Pages

Tuesday, May 10, 2022

Uniform Civil Code – 'A Riddle Wrapped In a Mystery inside an Enigma, ' As Churchill Would Have Put It

By Prof. Akhtarul Wasey Translated from Urdu by Ghulam Ghaus Siddiqi, New Age Islam 9 May 2022 Introduce the Uniform Civil Code to the People of India and Let Them Consider It Realistically and Fairly Main Points 1. Ignoring the Uniform Civil Code is one way for defeating the so-called advocates of the Uniform Civil Code. 2. It's also crucial to dispel the misconception that only Muslims will be affected by the Uniform Civil Code. 3. The UCC will be rejected not only by Muslims but also by the Hindu majority in the country. 4. If the Uniform Civil Code is forcibly imposed on them, it will create unrest among them and this will not be conducive to the healthy development of any country. ---- In a country that embraces practically all the religious traditions of the world, is proud of its position of unity in diversity, and recognises 22 languages in Schedule 8 of the Constitution, where the ruler and the water change over a few miles, where several rivers flow from various springs in various directions, eventually connecting the Arabian Sea and the Bay of Bengal, and the Arabian Sea and the Bay of Bengal combining to form the enormous Indian Ocean. You can't imagine India without diverse religious units, just as you can't envision the vast Indian Ocean without these rivers. However, there have been several attempts in the last few days to transform this multi-colour into a single colour. Now, in India, a similar call for a Uniform Civil Code is being heard once more. Those who have been calling for a Uniform Civil Code for years are unable to define what a Uniform Civil Code is. What shape and form will it take? Religious principles underpin the Hindu Civil Code as well as the personal law of numerous religious groups. Can you picture a Hindu wedding without the seven rotations prescribed by the 'Sanatan Prampra'? Can Sikhs accept each other as life partners without accepting Guru Granth Sahib as a witness? Similarly, can a Christian be married in a church without the pastor administering the oath? Can a Muslim, whether Sunni or Shia, marry without the help of a judge or Mujtahid? If not, then why the writ of the Common Civil Code? Does the Uniform Civil Code imply that marriages should be formally registered? As far as we know, even Muslims are not opposed to marriage registration. Marriage records are stored in mosques in most places. The Waqf Board in various provinces preserves the record of marriages across the province, and a living example of this can be found in Telangana, where the record of marriages has been preserved for hundreds of years. The Indian Constitution guarantees religious freedom to all religious sects in the country, which is both applicable and advantageous to the religious diversity of the country. As mentioned above, family law is considered by every religion as a part of their religion and they think that their family law is protected under the constitution. The Uniform Civil Code would be a step toward depriving this constitutional freedom and it would not be accepted by any sect adhering to the Constitution of India and religious beliefs. The subject of a common civil code has come up several times. It is being examined and implemented anew in states where the BJP is in power, but we believe that implementing the Uniform Civil Code will be difficult. It also appears that those yelling chants in favour of it have no actual motivation other than to harass Muslims. People who talk about one country and one law forget that family laws are not separate only in one country and their separation is not unnatural. Most countries around the world have a tradition of enforcing their own family laws in private life, but separate revenue laws are found only in our country. For example, not every Indian gets the same tax benefits, but if a Hindu gives an affidavit when filing his tax return that he is part of a joint Hindu family, he is given substantial tax benefits. That a person who does not take such an oath even though he is a Hindu is deprived of these concessions. It is also interesting to note that no matter how much a non-Hindu insists on being a part of a joint family, he will not be given these privileges. Those who talk about "one country, one law" should now be questioned about their silence on this issue. It's also crucial to dispel the misconception that only Muslims will be affected by the Uniform Civil Code. The UCC will be rejected not only by Muslims but also by the Hindu majority in the country. Muslim family law has small interpretive distinctions, whereas Hindu family law, marriage, divorce and inheritance issues have major disparities. There are also substantial distinctions between northern and southern people. The question arises as to whether all of these Hindus have a common viewpoint and have agreed on a single common civil code. If that's the case, you'll need to know what the code is. The truth is that any move like this would cause disturbance among the various sections of Hindus, who would be forced to oppose it. This will be an open challenge to their religious authority or the status, privileges and authority of their Dharma Guru. In terms of Muslims, their perspective is very obvious. They have their own perfect religion, and the Holy Quran, Hadith, Consensus (Ijma') and Conjecture (Qiyas) are the key sources of their family law. It should be noted that Consensus and Conjecture are only permissible if they do not contradict the Quran and Hadith. They have the complete right to profess their faith and follow religious regulations under the Constitutional rights of the country. As we have stated above, there are people of different religions in India who have their own religious and family laws and every religious entity loves its family law and will not be willing to give it up at any cost. If the Uniform Civil Code is forcibly imposed on them, it will create unrest among them and this will not be conducive to the healthy development of any country. We would like to advise the ruling class and party leaders in Uttarakhand, Uttar Pradesh, Himachal Pradesh, and other BJP-ruled states where the Uniform civil code is being discussed that they should first introduce a model or outline of uniform civil code to the people of a multi-religious country India and give them a chance to consider it realistically and fairly in a democratic country. We understand that this is being done solely to assuage the emotions of some people and scare minorities. We don't know anyone else, but as common Indians, we believe that if the ruling elite or party actually does play such a game, it will be like walking down a blind alley with no way out. The author effectively encourages Muslims not to yell at this moment without any reason, and that ignoring the Uniform Civil Code is one way for defeating the so-called advocates of the Uniform Civil Code. And if God willing, our current authorities make such a mistake, the vast majority of the people in this nation will understand them completely because people in this country can be religiously inactive but not religiously stray. Urdu Article: Uniform Civil Code: It Is an Unfolded Mystery یونیفارم سول کوڈ: ایک معمہ ہے سمجھنے کا نہ سمجھانے کا URL: https://newageislam.com/islam-politics/uniform-civil-code-mystery-churchill/d/126960 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism

The Al Furqan Prevails As It Must

By Naseer Ahmed, New Age Islam 9 May 2022 This is a rejoinder to Mr. Sumit Paul’s article, “Let's Scrutinise Certain 'Facts' In the Al-Furqan” Mr Sumit Paul says, “When I was a student of comparative religions and theology, I'd often laugh with my erudite professors seeing the anomalies, inconsistencies, aberrations and discrepancies in the scriptures of all man-made faiths, not just Islam.” I wonder why should anyone pursue the study of religions unless they have a passion for learning how religion has contributed to civilizing us and putting us on the path of discovering the secrets of the world. I now know, thanks to Mr Sumit Paul that the passion for mocking religion cold be the motivation for some. Is the profession of mocking religions so very rewarding that the Universities are teaching it and students enrol for it? He further says, “When Truth is so meandering and full of empty verbiage, it can be anything but Truth. Truth is and should be axiomatic. In other words, it must be self-evident and self-explanatory.” Oh really? If that were so, all of us would be polymath. Rocket science wouldn’t be called Rocket Science. Einstein’s general theory of relativity would be understood by a child. Every student of the sciences and mathematics would score a 100% on every test on the subject. He concludes with, “Now the point is: In spite of all these absurd inaccuracies, the Islamic apologists will continue to call their Quran, the INFALLIBLE book of Allah and even a mere suggestion to scrutinise these verses and 'facts' may result in the severance of your head from your torso.” Mr Sumit himself doesn’t believe in what he said above, otherwise, he wouldn’t have said it. As for the absurd inaccuracies that he speaks about, they are a result of his reading of a poor translation of the Quran, his own inadequacies, and his self-confessed bias for mocking. Historical Reasons for the Bias against Religion in Western Education Those of us brought up on western education are heavily influenced by its worldview formed based on Europe’s history. Therefore, the word medieval, which also connotes primitive and cruel, is unthinkingly used by us for the history of the rest of the world also. The medieval age is also the Dark Age for Europe, but not for the rest of the world. Western education has a very strong anti-religion slant which rubs off on all who acquire it. There are very good historical reasons why western education has this stance. During the medieval ages, also known as Europe’s dark age, the Church took a very hostile stand against science and the scientists, declared them heretics, made them publicly renounce science and if they defied, burnt them at the stakes preceded by indescribable torture. Such obscurantists are common to all religions to this day. For a very long time, education meant religious education primarily, but the seminaries were also centres of secular research and teaching subjects such as philosophy, medicine, mathematics and astronomy. The secular and the religious parted ways when the view of the world held by religion began to be questioned by those who pursued the sciences. The Church wielded enormous power because of peoples’ religious faith. Scientific discoveries which went against the Church’s view of the world were a big challenge to its authority and the Church fought back with persecution. The Reading of the Scriptures – Challenges The Bible and every scripture are primarily about religion or the moral way of living. These are not books of science or history, although they contain verses that describe the world, its origins, procreation, some natural phenomena etc. necessary for making a point. If the scriptures are from God, then these must not contain anything that contradicts facts determined by science. Also, a book inspired by God must be clear as to its literal meaning. However, every book of scripture is heavily interpreted. Why is this so? Because, when the literal meaning differs from the view held by the reader, he has a strong tendency to interpret what he reads, to make it yield the meaning he expects. Every translation involves such interpretation and differs from the original to the extent, that the translator’s knowledge of the world is defective or different from the text of the scriptures. The language of Jesus was Aramaic but the Bible people read is in English which is a translation from the Greek Bible. It is therefore translated and interpreted at least twice over. The problem is actually far more serious. The Bible comprises four Gospels selected from about 20 Gospels. These are not Gospels therefore but the Gospel according to their author who is not Jesus. The interpretation of the Gospel of Jesus has therefore taken place at several levels and stages. The human mind interprets and while interpreting, changes the meaning to suit its own worldview, and adds details that it finds missing or drops that which does not appear to make sense. The Quran is available as revealed, in the language of revelation, and also in hundreds of translations. It is also heavily interpreted for the same reasons discussed before, but luckily, recourse to the original text in Arabic is available. Should Science And Religion Be At Loggerheads? For a long time, the universities of secular education and religious seminaries competed to attract students and increase their influence. Initially, there were not many takers for secular education although it had not taken an openly anti-religious stand and a very strong belief in God was common among the scientists such as Isaac Newton and many others. In fact, the study of science was “inspired by the conviction that the universe is the product of a rational mind who designed it to be understood and who designed the human mind to understand it” or as Johannes Kepler said, “God created us after his own image so that we could share in his own thoughts”. The competition for influence between the seminaries and the secular universities continued. When Darwin came up with the theory of evolution as an alternate model of reality, which explains life without the Creator as the Intelligent Designer, evolving from humble single-cell microorganisms as a result of a process of natural selection, the challenge to religion became a very direct one. The fight now was framed as “either you believe in evolution or creation, or “either you believe in religion or science” and science appeared to be winning. Nothing succeeds like success as they say. Science became the new religion and equally dogmatic and intolerant of dissent. Scientifically speaking, the idea of intelligent design was never defeated and is valid to this day, and is overwhelmingly the more probable one, but has been discarded by those who swear by science. Today, it would require an extremely brave man to say in academic circles, that the theory of an Intelligent Design is overwhelmingly the more probable one. “As far as they are concerned, take your life in your hands to challenge the theory of evolution intellectually,” Gelernter (author of Giving up Darwin) said. “They will destroy you if you challenge it.” Such extreme allegiance to evolutionary biology fosters a deficit of free speech within academic communities. “What I’ve seen, in their behaviour intellectually and at colleges across the West, is nothing approaching free speech on this topic,” Gelernter said. “It’s a bitter rejection… It effectively shuts down meaningful scientific intellectual discussion.” Such behaviour reminds us of the extent to which Darwinism is no longer just a scientific theory but the basis of a worldview, and an emergency replacement religion for the many troubled atheists who need one. For the atheists, it is their religion for which they will fight, persecute, ridicule, mock and do all those things that bigots do. The common man does not think for himself and is brainwashed by his religion and that religion could be science. There are very few enlightened souls who believe in only the religion of God by whatever name, that the same God has inspired every religion including science, and that there is no need to be antagonistic to any of them. Religions including science complement each other and lead us to the truth. Now for the many misunderstandings that Mr Sumit Paul has of the Quran. The Story of Creation of the Universe in the Quran The Quran gives us the following amazing information that was confirmed by science much later: 1. That everything was brought together or joined together before being rent asunder 2. That the universe is expanding (as it should be if it was all joined together in the beginning) 3. That all living things are made of water predominantly For a very long time, astrophysicists and cosmologists had assumed a static universe with no beginning and no end, both in time and space. Then certain observations such as the accidental detection of cosmic microwaves and the measurement of their wavelengths led to the conclusion that the universe was expanding. If it was expanding, then working backwards in space and time, it became reasonable to assume that it was all swished together the size of less than a proton before the big bang. Time and space begin with the big bang. This is supported by Einstein’s General Theory of Relativity. Now compare this with what the Quran said 1400 years ago. (21:30) Do not the Unbelievers see that the heavens and the earth were joined together (as one unit of creation), before we clove them asunder? We made from water every living thing. Will they not then believe? (51:47) AND IT IS We who have built the universe with [Our creative] power; and, verily, it is We who are steadily expanding it Another Version of Creation In The Quran The creation of the Universe which includes the earth takes only two days (41:9 and 12). Making the earth fit for sustaining life takes another four days (41:10) or a total of six days. Verse 41:11 again speaks about bringing together everything before cleaving them asunder. The big bang theory confirms what the Quran said 1400 years ago. (41:9) Say: Is it that ye deny Him Who created the earth in two Days? And do ye join equals with Him? He is the Lord of (all) the Worlds. (10) He set on the (earth), mountains standing firm, high above it, and bestowed blessings on the earth, and measure therein all things to give them nourishment in due proportion, in four Days, in accordance with (the needs of) those who seek (Sustenance). (11) Moreover He comprehended in His design the sky, and it had been (as) smoke: He said to it and to the earth: "Come ye together, willingly or unwillingly." They said: "We do come (together), in willing obedience." (12) So He completed them as seven firmaments in two Days, and He assigned to each heaven its duty and command. And We adorned the lower heaven with lights, and (provided it) with guard. Such is the Decree of (Him) the Exalted in Might, Full of Knowledge. The day here is not our 24 hour day but a cosmic day which the Quran describes in one context as our thousand years and in another context as our 50 thousand years. In different contexts, a cosmic day is defined differently. The concept of relativity of time is there bang in your face. In the context of the creation of the Universe, the cosmic day is not defined. This could be because the number is very large for which there was no name in the vocabulary of the 7th century Arabs. For men of understanding, it is sufficient to know that a day here is a cosmic day and not our 24-hour day. The Sky in the Quran The sky in the Quran refers to everything out there in space and not just what we see as the blue skies and is correctly described as “like smoke”. The rain therefore falls from the skies as a result of the clouds raised and moved around by the winds. (24:43) Seest thou not that Allah makes the clouds move gently, then joins them together, then makes them into a heap? - then wilt thou see rain issue forth from their midst (46:24) Then, when they saw the (Penalty in the shape of) a cloud traversing the sky, coming to meet their valleys, they said, "This cloud will give us rain!" "Nay, it is the (Calamity) ye were asking to be hastened!- A wind wherein is a Grievous Penalty! (20:53) "He Who has, made for you the earth like a carpet spread out; has enabled you to go about therein by roads (and channels); and has sent down water from the sky." With it have We produced diverse pairs of plants each separate from the others. There is no verse in the Quran that says the earth is flat. However, there may be feeble minds who think that to say that the earth is spread out, is to say that it is flat! Don’t blame the Quran for it. Verses Regarding Relations With Christians The verses of the Quran need to be understood in their context. Verse 5:51 is from the war phase when the Christians of Medina behaved in a hostile and untrustworthy manner and it is under such circumstances that the Quran prohibits befriending them. The verse is transactional, meaning, limited to those Christians of those times of that place alone. Verse 5:5 permits marriage alliances with the Jews and the Christians and makes permissible their food and is what is generally applicable. There is no contradiction between verses 5:5 and 5:51. Does the Quran say that the sperm comes from between the ribs and the backbone? Many of the verses of the Quran cannot be understood correctly, except with the help of discoveries made by Science in the 19th century. Until such discoveries were made, these verses were mistranslated and misunderstood. Science corroborates what the Quran tells us. Science and the Quran are never at loggerheads. ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Also Read: According To Quran 5:51, Can Muslims Not Accept Non-Muslims As Friends? ------------------------------------------------------------------------ There are many verses in the Quran the truth of which is not self-evident but have been proved correct by scientific discovery. Now consider the following mistranslated verses: (86:5) Now let man but think from what he is created! (6) He is created from a drop emitted- (7) Proceeding from between the backbone (Sulb) and the ribs (Taraib): The incorrect interpretation by the translators and commentators of verses 86:6,7 is proof that the verse is not authored by man. At no point in the history of mankind did man think that conception takes place from a fluid that emanates from “between the ribs and the backbone” of a man. The role of testicles in conception was well known and so also the practice of castration to prevent procreation was well established. Clearly, therefore, any verse authored by man would have been worded differently and none of the commentators and translators understood their own version of the translated verse. It is easy to see how they went wrong. If the verse had contained only the word `Sulb’, 100% of the commentators/translators would have translated it as “from the loins of man”. For example, no translator/commentator has gone wrong in the case of verse 4:23 “ ….wives of your sons proceeding from your Aslabikum (which is translated as loins by all) …..”. In this verse, the reference is only to the sons of the man irrespective of their mother and therefore there is no place for the word “Taraib”. Also, consider: (76:2) Verily We created Man from a drop of mingled seed (nuṭ'fatin amshājin), in order to try him: So We gave him (the gifts), of Hearing and Sight. Verily, it is We who have created man out of a drop of sperm intermingled (with the female ovum) –Asad The literal translation of Nuṭ'fatin Amshājin is mingled seed The correct understanding of mingled seed is the mingling of sperm and ovum The earlier translators only wondered what mingled seed meant but did not possess knowledge of the biological process to translate correctly The word “Taraib” in 86:7 is what confused the earlier commentators/translators lacking knowledge of the biological process. We also know from William Lane’s lexicon, that “Taraib” most definitely refers to female anatomy but the commentators had no knowledge of the role of the ovum in conception and therefore took the word “Taraib” also to refer to the male anatomy. Now consider the various meanings of Sulb from William Lane’s lexicon: Sulb: said of a thing (and of a man), It (and he) was or became hard, firm rigid, stiff, tough, strong, robust, sturdy or hardy. The backbone is the bone extending from the base of the neck to the rump bone. And any portion of the back containing vertebrae and particularly the lumbar portion; the loins. Example of phrase of the Arabs: These are the sons of their loins; because the sperma of the man is held to proceed from the Sulb of the man as is said in the Ksh & c in (86:7). Taraib: The plural noun Taraib, rendered by Asad as "pelvic arch", has also the meaning of "ribs" or "arch of bones"; according to most of the authorities who have specialized in the etymology of rare Quranic expressions this term relates specifically to female anatomy (Taj al-'Arus). The commentators and translators not having knowledge of the role of the ovum in conception, and taking both “Sulb” and “Taraib” to refer to male anatomy made the obvious incorrect conclusion that if the liquid came from between “Sulb” and “Taraib” it could not be between loins and ribs but between the backbone and the ribs and as usual when bewildered, may have added under their breath "Allah knows best"! Now consider the correct translation in accordance with the most obvious and common usage of the words “Sulb” and “Taraib” in Arabic which is correctly rendered by Asad. 86:5 LET MAN, then, observe out of what he has been created: (6) he has been created out of a seminal fluid issuing from between the loins [of man] and the pelvic arch [of woman]. The literal translation of the verse: Man is created from a fluid ejected. Coming forth from between (Bayni) the loins (Sulb) and the pelvic arch (Taraib) The Arabic word bayni is suggestive that the loins and the pelvic arch do not belong to the same person and the ejected fluid is therefore from the loins of the man and the pelvic arch of the woman. While we know that semen is ejected from the loins of a man, is the egg ejected from the pelvic arch? Yes, it is. • The egg is transported to the entrance of the fallopian tube. Once inside the walls of the fallopian tube, muscle contractions push the egg gently towards the uterus. • The egg will either meet sperm on its journey through the fallopian tube and fertilisation will happen, or it will arrive in the uterus unfertilised and be absorbed back into the body. The wrong translation is itself proof that the verse is not authored by man! If it was authored by man, it would have omitted the word “Taraib” and like in 4:23, used only “Sulb” which then would have been translated by all as “issuing from the loins of man” Can we ignore Science and understand the Quran correctly? The Quran contains amazingly accurate knowledge about the world described using the limited vocabulary of the 7th century. Science helps us understand many of the verses of the Quran better. --------------------------------------------------------------- Also Read: Qur'an 5:51 - A Humanistic Interpretation --------------------------------------------------------------- It contains notions of instinct as genetic memory, and conception because of the mingling of the fluids containing the seed from both the man and the woman as against the 7th-century notion that the seed came only from the father etc. Scientists discovered the dynamics of human fertilization only in the nineteenth century which is why the translators and commentators struggled to translate verses 86:6, 7 correctly. Notions of instinct as genetic memory also emerged only in the 19th century but are explicitly contained in verse 7:172. Translators and commentators have similarly struggled with the translation of 7:172 and concocted the myth of Alam-e-Arwah. There are many more astonishing verses in the Quran that have been confirmed by science only in the last couple of centuries. This should, however, be enough to show how poorly the author has understood the subject on which he makes so bold to write. ----- A frequent contributor to NewAgeIslam.com, Naseer Ahmed is an Engineering graduate from IIT Kanpur and is an independent IT consultant after having served in both the Public and Private sector in responsible positions for over three decades. He has spent years studying Quran in-depth and made seminal contributions to its interpretation. URL: https://newageislam.com/islam-pluralism/furqan-quran-religion-western-education/d/126961 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism

Let's Scrutinise Certain 'Facts' In the Al-Furqan

By Sumit Paul, New Age Islam 7 May 2022 The Undotted And Oddly Vowelled Quran Was Generating Wildly Different Explanations Of Itself, As It Still Does Because The Written Arabic Has Two Features That Make It Difficult For An Outsider To Learn ------ Where is the need to justify verses such as, "Take not the Jews and Christians for friends/protectors (5:51)," When it comes to rejecting verses that are of doubtful divinity, we Muslims are either too cowardly or too lazy. We would tie ourselves in knots trying to justify the unjustifiable rather than admit honestly that some man-made verses have crept into our holy book. By Ghulam Mohiyuddin 04/05/2022 16:13:40 “Justification, clarification and interpretation are manifestations of dishonesty, “wrote Pakistani apostate of Islam Ibn Warraq, quoting Rene Descartes. That the aforementioned verse in the Quran needed laboured and completely unconvincing interpretation for being authentic and justifiable is a sure sign of it being SPURIOUS and a later-day INTERPOLATION. Why's the god, creator or Allah so ambiguous as to concoct every verse that needs an elaborate explanation at some point in time? Shouldn't every message, passage and verse in a holy book be unambiguous and unequivocal for every human to understand? Why do poor followers require a battery of exegetes, interpreters and apologists for greater and better understanding of religious verses? --------------------------------------------------------------- Also Read: Qur'an 5:51 - A Humanistic Interpretation --------------------------------------------------------------- When I was a student of comparative religions and theology, I'd often laugh with my erudite professors seeing the anomalies, inconsistencies, aberrations and discrepancies in the scriptures of all man-made faiths, not just Islam. The laboured and ludicrous explanations to justify the scriptural passages of all faiths made them all the more recondite and abstruse. When Truth is so meandering and full of empty verbiage, it can be anything but Truth. Truth is and should be axiomatic. In other words, it must be self-evident and self-explanatory. Despite the theo-scriptural boorishness of any religion, all faiths have accepted the fallibility of their holy books, albeit grudgingly, except for Islam. Christopher Hichens tellingly wrote in his epochal book, ' God is NOT great' that ' Reformation' has meant, for Jewish and Christians, a minimal willingness to reconsider holy writ as if it were (as Salman Rushdie so daringly proposed in his turn) something that can be subjected to literary and textual scrutiny. The number of possible ' Bibles' is now admitted to be immense and we know for example that the portentous Christian term ' Jehovah' is the mistranslation of the unuttered spaces between the letters of the Hebrew ' Yahweh.' Yet, no comparable project has ever been undertaken in Quranic scholarship. No serious attempt has been made to catalogue the discrepancies between its various editions and manuscripts, and even the most tentative efforts to do so have been met with almost inquisitional rage. ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Also Read: According To Quran 5:51, Can Muslims Not Accept Non-Muslims As Friends? ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Though Christianity and Church executed those who questioned the outlandish claims in Bible during the medieval times, it mellowed down with the passage of time and accepted that Bible is fraught with factual and scientific errors such as Seven-Day Creation, Tower of Babel, Human Evolution, A Global Flood, about Stars (The Bible makes it clear that stars are objects in the sky that will fall down when Jesus comes back) and many more. Now a SANE Christian will concede that these are indeed embarrassing 'facts' in his holy book written by our cave-dwelling, prehistoric ancestors. But will a Muslim openly accept that a great many Quranic 'facts' have failed the test of time and science? Earth and heavens created in six days, Earth created before stars, similar size of the sun and moon (by the way, modern science has revealed that 64.3 million moons could fit in the sun!), moon split in two, meteors as stars fired at devils, Flat-Earthism, the sky/heaven as a ceiling, humans created from clay, Adam and Eve (Sahih Hadiths say Adam was 60 cubits-or 90 feet-tall!), sperm originating between the backbone and ribs! Humans were created from a clot of blood, Gender decided at clot stage, Bones formed before flesh and many more. Critics typically argue that an all-knowing, perfect communicator would nevertheless have been able to avoid statements in the Quran that reinforced misconceptions of the time, caused future generations to have doubts about its perfection, and on a scale that critics contend is an overwhelming weakness. Now come the linguistic and stylistics aspects: Quranic Arabic is a little over 1400-yr-old. In other words, the Quran is a 7th-century scripture. But in reality, Arabic script itself wasn't standardized until the later part of the 9th century and in the meantime, the undotted and oddly vowelled Quran was generating wildly different explanations of itself, as it still does because the written Arabic has two features that make it difficult for an outsider to learn: it uses dots to distinguish consonants like ' b ' and ' t, ' and in its original form, it had no sign or symbol for short vowels, which could be rendered by various dashes or comma-type marks. This INTERPRETATIVELY AMORPHOUS and SEMANTICALLY SPECULATIVE nature of written Arabic was keenly observed by an American scholar of Islam and modern and ancient Arabic when he wrote that the Arabic words written on the outside of the Dome of the Rock in Jerusalem are different from any version that appears in the Quran! Secondly, Muslims' claim that Quranic Arabic is the quintessential example of the finest Arabic, spoken by Allah. Sorry, read passages from the books penned by the blind scholar of Arabic, Dr Taha Hussain, Naguib Mahfouz (1988 Nobel laureate for Literature), Dr Edward W Said (Jerusalem-born Dr Said could speak better Arabic than the native speakers in addition to speaking sublime Hebrew) or even The Seven Golden Odes of Pagan Arabia (Mu'allaqat). I'm afraid, pitted against these exquisite samples of literary and oral Arabic, Quranic Arabic simply pales in comparison. In a nutshell, Quranic Arabic is too obscure to be understood even by the scholars of Arabic. It has been further obfuscated by the exegetes and apologists of the Quran and Islam. Now the point is: In spite of all these absurd inaccuracies, the Islamic apologists will continue to call their Quran, the INFALLIBLE book of Allah and even a mere suggestion to scrutinise these verses and 'facts' may result in the severance of your head from your torso. ---- An occasional columnist for New Age Islam, Sumit Paul is a researcher in comparative religions, with special reference to Islam. He has contributed articles to world's premier publications in several languages including Persian. URL: https://newageislam.com/islam-pluralism/facts-al-furqan-quran-/d/126950 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism

Hyderabad Inter-Faith Killing: Why Muslim Condemnation is Not Enough

By Arshad Alam, New Age Islam 6 May 2022 They Must Start An Honest Conversation On Conversion And Casteism Main Points: 1. Both religion and caste are at play in the killing of Dalit Nagaraju in Hyderabad by Muslim family. 2. Muslims have always denied the presence of caste within their communities despite evidence. 3. They have indulged in Islamic supremacy by forcing the other party to convert at the time of marriage. 4. Insistence on conversion must stop; presence of casteism must be acknowledged. ----- Nagaraju and Fathima had married against the wishes of her family. ------ The gruesome murder of B Nagaraju in Hyderabad once again underlines the fraught lives of inter-faith couples. Nagaraju, a Dalit Hindu and Ashrin Sulthana, a Syed Muslim had got married recently against the wishes of the girl’s family. This was too much to digest for the Ashrin’s brothers and they killed Nagaraju in full public view. Nagaraju was stabbed multiple times, clobbered to death while the onlookers just made videos of the gruesome incident. Having witnessed her husband die in such a grisly fashion, Ashrin lost consciousness multiple times when narrating the incident before the press. This is both a religious and a caste issue. There are Muslims who are always in denial of caste within their society and they want to see it simply as a Hindu-Muslim issue. But of late, there has emerged a group amongst Muslims who privilege caste over everything and they are arguing that this is primarily a caste issue; that Nagaraju was killed simply because he was a Dalit. It is wrong to privilege one over the other; religion and caste are so enmeshed that it is often difficult to separate one from the other. The incident underscores the fact that sections of Muslims have as much of a problem with inter-faith marriages as amongst a section of Hindus. But may be the problem is much deeper within the Muslim society as these things are not discussed as openly as it is within the Hindu society. Just like Hindus would not like their wards to marry outside the community, Muslims also are completely opposed to such a practice. It is not surprising therefore that some Muslims came out in support of the Uttar Pradesh chief minister when he brought a legislation which made it very difficult for inter-faith couples to get married. In fact, the Muslim insistence on converting the boy or the girl before marriage makes a mockery of the very term inter-faith alliances. What is left of inter-faith when one partner has to necessarily convert in order to get married? Muslims cannot leave this insistence because in their reading of Islam, conversion is a must. If people are really getting married because they love each other, what is the point of abandoning once faith then? Till the time Muslims insist on conversion, there cannot be any genuine exchange of boys and girls between Hindus and Muslims. The Hindus will always feel that their numbers are being depleted and one cannot fault them since the doctrinal position on Islamic marriage insists on conversion. Syed Ashrin Sulthana, valiantly fought off his attackers, in a horrific killing in public caught on camera Wednesday evening. --- Muslims or Hindus do not have so much of an issue over inter-faith when the woman comes into their faith. In this case, Ashrin exited the community by marrying a Hindu boy thus making violence a foregone conclusion. In such an understanding, women are simply commodities who have no agency of their own. She must always be told what to do and policed all the time, more so in matters of choosing life partners. Muslims who proudly proclaim that women have a lot of freedom in Islam need to tell us why Ashrin was not free to choose a life of her own. Ashrin told the press that Nagaraju had consented to convert to Islam still he was killed. The killing therefore can also be explained if we understand that Nagaraju was a Dalit whose intended conversion even was not acceptable to this upper caste Muslim family. Dalits are ex-untouchables, a very hard-working community, some of whom have risen through centuries of caste oppression and discrimination. Their upward mobility fractures the established social hierarchy and those who want to maintain the status quo react violently to maintain their position and privilege. Similar process was/is at work in places like Haryana and Punjab where upwardly mobile Dalit boys were getting into relationships with dominant Jat community girls. The consequences were similarly grisly in many of such cases. Something similar seems to be at work in the Hyderabad incident where the Syeds, through sheer violence, are hell bent to maintain the status quo. The remorseless face of Ashrin’s brother tells us he killed Nagaraju as a matter of duty: any transgression by lower caste had to be punished in this fashion. ------------------------------------------------------------------------- Also Read: Honour Killing In Egypt: Tribal Mentality Persists Among Muslims Even In Modern Times ------------------------------------------------------------------------- We also need to understand the Pratiloma (unacceptable marriage) which is working in this case. In the traditional Hindu social order, taking a girl from lower caste is an acceptable form of patriarchy but the reverse is not possible. The man cannot take a girl from a caste higher than his own. Similar sentiments prevail in Muslim society also. Nagaraju was killed not just because he was a Dalit but also because despite him being so, he dared to marry a girl from high caste. Muslims are loathe to accept the presence of casteism within their communities despite documented evidence. They keep harping on the received wisdom that Islam is an egalitarian religion without any distinction of caste or class. They also argue that whatever casteism exists within Muslims is the result of ‘contamination’ with Hindu society. This is an a-historical understanding of Islam. Much before Islam came to India, it had already developed a complex stratification system. The Turks and Central Asians who came to India had come with the principle of hierarchy which dictated that Muslims of foreign descent were always superior to other Muslims, forget about Hindus. Scholars like Masud Alam Falahi have categorically demonstrated how such notions even became part of the Indian Islamic theology. Lest we forget, hierarchy became encoded in Islam the very minute it was argued that only a Qureish can become the leader of the community. This happened when the Prophet of Islam had not even been buried. ------------------------------------------------------------------------- Also Read: Honour Killing – The Most Deplorable Abuse of Human Rights Is Also Against the Ethics of All Religions ------------------------------------------------------------------------- The killing of Nagaraju is a rude reminder to all Muslims that they should first put their house in order. Firstly, they should confront the menace of casteism within their own society. Ambedkar was right to observe that Muslims have all the ills of Hindu society plus something more. And that something more is the rigidity that comes with Islamic theology. What is the need of conversion when two people simply want to be together? Muslims across all walks of have overwhelmingly condemned the incident. However, such condemnations have no meaning if there is no introspection as to why such an incident happened in the first place. For a start, Muslims have to do some soul searching and come out of their supremacist notion that only their religion is the ultimate truth and all others are false or astray. If they are really serious about putting the best face of Islam, then the insistence on conversion must be dropped forthwith. Secondly, they need to start an honest conversation about caste and untouchability within their midst. ----- A regular columnist with NewAgeIslam.com, Arshad Alam is a writer and researcher on Islam and Muslims in South Asia. URL: https://newageislam.com/interfaith-dialogue/hyderabad-inter-faith-killing-muslim/d/126943 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism

Why is There No Exit Option from Islam?

By Arshad Alam, New Age Islam 4 May 2022 It Can Only Mean That Islam Is Unsure Of Its Foundation Main Points: 1. Askar Ali was hounded by family and society for renouncing Islam. 2. If a person has the freedom to join Islam, then he/she should also have the freedom to leave it without any kind of repercussion. 3. But those who want to leave Islam are branded apostates who can be legitimately killed. 4. Taqlid or blind adherence has been the bane of Muslim society. ------ Representative Image/ Image Source: Zee ------- Askar Ali, a native of Mallapuram in Kerala was scheduled to speak in Kollam, at an event to “promote scientific temper, humanism and the spirit of inquiry and reform society”. He alleges that he was prevented from doing so by a group of Muslims who apparently kidnapped, misbehaved and threatened him. It must be mentioned here that Askar Ali is himself a student of Islamic theology and he wanted to speak on his experience of going through such a scholarship. Ali was finally able to deliver his speech in the presence of police but the whole incident has left him traumatized. Ali also says that his family members were the first to oppose him. But what is the issue here? Why did the Muslim society oppose Ali to speak his mind? Well, that’s because Ali has renounced his faith in Islam and his journey towards “humanism” dictates his conscience to speak against all dogmas. Since he is most familiar with the tradition of Islam, he wanted to speak on how Islam needs to be reformed so that Muslims are able to inculcate rationality and scientific temper. But then, some followers of Islam seem to have decided that it will have a detrimental effect on the minds of Muslims, especially the young, and hence resorted to all sorts of illegal practices to stop Ali from speaking. We haven’t heard the end of it. Kerala has a registered body of ex-Muslims (Muslims who have left Islam) and they are sure to take up Ali’s case. On the other hand, the state also has some very conservative religious factions who are bound to oppose him. A year ago, a video of a madrasa teacher in Kerala went viral as he was seen advocating killing those who leave Islam. It must be mentioned that amongst all those Indians who went to join ISIS, the majority came from Kerala. No wonder then, Muslims who become unhinged from Islamic teachings have a tough time articulating their views. But this is not the case of a lone Muslim in one state; rather this is a problem which all Muslim societies are facing for a long time. Many Muslims who no longer believe in the doctrine lead double- lives, pretending to have Iman (faith) in front of family and friends while opening up only within a select group. It is also true that Muslim society is tolerant towards such Muslims who despite leaving Islam do not publicly proclaim it. The minute he or she decides to air their views, hell breaks loose on them. First, they are ostracized from the family and society and at times they are even attacked for their non-conformist views. While the Ulama in Egypt understand atheism as a mental illness, the Indian Muslim society brings inordinate amount of pressure to bring the person back within the fold of Islam or even threaten to kill him. An individual is not a citizen till the time he or she has the freedom to speak freely. In not allowing non-believing Muslims to speak their minds, the Muslim society is infringing on their basic freedom of thought and expression. Even saner Muslims argue that non-believing Muslims spread chaos in society through their unconventional views and that in the process they hurt the feeling of others (Muslims). But the same Muslims never have an issue when all kinds of nonsense are spoken by believers. One can hear the Ulama rubbishing other faiths, especially the “idol worshipping Hinduism” in trying to proclaim the finality of Islam. Saner Muslims never challenge even the idiocy of those Ulama who try to prove scientific facts in the Quran and end up making a fool of themselves each time they do it. Why then the same courtesy is not extended to those Muslims who think Islam needs to be critiqued and reformed. The problem is much deeper. Taqlid (blind adherence) has become the defining principle of all law schools, especially amongst the Hanafis in South Asia. It simply means that Muslims have to follow whatever has been ordained for them by the Ulama in their writings. Such authoritative writings can only be extended by arguing for it but never against it. Theological knowledge in Islam can only have additions to approved principles. That’s even the likes of traditionalists like Ali Dashti and Fazlur Rahman, who tried a fresh interpretation (ijtihad), have been thrown out or relegated to the margins of Muslim religious imaginary. And we know that blind adherence of anything is not conducive to intellectual growth. This also runs inverse to the Quranic teaching which tells the believers to wonder and be curious about the world around them. Anyone who thinks out of the box is branded an apostate. This label puts the life of the accused in danger but also inhibits any kind of religious inquiry within Muslims. Someone who renounces Islam should be asked to repent failing which he or she is liable to be killed. This principle is upheld by all law schools, various hadith literature and even from the Quran itself. The only difference amongst scholars is by whom such a punishment should be given: the people, the Islamic state or God himself. Under the impact of such a theology, it is not entirely surprising that Muslims want to kill anyone who is even slightly suspected of being an apostate. In, India the situation might not to be as dire as it is in Pakistan, but given the general direction of religious orthodoxy, one cannot say that such things will not start happening in India. The case of Askar Ali is therefore not an exception. Muslim society brings its full might on anyone who opposes this tradition of blind adherence to theological consensus. This happens to even those who want to remain within the orbit of Islam but are perturbed by its theology and have some genuine questions about slavery, gender equality, etc. Rather than satisfying the intellectual curiosity of such people, Muslim society starts doubting the intention of such persons. The result is that he or she is forced to seek an exit from Islam. But even that is not acceptable to Muslims. Because the minute you go outside the fold, you are liable to be killed. While Islam claims that it spread through persuasion rather than the sword, its failure to give an exit option to Muslims belies its own principles. A society that does not ask critical questions of its own traditions, which always adores the past as perfection is a society unsure of its foundations. After all, why can’t questions raised by the likes of Ali not be answered in a true intellectual fashion? Or is it that Islam does not have an answer to questions raised by the likes of Ali? ---- A regular columnist with NewAgeIslam.com, Arshad Alam is a writer and researcher on Islam and Muslims in South Asia. URL: https://newageislam.com/islamic-ideology/askar-taqlid-islamic-theology/d/126931 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism

Thursday, May 5, 2022

Why is There No Exit Option from Islam?

By Arshad Alam, New Age Islam 4 May 2022 It Can Only Mean That Islam Is Unsure Of Its Foundation Main Points: 1. Askar Ali was hounded by family and society for renouncing Islam. 2. If a person has the freedom to join Islam, then he/she should also have the freedom to leave it without any kind of repercussion. 3. But those who want to leave Islam are branded apostates who can be legitimately killed. 4. Taqlid or blind adherence has been the bane of Muslim society. ------ Representative Image/ Image Source: Zee ------- Askar Ali, a native of Mallapuram in Kerala was scheduled to speak in Kollam, at an event to “promote scientific temper, humanism and the spirit of inquiry and reform society”. He alleges that he was prevented from doing so by a group of Muslims who apparently kidnapped, misbehaved and threatened him. It must be mentioned here that Askar Ali is himself a student of Islamic theology and he wanted to speak on his experience of going through such a scholarship. Ali was finally able to deliver his speech in the presence of police but the whole incident has left him traumatized. Ali also says that his family members were the first to oppose him. But what is the issue here? Why did the Muslim society oppose Ali to speak his mind? Well, that’s because Ali has renounced his faith in Islam and his journey towards “humanism” dictates his conscience to speak against all dogmas. Since he is most familiar with the tradition of Islam, he wanted to speak on how Islam needs to be reformed so that Muslims are able to inculcate rationality and scientific temper. But then, some followers of Islam seem to have decided that it will have a detrimental effect on the minds of Muslims, especially the young, and hence resorted to all sorts of illegal practices to stop Ali from speaking. We haven’t heard the end of it. Kerala has a registered body of ex-Muslims (Muslims who have left Islam) and they are sure to take up Ali’s case. On the other hand, the state also has some very conservative religious factions who are bound to oppose him. A year ago, a video of a madrasa teacher in Kerala went viral as he was seen advocating killing those who leave Islam. It must be mentioned that amongst all those Indians who went to join ISIS, the majority came from Kerala. No wonder then, Muslims who become unhinged from Islamic teachings have a tough time articulating their views. But this is not the case of a lone Muslim in one state; rather this is a problem which all Muslim societies are facing for a long time. Many Muslims who no longer believe in the doctrine lead double- lives, pretending to have Iman (faith) in front of family and friends while opening up only within a select group. It is also true that Muslim society is tolerant towards such Muslims who despite leaving Islam do not publicly proclaim it. The minute he or she decides to air their views, hell breaks loose on them. First, they are ostracized from the family and society and at times they are even attacked for their non-conformist views. While the Ulama in Egypt understand atheism as a mental illness, the Indian Muslim society brings inordinate amount of pressure to bring the person back within the fold of Islam or even threaten to kill him. An individual is not a citizen till the time he or she has the freedom to speak freely. In not allowing non-believing Muslims to speak their minds, the Muslim society is infringing on their basic freedom of thought and expression. Even saner Muslims argue that non-believing Muslims spread chaos in society through their unconventional views and that in the process they hurt the feeling of others (Muslims). But the same Muslims never have an issue when all kinds of nonsense are spoken by believers. One can hear the Ulama rubbishing other faiths, especially the “idol worshipping Hinduism” in trying to proclaim the finality of Islam. Saner Muslims never challenge even the idiocy of those Ulama who try to prove scientific facts in the Quran and end up making a fool of themselves each time they do it. Why then the same courtesy is not extended to those Muslims who think Islam needs to be critiqued and reformed. The problem is much deeper. Taqlid (blind adherence) has become the defining principle of all law schools, especially amongst the Hanafis in South Asia. It simply means that Muslims have to follow whatever has been ordained for them by the Ulama in their writings. Such authoritative writings can only be extended by arguing for it but never against it. Theological knowledge in Islam can only have additions to approved principles. That’s even the likes of traditionalists like Ali Dashti and Fazlur Rahman, who tried a fresh interpretation (ijtihad), have been thrown out or relegated to the margins of Muslim religious imaginary. And we know that blind adherence of anything is not conducive to intellectual growth. This also runs inverse to the Quranic teaching which tells the believers to wonder and be curious about the world around them. Anyone who thinks out of the box is branded an apostate. This label puts the life of the accused in danger but also inhibits any kind of religious inquiry within Muslims. Someone who renounces Islam should be asked to repent failing which he or she is liable to be killed. This principle is upheld by all law schools, various hadith literature and even from the Quran itself. The only difference amongst scholars is by whom such a punishment should be given: the people, the Islamic state or God himself. Under the impact of such a theology, it is not entirely surprising that Muslims want to kill anyone who is even slightly suspected of being an apostate. In, India the situation might not to be as dire as it is in Pakistan, but given the general direction of religious orthodoxy, one cannot say that such things will not start happening in India. The case of Askar Ali is therefore not an exception. Muslim society brings its full might on anyone who opposes this tradition of blind adherence to theological consensus. This happens to even those who want to remain within the orbit of Islam but are perturbed by its theology and have some genuine questions about slavery, gender equality, etc. Rather than satisfying the intellectual curiosity of such people, Muslim society starts doubting the intention of such persons. The result is that he or she is forced to seek an exit from Islam. But even that is not acceptable to Muslims. Because the minute you go outside the fold, you are liable to be killed. While Islam claims that it spread through persuasion rather than the sword, its failure to give an exit option to Muslims belies its own principles. A society that does not ask critical questions of its own traditions, which always adores the past as perfection is a society unsure of its foundations. After all, why can’t questions raised by the likes of Ali not be answered in a true intellectual fashion? Or is it that Islam does not have an answer to questions raised by the likes of Ali? ---- A regular columnist with NewAgeIslam.com, Arshad Alam is a writer and researcher on Islam and Muslims in South Asia. URL: https://newageislam.com/islamic-ideology/askar-taqlid-islamic-theology/d/126931 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism

Wednesday, May 4, 2022

Qur'an 5:51 - A Humanistic Interpretation

By V.A. Mohamad Ashrof, New Age Islam 4 May 2022 Does The Verse 5:51 Really Forbid Contact And Alliance With Judeo-Christians Including The Common People In A Bid To Derive A Humanistic Interpretation ---- “O you who believe! Take not the Jews and Christians for friends/protectors (Awliya)” (Q.5:51). Islamophobes and Muslim extremists like Osama bin Laden, Ayman al - Zawahiri, and Abu Bakr al - Baghdadi often quote Q.5: 51. This small paper examines whether this verse really forbids contact and alliance with Judeo-Christians, including the common people in a bid to derive a humanistic interpretation. Muslim and Anti-Muslim extremists are abusing the Qur'anic reference to "do not make alliance with Judeo-Christians" in the sense of "not making friends" (Q. 5:51, 60: 1, 4: 139, 5:57, 3:28). The word “Awliya” really means guardian, responsible manager, master, keeper, and servant. The following verse of the Qur'an will help us to understand the more subtle meaning of the word “Awliya”: “As for the disbelievers, they are guardians of one another. And unless you ˹believers˺ act likewise, there will be great oppression and corruption in the land.” (8:73). The message of the verse is that the non-cooperation of the adherents of goodness will lead the world to disaster because the adherents of evil are in cooperation. ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Also Read: According To Quran 5:51, Can Muslims Not Accept Non-Muslims As Friends? ------------------------------------------------------------------------ The verse Q.5:57 illuminates the verse Q.5:51 further: "O believers! Do not seek the guardianship of those given the Scripture before you and the disbelievers who have made your faith a mockery and amusement. And be mindful of Allah if you are ˹truly˺ believers." (Q.5:57) It is only those enemies who are mocking the believers for the sake of amusement should not be taken as allies. If one reads Q.5:51 and Q.5:57 together, she will get the following idea: do not take Jews and Christians who are bitterly hostile to you as stewards. The basic reason is that they are eager to ridicule and insult your faith. Jews and Christians are the authoritative bearers of the divine message: the command to "ask the people of the Book" is found throughout the Qur'an (Q. 10:94; 17: 101; 25:59; 16:43; 21: 7; 43:45, 2: 211). One verse in the Qur'an explains the other (Q. 4:82, 2:85). It is said in one place that God will lead astray whomever He wills (Q. 3:27); another verse clarifies that those who ignore the signs of God are thus led astray (Q. 6:39). The Qur'an forbids making enemies who protect each other their guardians (Q. 8:73; 45:19). It reminds the unbelievers that they are allies of one another and warns that oppression and corruption will take place on earth if they are led (Q. 8:73). Do not make allies even members of your own family if they are rivals (Q. 4: 139; 9:23). “Children of Adam” in Q.17:70 refer to all mankind and shows that human being is by her very creation deserves regard and respect as a natural birth right, regardless of which community he belongs to. Respect and justice for humankind is one of the fundamental teachings of the Qur'an (4:135, 5:8). It instructs Muslims to show goodness to those who do evil (41:34), to speak words of peace to those who are hostile (25:63), to call to the way of God with wisdom and beautiful preaching (16:125), to treat peaceful non-Muslims with the utmost kindness and justice (60:8), to be the best of people towards other people (3:110), and to respect freedom of consciousness and religion (2:256, 10:99). Muslims are commanded to protect churches and synagogues; they are holy places where God's name is being “commemorated in abundant measure" (Q. 22:40). The Qur'an also supports marital relations with the Judeo-Christians (Q. 5: 5). It also describes marriage as a warm example of emotional and loving relationships (Q. 2: 187, 2: 229-237; 4:19, 4:25, 9:71; 30:21). The underlying cause of forbiddance contained in Q.5:51 are further explained in verses Q.3:28 and 4: 139. As stated in Q. 60: 7-9, it is clear that the Qur'an does not oppose normal and friendly relations with human beings. The Qur'an predicts that Jews and Christians will be eternal enemies due to their theological disputes (Q. 5:64). However, they can also unite for evil and conspire against goodness: a clear example of this is the alliance between Christian and Jewish Zionists. Christian Zionists are fundamentally anti-Semitic; they join the Jewish Zionists for political purposes. The last days of Christian Zionists also foretold the Holocaust: two-thirds of the Jewish people in the land of Israel would perish. The remaining third will be reformed and await God's deliverance at the second coming of Christ. (Walvoord, p. 108) This is what Christian Zionism wants. The goal of the unholy relationship without ceasing to be anti-Semitic is a really a cause of rebellion on earth. The Qur'an commands people to help one another in good deeds (Q. 2: 148; 2: 177; 5: 2; 60: 8-9). According to the Qur'an, not all the people of the Book are of the same nature; some of them are pious (Q. 3: 113-14, 5: 82-83, 7: 159, 5:66, 3:75, 2: 121, 17: 107-108). The Qur'an is the only non-Jewish scripture in the world that honours the Jews (Q. 2:40, 2: 47-52, 2: 57-58, 5:20, 5:44, 10:47, 10: 90-93, 14: 6, 17: 2-3, 20: 47-52, 20: 77-80, 44: 30-32, 45:16). The Qur'an praises good Jews and promises salvation if they follow the true teachings of Moses (Q. 2: 62, 2: 121-122, 3: 113-115, 3: 199, 5:12, 5:65-66, 5:69, 29:46). Islam absolves the Jews from the allegation of the “killers of Jesus Christ” (Q.4:157-158). The Qur’an’s main criticisms of the Jews include: breaking the covenant, rejecting the clear evidence (Q. 4: 153-4), branding the Prophets as liars and killing them unjustly (Q. 5:70), and insulting the mother of the Jesus Christ (Q. 4: 153), behaving unjustly (Q. 4: 160-1) and taking interest and accepting bribes (Q. 5:62). Moreover, some Jews were cursed because of the claim that Ezra was the Son of God (Q. 9:30). The Judeo-Christian scriptures and history attest to these criticisms. Trinity is one of the most important criticisms of the Qur'an against Christians (Q. 2: 116; 5:73). Christians misunderstand Jesus' sonship (Q. 5:72; 9:30); Jesus is merely a human, Messiah and a prophet. Christians err also on the issue of Jesus' crucifixion (Q. 4: 157-158) and their understanding of the fall of mankind; therefore, they fail to understand the righteousness of God: "He who carries a load does not bear another's burden" (Q. 35:18, 53:38). The Qur’an teaches that Jesus was not God incarnate, he did not die on a cross, and he was not raised from the dead (Q.4:157; 5:116). This does not prevent the Quran from praising good Christians assuring them that they too have salvation if they follow Jesus' true teachings (Q. 2: 62, 2: 121-122, 3: 113-115, 3: 199, 5: 65-66; 5:69, 5:82, 29:46). Verse Q.5:82 refers to Christians as those who are close to the believers. The Qur'an is the only non-Christian book in the world that has great respect for Jesus and Mary (Q. 3: 42-55, 5: 44-46, 5: 110, 43:59). The Qur'an's harsh words are not aimed to any religious groups, but to wrong attitudes, wrong thinking, arrogance, and hostility to Islam. From the Qur'anic point of view, there is no permanent enemy: "Prevent evil with the best of good, so that he who is hostile to you will be like a close friend" (Q. 41:34). It bestows benevolent and constructive guidance to the people of the Book (e.g. Q 3:64, 3: 113–115, 3:199; 5.69; 16.43; 29.46). When a Christian delegation arrived from Najran, the Prophet allowed them to worship in his own mosque. (Guillaume, pp. 270-277) The Quran only objects the alliance of the evil forces for ulterior motivation and purpose and not the alliance with any ordinary Jews and Christians (Q. 4:89, 4: 144; 5:51, 5:57). It is clear that the ill-intentioned (Q.33: 32) Judeo-Christian Zionism and their ancestral forms are united in mutual aid for perverse and mysterious evil purposes. Hypocrisy, deceit, perversion and cruelty are the basic reasons; they use faith for their own political purposes (Q. 2: 8-11, 24: 47-50 33:12, 33:60, 47:20, 47:29, 74:31). The Qur'an itself has made it clear that among the Jews and Christians there are people who stand for justice (Q. 3: 113). Among them are good men who are financially faithful (Q. 3:75). The Q. 5:51 forbids the protection of Christian-Jewish Zionist activities. Not any of the good deeds of the Jews and Christians, which are on the basis of the belief in monotheism and Life Hereafter, would be wasted (Q. 5:69, 2:62, 22:17). "If you do deeds of charity openly, it is good; but if you bestow it upon the needy in secret, it will be even better for you, and it will atone for some of your bad deeds. And God is aware of all that you do" (Q.2: 271). Nowhere does the Qur’an distinguish between believers and unbelievers, and Qaradawi quotes some of the Prophet's disciples as aiding and abetting non - Muslim monks. (Qaradawi, p. 449) The Qur'an declares that the children of Adam have full respect (17:70), that human beings were created superior to the angels (Q.2:34, 32: 7-9), and therefore human life is most sacred (Q.5:32). Muslims are obliged to enlighten the worlds with the noble ideals of goodness and piety (Q. 2: 143, 2: 177, 2: 189, 2:44, 3:92, 58: 9). The Qur'an refers to the addresses of the prophets, mostly enemies, as "brothers": Brothers of Lot (Q. 50: 12-14), Noah (Q.26: 106), Hood (Q.26: 142, 7:65), Salih (Q.26: 142, 7:73) and Shuaib (Q.26: 176, 11:84). The true Islamic adherents can see human brotherhood in a generic sense, even though they are not their own blood-brothers. (Ali, p.422). References: Ali, Yusuf, The Holy Qur’an: English Translation Meanings & Commentary, Madina: King Fahd Holy Qur’an Printing Complex, 1411 H Guillaume, Alfred (tr), The Life of Muhammad: A Translation of Ibn Ishâq’s Sîrat Rasûl Allâh, Oxford: OUP, 1968 Qaradawi, Yusuful, Fiqh alZakat (Tr.Dr. Monzer Kahf), London: Dar alTaqwa, 1999 Walvoord, John F, Israel in Prophecy, Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 1988 ---- V.A. Mohamad Ashrof is one among the Muslim scholars of Kerala who is regularly publishing articles and papers dealing with Islam and Contemporary Affairs. He has worked as the Executive Editor of Al-Harmony, a Quarterly Journal on Islam and Thought and Ethics, for 10 years. He is the joint secretary of Forum for Faith and Fraternity- a Muslim think tank based in Kochi. He is also the Secretary of International Interfaith Dialogue India, an interfaith movement based in Kerala. URL: https://newageislam.com/islam-pluralism/quran-5-51-humanistic-interpretation/d/126928 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism

Time To Pause And Ponder Over Amjad Ali Khan's Lamentations

By Sumit Paul, New Age Islam 4 May 2022 Mankind Needs NO Religion, Scripture, Sect, Nation, Ideology, Divinity, Spirituality (A Mere Modern-Day Fashionable Cult) Or The Biggest Concoction GOD ---- " Perhaps there are some shortcomings in our education system which we have to improve. Otherwise tell how a PhD done man becomes communal irrespective of religion. That’s why we have to make people merciful......." ‘In the 21st century it seemed that everything would be peaceful. It used to be that people would be wiser by education but schools have become a business industry. Perhaps that is why education could not make us merciful. Even today people are discriminated against on the basis of religion and colour. Instead of being merciful, people in the world have become more merciless.' Ustad Amjad Ali Khan ------ The recent aforementioned lamentations expressed by the legendary sarod maestro Ustad Amjad Ali Khan in Bombay (sorry, no Mumbai for me) make one ruminate over them. He's spot-on. We all have become too religious in spite of our 'education.' In fact, this so-called education has made us all the more hardcore and blinkered. Instead of understanding and imbibing the spirit of a faith, we've suddenly become more concerned about the external manifestations of it. All of a sudden, a Muslim man has begun to flaunt his skull-cap, his beard sans moustache(!) and wear ankle-high trousers, a Hindu is proudly showing his tilak and other symbols, Christians are showing their cross and other sarcophagus sacraments dangling and proclaiming their Christianity, 'educated' Sikhs are brandishing their daggers, followers of Jainism are greeting each other with Jay Jinendra and non-Jains (Maheshwaris) are shouting Jay Gopal........the blatant religious proclamations of all religions are the latest (spiritual) fads and followers of different religions are condemning each other on social platforms with a vengeance. What's going on? The sarod-maestro is right that our education is flawed. Because of this discriminatory education, we all have become so religiously sick and hidebound. I ruefully remember the last interview of the great orientalist Dr Edward W Said in which he stated, " There's hardly any HUMAN left. Mankind is compartmentalized into nations, religions, ideologies, sects, sub-sects, and whatnots. Humans have relegated themselves to moving labels." So very true. Urdu poet Nida Fazli said the same thing in one of his couplets: Girja Mein, Mandiron Mein, Azanon Mein Bant Gaya/Hote Hi Subha Aadmi Khaanon Mein Bant Gaya ( Pigeonholed into church, temple and Azan/ Right from the morning, man is compartmentalized into sects and boxes). Al-Furqan categorically states that the Allah is Rabbul-Aalameen (the god of the whole universe) not just Rabbul-Musalmeen (the god of only Muslims). Yet, all faiths have their respective gods and each faith, nay even a sect, claims to have the exclusive monopoly of Truth! Isn't it bizarre? The quiddity of all man-made faiths is LOVE but we seem to be obsessed with HATRED. Amir Khusro says in one of his Persian couplets, ' Kaafir-E-Ishqam Musalmani Mara Darkaar Neest/Har Rage-Jaan Taar Gushta, Haajat Zunnar Neest' (I'm a Muslim, whose faith is LOVE, I don't require Islam/My every vein is now a sacred thread (Janeu), I don't need to wear a Zunnar (sacred thread word by Hindus). We've been fighting in the name of religion right from the advent of human civilization and shedding the blood of our brethren just because we perceive that the other person doesn't belong to our religion or religious sect. So, he or she must be eliminated. Quran audaciously declares, ' Kuffar La'aitbaar (Infidels are not to be trusted!). How ridiculous this sounds! But this has been happening. We've not yet understood that any religion is a mental slavery. Saghar Nizami aptly said this in a quatrain, ' Aqeede Mere Saamne Kaanpte Hain/Usool-E-Muhabbat Ki Buniyaad Hoon Main/Na Zunnar Ki Fikra, Na Tasbeeh Ka Gham/Dimaghi Ghulami Se Aazaad Hoon Main' ( All traditional faiths tremble before me/ I'm the cornerstone of love/Neither am I concerned about the sacred thread, nor do I care for the rosary/ I'm free of all mental slavery). Yes, religion is a state of mental enslavement. It's a doctrinal thralldom. It quashes an individual's righteous individuality. Bal Labhu Ram Mukand ' Arsh' Malsyani's famous quatrain articulates this, ' Dairo-Haram Se Aur Toh Haasil Na Kuchh Hua/Sajde Zaroor Ishq Ki Qeemat Ghata Gaye/Kitna Farebkaar Hai Ahsaas-E-Bandagi/Hum Manzil-E-Khudi Se Bahut Door Aa Gaye ' ( Temple and mosque couldn't do anything worthwhile/Albeit, genuflections trivialized the value of Love/How deceptively comforting is the feeling of worship/ We've gone far away from the crux of righteous ego). Mankind needs NO religion, scripture, sect, nation, ideology, divinity, spirituality (a mere modern-day fashionable cult) or the biggest concoction GOD, the root of all problems. All we need is humanity and the nurturing of the most sublime humane attributes. Stop Azan, reciting Hanuman Chalisa, Ardaas at Gurudwaras and Sunday prayers. Find the divinity that's immanent in you. ---- An occasional columnist for New Age Islam, Sumit Paul is a researcher in comparative religions, with special reference to Islam. He has contributed articles to world's premier publications in several languages including Persian. URL: https://newageislam.com/islamic-society/amjad-lamentations-azan-ardaas-hanuman-chalisa/d/126927 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism

Monday, May 2, 2022

New Indian Politics And Increasing Legal Conservatism Among Indian Muslims

By Grace Mubashir, New Age Islam 2 May 2022 Muslim Personal Law And Special Powers For Minority Institutions Helped Integrate Muslims In The Fledgling Nation Main Points: 1. Era of Community-Led Internal Reforms 2. Rise of Hindutva Politics and Increasing Legal Conservatism among Muslims ----- Amid the existential crises of Indian Muslims after Partition, the constitutional assurances given to the collective identity was vital in ameliorating the fears of the Muslim community. While individual freedoms are tenable while interpreting the constitution, recognition of the collective identity of the Muslim community by the way of State protection for colonial-era Muslim Personal Law and special powers for minority institutions helped integrate Muslims in the fledgling Nation. When the Nehru government feverously pushed the agenda of codification of Hindu Code, Muslims were spared. Nehru was of the opinion that Muslims being an embittered minority, the State shall not force changes in Personal Law and; instead support all Community-led reform movements. His was a prudent political act to forestall militant Community mobilization. As pointed out by Mohamed Qasim Zaman, Muslims in Indian subcontinent were aware of the colonial nature of the Muslim Personal Law and an undercurrent of reform was prevalent among the Faithful. It was Ashraf Ali Thanwi who fiercely endorsed flexibility and contemporary changes in Muslim Personal Law to shake off imperialist connotation of Muslim Laws. Scholars like Justice Ameer Ali, Asaf A. Fayzee, and Muhammed Ismail Sahib were aware of the legal changes in contemporary Muslim communities and the vested interests of Colonial powers in feudalizing legal cannon of Islam. The Muslim Shariat Act of 1937 and Marriage Dissolution Act of 1939 were in fact nascent steps towards gradual progression towards modernization and codification of Muslim law in the Subcontinent. According to Zoya Hassan, the political insecurity after Partition led to an abrupt halt to the codification of Muslim Law and, instead, the identity fears of the Community manifested in their staunch support to Colonial era Personal Laws. It was viewed as final concession to Indian Muslims hence to be safeguarded at any cost. Modernization and codification was relegated to the backburner for the protection of limited constitutional rights. Narendra Subramanian has documented the role of Personal Laws in the formation of Muslim identity in India. Era of Community-Led Internal Reforms The relative immunity from State intervention expedited internal reform in the community. The jolt of reality in independent India accentuated the pace of internal reforms. Staring at the bleak reality of Indian Muslims, community leaders, cutting across various factions, supported internal reforms in varying degrees. Women's education was promoted. Women's visibility in formal and informal sectors was motivated. Hadees literature was studied to reform existing Muslim canonical laws. The general reading of Indian Muslims as a monolithic community often glosses over the vibrant diversity underlying the regional differences in Islam. In South Indian Muslims, due to historical reasons, internal reforms were at meteoric rise whereas the North Indian counterpart took a lackadaisical approach. While elite upper caste Muslims sensed opportunity in the scarce crumbs the new republic threw to them, other marginalized sections of the society soon appropriated internal reform thanks to evolving situations. Secular education got wider acceptance among the community. Madrasas and maktabs, established exclusively for religious education, showed promising interest in integrating school education. Many states enacted laws with the consensus of the community. The induced reforms with the blessings of community were making substantial strides in reforming the community. And with Shah Bano all hell broke loose. The Shah Bano issues of 1980s changed the course of Muslim reform movements. The conservative and reactionary clergy tightened their grip on the community. Progressive sections were relegated into irrelevance. Major concession by Rajiv Gandhi government to the conservative section by overruling the then Supreme Court verdict proved fatal for the progress of the community. Rise of Hindutva Politics and Increasing Legal Conservatism among Muslims The failure of Janata Government initially laid the foundation for Hindutva politics. Later, Mandal politics inflamed religious passion and Kamandal politics surrounding Babri Masjid only hastened the growth of right wing Hindutva politics. They questioned the alleged minority appeasement politics. Major war cry of BJP was to end state protection to Muslim Personal Law. According to BJP, the existence of separate civil laws for Muslims is against the unity of nation and demands the implementation of Uniform Civil Code. Along with recurring communal tensions, the waning political importance as a key vote bank pushed the Community into defense. This had a debilitating impact on the orientation of the Community. While political changes of Muslim community are well-documented, the question of how it perpetuates legal conservatism needs keen attention. Afraid of Hindutva attacks on Muslimness, a general trend of dogmatic loyalty towards Muslim Personal Law could be seen. After 2014, when Modi captured Delhi for the first time in Indian electoral politics without Muslim support, a sense of obscurantism has overwhelmed the community. The Hindutva rhetoric denigrating the honorable partnership of Muslims with the Republic has raised existential threats among the faithful. Citizenship controversies further alienated the Muslims. Muslims generally are suspicious of Hindutva's hidden agendas of undermining constitutional support in their future nation with majoritarian zeal. Even Muslims are not averse to the idea of reforming the religious laws as happened in many other Islamic countries. But the fear of Hindutva has practically stalled community-led internal reforms. While BJP heralds Triple Talaq Bill as a milestone in ensuring justice for Muslim women, the community was scornful of the act while the practice is increasingly condemned by the faithful. Making a civil act a criminal offense which invokes imprisonment, the community has serious reservation about the ulterior motives of the BJP in forcing changes in Muslim laws. Ghazala Wahab has discussed the dilemma among Muslims in supporting reforms pushed by BJP. Religious identities are calling shots on reform these days instead of caste loyalties. Muslim community should be encouraged to take internal reforms without State compulsion. Civil society, religious role and educated sections have to play bigger roles in reforming the Colonial era Muslim Personal Laws. But, imposition of State-led top-down approach will hurt the pace of internal reforms of Muslim community. Reforms should be the outcome of Community-led process. The State shall merely aid the reform and every effort to shove down changes ought to have adverse results. --- An occasional New Age Islam columnist, Grace Mubashir is a journalism student at Indian Institute of Mass Communication, Delhi URL: https://newageislam.com/islamic-society/indian-politics-legal-conservatism-muslims/d/126918 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism

Gujarat Temple Invites Muslims

By Mr Reaction Wala 10 April 2022 Some comments on the Video RAMESH VAIDYA It's really an Example for other Jokers like U.P. Now Randwa and his Party will become more active in creating division here as well.. KHAJA ZEESHAN UDDIN This looks our indian culture and prosperity, we are indian, Imran Ahmed Can't believe this happened in Gujarat😳 Yusuf Sonde May god bless these hindu brothers. Mohd Ayan This is the real sweetness of our secular country.......and they are real hindus not like an andhbhakts......when we can see this type of peoples we can proud to say i m an indian. irfan hasan thanks to all those who are involved and made it possible ...😘😘 Mohammed Areefuddin Well, that's a good start at destroying political agenda and progress towards making our country the GREATEST Shahriar Mistry This is my India,, and I m proud 2b an Indian. Hope dis video open d close eye lid of Andhbhakts wu fi8 in d name of religion everyday URL: https://newageislam.com/multimedia/gujarat-temple-muslims-/d/126915 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism

Eid-ul-Fitr Is An Occasion To Celebrate Humanity And Brotherhood

By Grace Mubashir, New Age Islam 2 May 2022 Eid - A Social Event To Cement Stout Human Bonds Of Love And Affinity Transcending Religious And Social Considerations Main Points: 1. Islam is a social religion which allows celebrations and festivities subject to refraining from the forbidden and encouraging virtues in society. 2. Not to forget Allah and steadfastly abide by his instructions are essential to divine understanding of Eid. 3. Fitr Zakat is a mere jurisprudential rendition of social responsibility to tend to the needs of people in need. ------ Muslims across the world celebrate Eid-ul-Fitr with a refurbished mind through month long fasting. Eid is a holy celebration to fasten the resolve to maintain the spiritual purity and impeccable faith gained through month long fasting from adulterations and contaminations. It is a social event to cement stout human bonds of love and affinity transcending religious and social considerations. Eid announces the auspicious culmination of month long fasting. Fasting is a crass reminder of hardships of hunger and asks the faithful not to forget the God in times of prosperity. Eid presents a happy occasion for celebration for the believers without indulging in carnal desires and satanic temptations. This is a ‘gift day’ for Muslims after enduring pangs of hunger during fasting to heed to the commands of divine instructions. Islam is a social religion which allows celebrations and festivities subject to refraining from the forbidden and encouraging virtues in society. Two Eid celebrations, viz. Eid-ul-Fitr and Ear-ul-Azha, are celebrated by Muslims every year across the world. Eid-ul-Fitr is observed at the end of fasting whereas Eid-ul-Azha is celebrated simultaneously to Haj Pilgrimage. The core messages of Eid celebrations are of happiness and divine remembrance. Eid celebration is associated with two important themes; divine and humane. Not to forget Allah and steadfastly abide by his instructions are essential to divine understanding of Eid. The celebration beginning with divine exaltations and special prayers has spiritual contents. It exhorts the faithful to submit themselves to divine pleasure and not to stomp the earth haughtily. The humane aspect of Eid adds glitter and wafts of scent to the celebration. It is an occasion for family unions, neighborhood visits, outings with family and visiting friends. The tradition of inviting all neighbors to the house to delicious feasts without religious considerations adds more happiness to the occasion. Non-Muslim friends and neighbors visiting my home for Eid celebrations was highly anticipated for in my childhood which is reciprocated during Onam and Vishu festivals by vising their respective homes. The virtuous liturgies of the day wrapped in spiritual sobriety prod the Muslim community to work for a brighter future in tandem with societal expectations. Prophet has religiously prohibited the faithful from fasting on this day. The message of Eid is that no one should be left with empty stomach wriggling with hunger. To ensure this, Islam calls for distribution of Fitr Zakat, (compulsory donation for financially eligible Muslims) prior to attending the Eid prayers. This charity donation ensures no one is bereft of food at this day and reminds the faithful of the eternal moral obligation to tend to the needs of the poor. Bringing home a destitute child found at a roadside, Prophet Muhammed offered him dress and food and said to his wife Ayesha; “today the happiness of this child completed our happiness”. This is the message of Eid to lend helping hands to those in distress. Fitr Zakat is a mere jurisprudential rendition of social responsibility to tend to the needs of people in need. Eid heralds the noble messages of unity and brotherhood. It entails messages of compassion, empathy and benevolence. It sends strong messages against violence and communal discord. It is a gentle reminder of love prevailing hatred. In practice, Eid is not an exclusive festival of Muslims alone, but it is a celebration of all who values affection and friendship. The festival should be used to weld together social relations. When the communal wedges are seeping dangerously deep inside into the time-tested social harmony, Eid should be an occasion to celebrate beauty of coexistence and religious pluralism. Gestures like inviting neighbors to join the Eid festivals, offering ‘Eid Thuhfa’ (token gifts) and sending social media greetings will definitely help bring people together and fight cynics and messengers of doom. Social interactions like on Eid will come a long way in foiling the bids to keep hate on simmer. ------ Grace Mubashir is a journalism student at IIMC, Delhi URL: https://newageislam.com/islamic-culture/eid-fitr-humanity-brotherhood/d/126919 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism

Sunday, May 1, 2022

Taj Mahal Or Tejo Mahalaya, A Shiv Temple? Get The Facts Straight

By Sumit Paul, New Age Islam 1 May 2022 A Seer From Ayodhya Has Called For A Prayer Session At The Taj Mahal On May 5 Alleging That The Monument Was The Tejo Mahalaya, A Shiv Temple Taj Mahal ----- A seer from Ayodhya has called for a prayer session at the Taj Mahal on May 5 alleging that the monument was the Tejomahalaya, a Shiv temple. Quoting Rana Safvi from Daily O, 24/10/2017, " When Mumtaz Mahal died and it was decided to bury her in Akbarabad, as Agra was known then, a search for the best place to build her mausoleum was undertaken. Her grieving husband had already decided to make her resting place a veritable paradise itself. A majestic and huge tomb was to be constructed. Since the structure would be very heavy, the architects took the decision to support it on large wooden slabs built over deep wells. This stabilised the sand and acted as augured piles. For this purpose, the position chosen was at a node in the River Yamuna, which seemed the most suitable. This plot of land belonged to Raja Man Singh, Akbar’s general who had marriage ties with the Mughals." Taj Mahal was built on the land where Raja Jai Singh had a mansion and there is no mention of any religious building on that land (courtesy, Taj Mahal: The Illumined Tomb by W E Begley and ZA Desai). Moreover, according to the rules, esp. the theological rules of Islam, a mausoleum cannot be built upon an already existing religious structure belonging to Islam or of any other faith. It's considered to be profane from Islamic religious perspective. P N Oak's theory that Tejo Mahalaya (a Hindu temple) was later renamed or rechristened as Taj Mahal by Shah Jahan or Mughals, doesn't hold water for Mughals spoke Persian, which's a highly evolved and exquisite tongue. Shahjahan had no dearth of 'new' names in Persian for his dream project. So, why on earth should he retain the old name Tejo Mahalaya with a slight change to make it Taj Mahal? Shahjahan had names like ' Khwabgaah', 'Hayaan' (archaic Persian word for something exquisite) and ' Shabistan' (a magnificent bed-chamber) for the grand mausoleum, but he zeroed in on Taj Mahal. One more myth about Taj Mahal is that Shah Jahan got the hands of the artisans chopped off after the completion of the splendid structure. This is a blatant lie. There were approximately 20, 000 workers who built the Taj Mahal. Some names are still known: Ustad Ahmad Lahori : Main architect Ismail Afandi, Ottoman Empire: Designer of the Main Dome Ustad Isa and Isa Muhammad Effendi, from Persia: Architectural Designer 'Puru' from Benarus, Persia: Supervisor Architect Qazim Khan, Lahore: Gilding Chiranjilal, Delhi: Chief Sculptor and Mosaicist Amanat Khan of Shiraz, Iran: Chief Calligrapher Muhammad Hanif: Mason Supervisor Mir Abdul Karim Khan and Mukkarimat of Shiraz: Financial Manager, Daily Production Records in Persian are available that all these people later participated in building the mosques and palaces in Esfahan (about which it's famous in Persian-Esfahan nesf-e jahan: Isfahan is half the world) and Khorasan in Iran and Central Asia. Scores of artisans who built Taj were also involved in building other monuments after Taj Mahal. Do you think they built those monuments sans their hands? It's time to accept the truth and refrain from vitiating the vibes of the country and envenoming the minds of the people . ---- An occasional columnist for New Age Islam, Sumit Paul is a researcher in comparative religions, with special reference to Islam. He has contributed articles to world's premier publications in several languages including Persian. URL: https://newageislam.com/interfaith-dialogue/taj-mahal-tejo-mahalaya-shiv-temple-/d/126908A New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism

A Crucial Message Of Eid-Ul-Fitr For Us Indian Muslims!

By Ghulam Rasool Dehlvi, New Age Islam 1 May 2022 The Institutionalisation Of Eid-Ul-Fitr Marks The Prophet’s Quest For Establishing Universal Brotherhood, Social Cohesion, National Integration, Cultural Festivity And Above All, Deep Humane Emotions For The Poor Main Points: 1. Eid-ul-Fitr returns every year to revitalize our faith in the universal values of brotherhood, social and cultural harmony, religious diversity and mutual respect, besides the spirit of charity. 2. Prophet (pbuh) cultivated a composite culture in his city of Madina, using the Arabic term “Ummah” in his Constitution, Misaq-e-Madina which encompassed all religious communities, races, and ethnic tribes. 3. For Indian Muslims, Eid-ul-Fitr is an open reminder that if they truly follow the peaceful Prophetic ideals in letter and spirit, they must act as an integral part of "One Nation", a multi-religious 'Ummah' in India bound by a Constitution which can be likened to Misaq-e-Madina in many respects. 4. This year, Eid-ul-Fitr arrives as an open reminder for us Muslims to incorporate the magnanimous social values of the holy Prophet (pbuh) into our practical life, if we really wish to survive and achieve glory in these trying times. ----- Few people know why Muslims’ first and foremost festival and the holiest occasion at the end of Ramadan—Eid-ul-Fitr—has been institutionalised in Islam. Persian Islamic scholar of Arab descent, Abu Dawud al-Sijistani who compiled one of the six canonical Prophetic Traditions, reports in his collection: [After the migration from Mecca] when Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) arrived at the city of Madinah, he felt the need for a feast that could imbibe peace, unity and charity for the poor. Thereafter, the Holy Prophet received the divine inspiration to announce that "Allah has granted two blessed Eids: Eid-ul-Fitr and Eid-ul-Adha ..." (Abu Dawud, "Salat", 245). According to this hadith, the origin and institutionalisation of Eid-ul-Fitr in Islam marks the Prophet’s quest for establishing peace and universal brotherhood, social cohesion, national integration, cultural festivity and above all, deep humane emotions for the poor. Etymologically, the Arabic-origin word 'Eid' implies 'something that returns every year', and 'Fitr', another Arabic word refers to acts of benevolence and charity for the less fortunate. Thus, Eid-ul-Fitr together denotes an occasion that comes every year to revitalize a humane spirit in us towards the weaker sections of our society. While it comes as the most sacred Islamic festival at the end of Ramadan, it also serves as a beautiful reminder of our common heritage of peace, unity and inclusivity. In essence, Eid-ul-Fitr returns every year to revitalize our faith in the universal values of brotherhood, social and cultural harmony, religious diversity and mutual respect, besides the spirit of charity. At a time when we, the people of India are in dire need of unity, inter-religious cooperation, national integration and social cohesiveness, the universal celebration of Eid-ul-Fitr seeks to bring us together in a spiritual synergy to preserve our shared local cultural heritage, which is India's inbuilt inclusivity, religious diversity and unity in multiplicity. In Madina, where the Holy Prophet (pbuh) started to celebrate Eid-ul-Fitr, there was a multi-religious society which comprised not just the holy Prophet's Companions i.e. Muslims but also Jews, Christians, pagans, polytheists, and even atheists. Significantly, the Holy Prophet (PBUH) celebrated this diversity and nurtured religious inclusivity and cohesiveness in his society through various initiatives including the Eid-ul-Fitr. An epoch-making and historic initiative to strengthen inclusiveness and national integration was the written constitution of Madina, known as Misaq-e-Madina. Going by this, Prophet Mohammad (pbuh) formed "One Nation" in Madina and termed it "Ummah" bound by the constitution which was written in 622 CE. Significantly enough for us Indian Muslims, Eid-ul-Fitr is an open reminder that if we truly follow the peaceful ideals of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) in letter and spirit, we must act as an integral part of "One Nation", and a multi-religious 'Ummah' bound by the Indian Constitution which is considered the best and the most democratic in the world, and which can be likened to the Misaq-e-Madina in many respects. For, the Constitution of Madina laid great emphasis on unity and integrity among all the tribes and members of the state albeit with their religious, doctrinal and cultural distinctions. In fact, the first clause of the Misaq-e-Madina as laid out by the Prophet (PBUH) himself, goes like this: "We are all one Ummah (nation or people)". Thus, the holy Prophet fostered a composite culture in the city of Madina, using the Arabic word “Ummah”, which actually encompasses all religious communities, races, ethnic tribes and social ranks, each with their own racial, cultural, national, religious or linguistic distinctions. The Prophet (pbuh) exhorted his followers to behave towards all of them as brothers and treat them as they want themselves to be treated. He inculcated noble humane values through the festival of Eid-ul-Fitr, with an aim to foster universal human brotherhood. Among those prophetic traditions relating to the Eid-ul-Fitr are greeting people time and again, shaking hands and hugging when meeting or parting, visiting and comforting the sick, offering condolences to the bereaved, and exchanging gifts with other members of the society, sharing happiness with all means possible. Such acts that strengthen sociability, inclusiveness, fraternity, brotherhood and charity are the hallmarks of Eid-ul-Fitr. Thus, Eid-ul-Fitr has been instituted in Islam to foster an inclusive social system that seeks to establish a humane, well-cultured and sympathetic society. In fact, Islam stresses the importance of social values through this most sacred festival, celebrating the spirit of peace, delight, kindness, compassion, brotherhood and equality among people of all traditions, castes, creeds and religions. This is the prime objective of celebrating Eid in Islam. However, it is also aimed at distributing charity to the poor, and hence its full name is Eid ul-Fitr. The word Fitr in Arabic or Fitra in Urdu means a form of charity from the rich to the poor to help them celebrate Eid with the fullest festive spirit. This is precisely why Islam has enjoined upon Muslims on this day to distribute fitrah (a fixed amount of charity mandatory for every Muslim) to the poor. Besides, Muslims are exhorted in the Prophetic traditions to hold delicious feasts and invite friends and neighbours from all faith communities on Eid. Obviously, such noble activities help us strengthen bonds of love, mutual harmony, human brotherhood, and social integrity. Most notably, Eid-ul-Fitr has appeared this year to rejuvenate the essential messages of the Holy Prophet (pbuh): love in place of hatred, patience in place of anger, forbearance in place of warfare, inclusivity in place of exclusivity and humility and not supremacy. These are the days when Muslims are living in a turbulent time characterized as the time of fitnah (tumult) in some of the Prophetic sayings (Ahadith). Therefore, they need to revive the inner spirit rather than the external form of Eid—which is to maintain sociability, good neighbourliness and care for the underprivileged, destitute and downtrodden people. This is the ultimate objective of Eid-ul-Fitr in Islam. Merely fasting during Ramadan and then feasting on delicious foods and wearing fancy dresses on Eid is not the ultimate purpose. This year, Eid-ul-Fitr arrives as an open reminder for us Muslims to incorporate the magnanimous social values of Islam in our practical life, if we really wish to survive and achieve glory in these trying times ----- Ghulam Rasool Dehlvi—regular columnist at NewAgeIslam.com—is an Alim and Fazil (Classical Islamic scholar) and a Delhi-based writer. Having graduated from a leading Islamic seminary in India, he is now pursuing his PhD at Jamia Millia Islamia University. Currently, he is also serving as Dean of the Faculty at an interfaith educational institution—Minhaj Learning & Research Centre (MLRC) in New Delhi. URL: https://newageislam.com/islam-spiritualism/message-of-eid-fitr-indian-muslims/d/126907 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism