tunnel?

By Dr. Mohammad Ghitreef, New Age Islam 10 May 2022 It Is Not Possible That You Maintain A Closed Mind In Theology And Perform Marvellously In Science Main Points: 1. Muslims must understand that if they want development and progress, they will have to provide a suitable atmosphere for free-thinking and freedom of experience 2. Humankind and its thought do not go ahead in isolation or in a vacuum 3. Voices of reform in religion, anti-church, liberal, and pro-change currents had been stirred everywhere ----- Muslims must understand that if they want development and progress, they will have to provide a suitable atmosphere for free-thinking and freedom of experience, a prerequisite to innovation and creativity. Indeed, the reform package is a complete package. You have to adopt it in Toto, not in parts. You have to open the door of reform in both religion and society. It is not possible that you maintain a closed mind in theology and make marvellous progress in science. Free thinking is a must for both religion and science. Languages draw on other languages, new ideas are derived from different beliefs, and cultures borrow from other cultures. Likewise, human civilizations benefit from other past and present civilizations, which means that humankind and its thought are not going ahead in isolation or in a vacuum. When they started their civilizational journey, Muslims also benefited from other contemporary civilizations; Roman, Persian, Egyptian, Indian, etc. Yet when they declined, and the Western civilization replaced them and took the reins of the world in its hand, this trend was not reiterated. -------------------------------------------------------------------------- Also Read: Islam And Modernity: The Compatibility Question -------------------------------------------------------------------------- Renaissance had ample opportunity to flourish after this process of give and take in the sixteenth- seventieth centuries, meaning that having much benefited from the translation movement from Arabic into first Latin then all the major languages of Europe like German, French, English, etc. Voices of reform in religion, anti-church, liberal, and pro-change currents had been stirred everywhere. The renaissance movement influenced people in Europe from different schools of thought differently. The people associated with this movement saw themselves as an advanced class and fought against religious and political persecution. In its aftermath all the negative notions of irrationality, arbitrariness, obscurity, and superstition of the last centuries vanished. With this powerful renaissance movement in Europe, Enlightenment gained momentum. Modernity has encouraged new ideas and thoughts and given free thinkers full opportunities to express themselves. And the effects of this movement were felt all over the world. French Revolution, which vigorously rebelled against traditional modes and sought to change every old thing with the modern one, eventually led to the American war of Independence. In the wake of all this, social, economic, and political theories changed drastically, leading to the Industrial Revolution and the European colonial spree in Asia, Africa, and Muslim lands. As far as the Muslim world is concerned, new ideas had come along with colonial powers, but there was profound suspicion about these new realities; renaissance, liberalism, etc. Conspiracy theories had been there at play, and Muslim Ulama and intellectuals were very reluctant to accept new ideas. The West has changed its political, social, and religious set up in the last three centuries. Still, even after gaining Independence from colonialism, Muslim scholars have been inclined to reject Western ideas as a product of a secular outlook. In parallel, they turned to a relatively closed and more rigid religious and political system and style of government, where concepts of power, dictatorship, enforcement, and authoritative rule became more important than religious rethinking and reconstruction. With the exception of Muslims, each faith group and nation in the world has, in one manner or some other, integrated present-day notions into its system of thinking and action. There are many reasons why Muslims do not accept Western views. On the one hand, the design of religious beliefs devised by the Muslims in later periods was inflexible in its logic, and no new concept could enter into it. Especially since their order had primarily become independent of its sources, the Quran and Hadees, and had become an automatic makeup. Each new concept and viewpoint collided with some of the features of that system and was therefore considered unacceptable. Because that tradition did not retain the openness and splendour of the early centuries, even some twentieth-century scholars such as Moulana Ahmad Raza Khan thought Copernicus and Galileo's research to be contrary to Islamic beliefs. And they followed the Ptolemaic concept of the motion of the stars, which for a long time dominated the world as a scientific theory. -------------------------------------------------------------------------- Also Read: Tradition and Traditionalism in Muslim Community --------------------------------------------------------------------------- There are many other reasons why modern ideas did not take root in Muslim lands. First, the pre-colonial education system in Muslim countries contrived by courtier Ulama and scholars teaches the reader an absolute submission to kings and emperors. Giving them the title shadow of God ( ظل الهي), making the human mind subject to sheer obedience, resignation, and rigidness. This ambience ranged from classroom to textbooks and subjects fostering authoritative culture and values. Stirring minds to think was not one of its goals, for questioning was forbidden. Therefore, the lack of personal freedom once ensured by Hazrat Umar, the second caliph of Islam and others, which human beings should have had, has affected their economic life. And there has been a complete ignoring of new means of production. Economic stagnation, overpopulation, and intellectual stagnation were the three deadly plagues that plagued Muslims. In fact, the efforts made in Islam regarding Ijtihad, as it seems to me, have been made ever, not consciously but under a particular need. One of the reasons for close-mindedness in Muslims is the predominance of ignorance. This ignorance is not in public only, but it is profound among scholars. They do not look at the Islamic injunctions in their evolving historical context; instead, they take them as eternal, ignoring whether the present age accepts some old Islamic injunctions or not. It resulted in such extremism we witness now that ordinary people take liberalism, secularism, and democracy as something amounting to be infidelity and Kufr and draw the sword from their sheath against them. It is the fault of the modern apologists of Islam like Maududi, Qutub, Ali Shariati, Ali Nadwi, et al. They waged a wrong jihad against modernity. They advocated for a religious structure based only on command, obedience, and blind imitation of Salaf (predecessors). Leaving no room for fresh thinking and inventing new ideas. And in this paradigm, they excluded the modern understanding of universal values from the realm of Islam and called modernity a misleading way. Among the Muslim countries, which are relatively more developed and have their eyes on the future, are the ones that have adopted one of the two alternative spheres of thought, secular or sacred. Turkey has adopted a sophisticated style and seeks to enforce it as a way of life through state power. She has succeeded to some extent. Turkey has gained Independence from many of the problems facing other Islamic nations. Despite the conservative religious theology of fixation and a conservative collective psyche, India was the land where, while maintaining the spiritual roots, Sir Syed Ahmad Khan developed a new critical approach to understanding and interpreting religion. As a result of his efforts, a window was opened for Indian Muslims, despite strong opposition from conservative Maulvies. Which shows what is happening in the western world. Unfortunately, this movement was also hijacked midway by landlords and Ulama after Khan's demise. In Muslim societies, the tribal or feudal societal structure is generally predominant. This structure is compatible only with the monarchical system and gives rise to command, obedience, and blind following. The historically existing paradigm mentioned above is one of the main reasons this structure has remained strong in the history of Muslims. For instance, the government of Saudi Arabia cuts off the hands of the common thief but the wealth of the country, which is owned by a family and where freedom of speech is lacking, where the king's decree is divine judgment. How many royal family members then were convicted of seizing state resources? We cannot understand that logic has left Aristotle far behind, replaced by a new worldview based on natural science and now cosmology. I can summarize the Muslim malaise as follows. 1-Muslims, throughout the ages, had been the victim of a ruthless triangle of kings, papacy, and priesthood, as called by Iqbal اے کشتہ سلطانی وملائی وپیری (one who is ruined by sultans, mullahs, and priests). So Muslim psyche is built on absolute obedience to literalism promoted by that old paradigm. 2-Women had been traditionally kept inside the home strictly, deprived of all their freedoms, dignity, and individual rights. 3- Individual was suppressed by the burden of collectivism. His freedom was slaughtered on the altar of society and collective wisdom. 4- All the educational systems developed in Muslim lands were established, run, financed, aided, or controlled by the elite, the rulers, the aristocrats, the big courtiers, and community elders. It was based only on memorizing and thinking nothing, ensuring the protection of vested interests and absolute submission to rulers, mullahs, and priests, thus negating individualism forcefully in all walks of life. All that is needed is for us to change the system that is prevalent in our Islamic seminaries today as a first step to the direly needed renaissance. And what I mean by that is not only to include English and science subjects in these madrassas, but to change the whole curriculum used in religious education. Muslims must understand that if they want development and progress, they will have to provide a suitable atmosphere for free-thinking and freedom of experience, a prerequisite to innovation and creativity. Indeed reform package is a complete package. You have to adopt it in Toto, not in parts. You have to open the door of reform in both religion and society. It is not possible that you maintain a closed mind in theology and perform marvellously in science. Free thinking is a must for both religion and science. ---- Dr. Mohammad Ghitreef is a Research Associate with the Centre for Promotion of Educational and Cultural Advancement of Muslims of India, AMU Aligarh. URL: https://newageislam.com/islamic-society/modern-age-social-development-ulema-/d/126968 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism

Debunking Islamophobic Myths about 26 Wartime Verses: Part 4

What Is The Background Of Three Quranic Verses Prohibiting Friendship With Non-Muslims (9:23, 5:51, And 5:57)? Main Points: 1. It is a popular misconception that Islam prevents Muslims from establishing friends and forming social interactions with others. 2. Thinking that befriending non-believers can lead to Kufr is an extremely flawed line of thinking. 3. In these verses, awliya needs to be understood as guardians or patrons in the historical and strict military sense. ------ By Kaniz Fatma, New Age Islam 29 April 2022 This part will attempt to debunk Islamophobic myths about three verses of the Quran because the subject of all three verses is the same. Allah says (interpretation of the meaning): “O People who Believe! Do not consider your fathers and your brothers as your friends if they prefer disbelief over faith, and whoever among you befriends them – then it is he who is unjust.” (9:23) “O People who Believe! Do not take the Jews and the Christians your friends; they are friends of one another, and whoever among you befriends them, is one of them; indeed Allah does not guide the unjust.” (5:51) “O People who Believe! Those who have made your religion a mockery and a sport, and those who received the Book before you, and the disbelievers – do not befriend any of them; and keep fearing Allah, if you have faith.” (5:57) Allah Almighty has prohibited believers from establishing Muwalaat (friendship in matters of religion) with Jews, Christians, disbelievers, polytheists, and apostates in the aforementioned three verses of the Quran, and has conveyed His disapproval and indignation at those who do so. Based on this principle, many Islamophobes and radical Muslims say that Islam prevents Muslims from forming friends with non-Muslims. They cite the verses mentioned above to prove their point. So it is essential to examine the meaning of Muwalaat/Awliya in these verses, as well as whether Muslims can accept non-Muslims as friends. The following is a summary of Haris Aziz's treatise: The word Awliya has various meanings such as friends, protectors and guardians, and if the meaning is taken to be friends then it seems to contradict the Islamic message of peace and cooperation. The context and the historical background of this verse have been well explained by David Dakake. In this verse, Awliya needs to be understood as guardians or patrons in the strict military sense. The word Awliya means ‘Friends, protectors, and guardians, and if this means ‘friends’ in verse 5:51, it will appear to contradict the Islamic message of peace and cooperation. David Dakake has provided a thorough explanation of the context and historical history of this verse. In this verse, Awliya must be taken as guardians or patrons in the strict military sense. This is because Muslims were in a perilous position in Medina at the time this verse was revealed, with the Makkans plotting an attack on them and some Christian and Jewish tribes scheming against them. As a result, Muslims were told to strengthen themselves and not rely on others unnecessarily. Al-Tabari, one of the oldest commentators on the Quran, explains the entire context. Furthermore, if we read the verses immediately after 5:51, verse 5:57 confirms the meaning even further: “O you who have believed, take not those who have taken your religion in ridicule and amusement among the ones who were given the Scripture before you nor the disbelievers as Awliya. And fear Allah, if you should [truly] be believers.” (5:57) This demonstrates that, while Muslims should cooperate with non-Muslims in general and form friendships with well-intentioned non-Muslims, they should be wary of appointing as a guardian someone who despises Islam or does not want Muslims well. It's distressing to note that, despite the fact that a simple technique leads to the correct interpretation, this verse is not only misused by anti-Islamic organisations, but also by some hate-mongering Muslim groups. Similarly, a warning (Quran 5:82) regarding the animosity of the Jews of Medina toward Muslims must be viewed in its historical context and should not be taken to mean that Muslims should be hostile to them. (Islamic Political Radicalism – A European Perspective, Edited by Tahir Abbas, Anti-Semitism Amongst Muslims – Haris Aziz, Edinburgh University Press, p79-80, cited in https://osmanisnin.wordpress.com/2022/01/02/what-does-awliya-mean-in-quran-551-can-muslims-take-non-muslims-as-friends/) According to Mufti Badruddoja, a classical Indian scholar, These verses prohibit demonstrating Muwalaat (religious friendliness) to Jews, Christians, Infidels, polytheists, and apostates, but they do not prohibit Muamalat with them, that is, buying, selling, conducting transactions, establishing peaceful cohabitation, and sitting together. These verses do not prohibit people from engaging in worldly affairs as long as they do not damage one another. Those who accuse the Quran of encouraging hatred and violence need to comprehend the difference between Muwalaat and Mua’amalat. They are not related to one other. It's possible that you do Mua’amalat (worldly affairs) with someone all your life, such as transactions, buying and selling, but you don't even have a nominal acquaintance with them. It's also possible that you've developed a friendship, emotion, or propensity for someone but have never transacted or coexisted with them. This distinction has revealed that “neither friendship is indispensable for Mua’amlaat nor Muwalat or friendship for Mua’amlaat”. The distinction between Mua'amalat and Mua’amlaat is significant. In the aforementioned verses, Allah Almighty prohibits Muwalat with Jews, Christians, unbelievers, polytheists, and apostates; however He Almighty does not prohibit believers from establishing Mua'amalat, or trade or peaceful coexistence with them. (Summarized The Verses of Jihad in The Quran - Meaning, Denotation, Reason of Revelation and Background - Part 6) When we examine the exegesis (Tafsir) of these verses critically, we can determine that they are specifically referring to prohibiting an alliance with non-Muslims who wished to damage the Muslim community. Furthermore, these verses were revealed in the midst of political strife, not during a period of peace. It is a popular misconception that Islam prevents Muslims from establishing friends and forming social interactions with others. It contradicts both current reality and Islamic history. It's also a hazardous viewpoint, as some have claimed that befriending non-believers can lead to Kufr. This line of thinking is extremely flawed. Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) has a long history of peaceful coexistence with people of many religious communities. In both Makkah and Madinah, he lived with Christians and Jews. Even when there were apparent disagreements with certain of the Jewish tribes in Madinah, the Prophet (peace be upon him) did not cut off links with the entire Jewish community. In Madinah, the Prophet acknowledged the Jews as one community with the Muslims. Throughout Islamic history, the Prophet (peace be upon him) cooperated with different non-Muslims. For example, when he and his companion Abu Bakar left Makkah for Madinah during the Hijrah, he relied on Abdullah bin Urayqat, a non-Muslim, to guide and direct them. According to a hadith preserved in Sahih Bukhari, the Prophet paid a visit to a Jewish lad who used to serve him till he became unwell. The Prophet's kind demeanour illustrates the beauty of his teachings, inspiring the youngster to accept the message of the Prophet. These are just a few examples of the Holy Prophet’s remarkable interpersonal relationships with members of various faiths. (Peace be upon him). In addition to his social contacts with people of different faiths, the Holy Prophet emphasised the need of maintaining kinship ties despite religious differences. He advised his companion, Saad bin Abi Waqas, to maintain a good connection with his mother, despite the fact that she did not share the same faith. The Holy Prophet emphasised that one's faith and belief should not interfere with one's family ties. He was Abu Talib's confidant and had an excellent relationship with him. Abu Talib was crucial to the Prophetic message's success. He shielded the Prophet from those who tried to stop him from carrying out his mission. The Prophet (peace be upon him) also lavished love and respect on his uncle. As a result, it is perfectly acceptable for us to befriend individuals who do not share our beliefs. We can always extend friendships to whomever we want to be friends with and embrace friends regardless of their religious beliefs. A friend in need is a true friend. Indeed, some of our friends share our ideals, but we all share our humanity and, more importantly, our strong links to real friendship. A serious assessment of the overall message of the Quran, as well as the Holy Prophet's diverse deeds, would be ample grounds to reject any restricted or exclusivist readings of these verses. Several verses in the Quran exhort us to do good to people of other faiths and to create positive relationships with them. Allah Azzawajal says in the Quran, “And He does not forbid you to deal kindly and justly with anyone who has not fought you for your faith or driven you out of your homes; God loves the Just.” (60:8) As Muslims, we have a religious obligation to challenge interpretations that seek to sow division and hatred. It is our responsibility to portray a favourable image of our faith and to explicitly reject exclusivist interpretations of the Bible. As taught by the Holy Prophet, we spread Rahma (mercy) to all. We must have trust that our faith does not need us to be isolated from other communities and that it does not create hostility in our interpersonal relationships. It is critical that we make attempts to learn about and interact with others in order to develop social cohesion. So, absolutely, we can make friends with our non-Muslim acquaintances. And, certainly, we must, because the beauty of human connections comes in their uniqueness. (Excerpts summarized from Can Muslims Befriend Non-Muslims?) In conclusion, Muslims have no problem maintaining casual friendships and cordial acquaintances with people of other faiths as long as those people do not oppose or dislike Islam or Muslims, do not engage in or incorrectly influence Muslims toward immoral behaviour, and are not unjust and oppressive to anyone. The words of Allah Most High Himself demonstrate this when He says: “Allah does not forbid you from showing kindness and dealing justly with those who have not fought you due to your faith or driven you out of your homes. Allah loves those who deal justly. Allah only forbids you from those people that fought you because of your faith, drove you out of your homes and helped in your expulsion, that you take them as intimate associates. And whosoever takes them as intimate associates, then it is they who are the wrongdoers.” (60:8-9) Other Parts of the Article: Debunking Islamophobic Myths about 26 Wartime Verses: Part 1 on Verse 9:5 Debunking Islamophobic Myths About 26 Wartime Verses Of Quran Considered Militant And Exclusivist: Part 2 On Verse 9:28 Debunking Islamophobic Myths about 26 Wartime Verses: Part 3 on Verse 9:123 ------ Kaniz Fatma is a classic Islamic scholar and a regular columnist for New Age Islam. URL: https://newageislam.com/radical-islamism-jihad/islamophobic-myth-wartime-verses-part-4/d/126967 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism

Plight of Being a Hindu Player in Pakistani Cricket Team

By Sumit Paul, New Age Islam 9 May 2022 One can sympathise, nay empathise, with the plight and predicament of a Hindu player in Pakistan's cricket team. Yes, you've guessed it right. I'm talking about Danish Kaneria, who was pretty successful as a Pakistani international cricketer and (particularly) as a Hindu player to have played Test cricket for Pakistan. Danish Kaneria had alleged that the PCB did not offer any help after he was banned from cricket. ----- Prior to him, Danish's first cousin Anil Dalpat played international cricket for Pakistan. Now Kaneria has accused Shahid Afridi for intimidating him and also goading him to convert to Islam. Nothing new. Yusuf Yohanna, a Christian, reluctantly became Muhammad Yusuf for professional survival. The Dawn of Pakistan hinted that had he not embraced Islam, he'd have been booted out of the team just like Wallis Mathias, Duncan Sharpe and Sohail Fazal, all Christian cricketers. But look at the history of the Indian cricket team. So many magnificent Muslim cricketers embellished the Test team and brought laurels to the country. Who can forget the dynamic Mansur Ali Khan Pataudi Jr, debonair Salim Durrani, a poor man's Garry Sobers, dashing Mushtaq Ali, dandy Abbas Ali Baig, delightful Muhammad Azharuddin, defiant Abid Ali, dour Pathan brothers, to name but a few? But the scenario is correspondingly different in Pakistan. Like the country's murky politics, its cricket team is also ruled and regulated by religion (read Islam). Vintage Pakistan - Salim Malik, Rameez Raja and Anil Dalpat in 80's Courtesy : Shoaib Ahmed / Moin Ahmad | Facebook ----- Long ago, a few Pakistani Urdu dailies mentioned, off the record, that not just Afridi, but also a few other Pakistani cricketers used to scoff at Kaneria and called him a Kafir (infidel). Pakistani Urdu daily ' Azkaar ' went on to say that Dinesh became Danish (Arabic for Aqalmand; intelligent) to give an impression of being a quasi-Muslim, though Danish Kaneria always denied this. Hindus in Pakistan are Kafir and you may be aware that the ill-fated descendants of vanquished Marathas, in the Third Battle of Panipat that took place on Jan 14, 1761 between the Maratha Empire and the invading army of the Durrani Afghan Empire, are still (languishing) in Pakistan. Most of them embraced Islam to survive. Those who didn't accept Islam, worked as manual scavengers and hangmen in Pakistani gaols. Pakistan's humane Air Chief Marshal Noor Khan wrote to the then government of Pakistan to do something to ameliorate the collective lot of these unfortunate descendants of the miserably defeated Marathas, many of whom worked as toilet-cleaners at Pakistan's Staff College, Kakul. This ill-treatment of non-Muslims in a Muslim State is indeed a blot on the escutcheon of Islam. But as usual, Pakistan has nonchalantly denied this. ---- An occasional columnist for New Age Islam, Sumit Paul is a researcher in comparative religions, with special reference to Islam. He has contributed articles to world's premier publications in several languages including Persian. URL: https://newageislam.com/interfaith-dialogue/hindu-player-pakistani-cricket-team/d/126959 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism