By Arshad Alam, New Age Islam
31 January 2023
The Sira And Hadis Literature Have Shown To Be Fabricated, So How Do We Know About The Early Islamic Community
Main Points:
1. The extant Sira and Hadis were written down much after the death of the Prophet Muhammad.
2. Yet most of what we know about him and the early Islamic community comes through this literature as the Quran does not tell us much.
3. Scholars have shown this post-Quranic material to be contradictory and at times plain fabrications.
4. How then do we then reconstruct the historicity of the early Islamic community, including the career of Prophet Muhammad?
-------
The traditional Islamic narrative about Prophet Muhammad tells us in minute details about his birth, youth, his prophethood, his marriages and...